Trundle really doesn't seem like mafia to me and you haven't explained why you think he should be us risking a mislynch iirc. If he flips green, myself and others have plenty reason to be annoyed with you. Honestly I still think you're town but what you could be doing here could be detrimental.
Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
amanda1983
Senior Member
Ya I'm not ruling out voting No Lynch still but I think Trundle is absolutely Mafia and I'm really really struggling to see why leaving him alive is better than lynching him. He's been saying this stuff for how long now? It's just gonna be the same next day phase and we'll have enough to work through as it is with Karen's weird af role-claim (whatever that may be) in addition to so much I can't even keep track of it anymore.
If I had any doubt about Trundle NOT flipping scum, I'd switch to No Lynch in a heartbeat. There's no doubt, and unless he somehow provides it, I want him lynched.
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
Is this directed at me?
amanda1983
Senior Member
This. Please. We do not have the time for this rn.
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
@Dad - What gives you the Trundle TR?
i can?t. it?s not going to help and i cant say much more than that. if you think about it some more maybe you can deduce the role from what ive said.
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
I made a decision though. I don't want a no lynch (I don't like the idea of no lynch because it's a waste of a day. It's better to play with chances rather than do nothing imo like with inactives) and my opinion on Trundle is iffy (Refuses to claim though is suspicious, could save own butt) so I voted for myself in order to not get modkill. I currently don't have a stance and me voting for someone beside myself will have 0 reason behind it and probably completely random.
amanda1983
Senior Member
Wait glow are you kidding here ??
Yes.
- - - Post Merge - - -
He's not a complete townread but I've already explained some things regarding his tone and hit and miss with his reads, and pointed out glow's analysis as well which I agree with. The only reason I can't completely townread him is because Heyden's meta read also makes sense, but doesn't push me to want to sacrifice one of our two mislynches.
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
I want to vote this so bad.
He has this sort of vague cherrypicking agenda--if you go through the ISO it should be very clear what I mean--I'm not going to isolate specific posts but I still believe it to be true. That combined with, as I stated before, his low thread presence, makes me want to lynch him.
- - - Post Merge - - -
@Antonio - Let me clarify: in a time that townspeople need to take stances, you aren't taking one--why should I not believe it's indecisive scum keeping their options open?
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
trundle's been weird all game, and his casualness about the lynch when he's threatened to claim PR is just strange af. I don't see a better option other than Kammm, who's gonna get MK'd anyway
Also lol @ glow because Heyden unvoting and only leaving Karen with one vote makes your threat of your two votes useless now.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And glow if you authentically believe Trundle is town then you'd throw them on no lynch at this point.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And glow if you authentically believe Trundle is town then you'd throw them on no lynch at this point.
Just keep what I said in mind last minute ijs.
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
Fair enough I guess, though I find his later posting problematic...
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
If you have noticed my last posts, my scummies were only you and Vanessa. Both of my theories were squashed and ever since then, I can't come up with a solid scum about a user. If I do, it will be half assed.
You may say I have a stance similar to indecisive people voting no lynch but like I said, I would rather luck take it's course then do nothing at all. That's why I voted for myself instead of no lynch. I also voted so I won't be modkilled.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
if you're only voting to not get mk'd then vote nl and not yourself. Self voting makes you look incredibly scummy jsyk
And Antonio, voting for yourself is useless in this situation when there's stronger power in your vote in this very moment. And personally my no lynch vote isn't indecision, it's me voting no lynch because I wasn't able to convince enough people to vote what I believe to be the best choices this day.
Why are you trying to persuade him to no lynch rather than lynch Trundle? You seem pretty set on Trundle so this is odd.
