Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Antonio]

Anyways, what happened to fireninja1?

 

[iLoveYou]

I DO think scum tom would go this long because everyone keeps giving him a place to stay hidden in this game. He has every opportunity to hide in what you guys are saying " don't lynch inactives" & " Tom shouldnt be considered for a lynch if he doesn't post".

To Vanessa I cant quote on a mobile

 

[cornimer]

I DO think scum tom would go this long because everyone keeps giving him a place to stay hidden in this game. He has every opportunity to hide in what you guys are saying " don't lynch inactives" & " Tom shouldnt be considered for a lynch if he doesn't post".

To Vanessa I cant quote on a mobile

Fair enough

Also I just want to say nobody should doubt Dolby's blue sniping abilities, when he was scum in Caxnival he literally picked out EVERY SINGLE BLUE by the end of the day 1 or beginning of day 2 (he listed them in the quicktopic) including me even though it was my first game and I was posting trash

 

[cornimer]

I DO think scum tom would go this long because everyone keeps giving him a place to stay hidden in this game. He has every opportunity to hide in what you guys are saying " don't lynch inactives" & " Tom shouldnt be considered for a lynch if he doesn't post".

To Vanessa I cant quote on a mobile

Fair enough

Also I just want to say nobody should doubt Dolby's blue sniping abilities, when he was scum in Caxnival he literally picked out EVERY SINGLE BLUE by the end of the day 1 or beginning of day 2 (he listed them in the quicktopic) including me even though it was my first game and I was posting trash

 

[illunie]

Why would they want to risk leaving a potential blue for next Day's lynch, to interfere with their plans at night One ? A potential blue is always a threat to mafia and I don't know why they would waste a hit on Kate who also looked very suspicious and could have equally been a lynch target today. They are all equally quiet -> Tom, Kate & Oath. Why take out two but not Tom ? Think about it, they didnt know Toad was a detective right ? They assumed he was blue and luckily got a detective which means no alignments went through that night from Toad's investigation. Why would they take the chance on Tom who could have also been a detective as equally as Toad for next day lynch ?

Assuming Tom was a potential blue, why would they allow him to live a night to be able to gain reads ?? If he is how come he isnt providing reads ??

The fact that they went after a quiet Oah but not a quiet Tom is not sitting right with me. I'm sorry.

- - - Post Merge - - -

& forget it .. a quiet Kate over a quiet Tom. No way.

ok, how about this then
mafia read tom as blue and tried to kill him but they were stopped by smth
oath shot kate as his own scumread but it turned out to be wrong

all up, mafia sent in the kills for oath, tom and toad, having gotten a blue read on all three
hows that? it explains every argument youve made

they didnt take out tom bc they were unable to
they didnt kill kate, oath did

this honestly explains everything thats happened in this game, and bc of that i want a dolby lynch tonight. if he does flip scum, i think this games gonna begin to unravel fast. probably gonna make a smaller iso on him later to support my read

 

[illunie]

i dont really wanna say more and endanger tom, but i think its probably ok to put everything out if the mafia team knows as much as i think they do

 

[iLoveYou]

My question stands:

Tom what are your reads on people this game ? Can you provide any thoughts or insight or anything ?

 

[cornimer]

this honestly explains everything thats happened in this game, and bc of that i want a dolby lynch tonight. if he does flip scum, i think this games gonna begin to unravel fast. probably gonna make a smaller iso on him later to support my read

Music to my ears

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dolby or Antonio I'm fine with either

 

[Kamzitty]

Jeez I'm trying to read the last few pages and they're making my head spin :') so much new info and different suspicions.. I have to head to bed now, but I'll catch up tomorrow morning. If anybody wants me to reconsider my ryumia vote please let me know, for now I still think she could def be scum but since the dedenne lunch I've been doubting myself, so ofc I'm open to hear opinions from the more experienced players! Goodnight everybody (also welcome to the game vampnessa!)

 

[N e s s]

What the hell......if tom were hit he would admit it right now, that doesn't explain anything

 

[illunie]

What the hell......if tom were hit he would admit it right now, that doesn't explain anything

gonna wait for him to post before i speculate on that, but ive thought about it

 

[cornimer]

Jeez I'm trying to read the last few pages and they're making my head spin :') so much new info and different suspicions.. I have to head to bed now, but I'll catch up tomorrow morning. If anybody wants me to reconsider my ryumia vote please let me know, for now I still think she could def be scum but since the dedenne lunch I've been doubting myself, so ofc I'm open to hear opinions from the more experienced players! Goodnight everybody (also welcome to the game vampnessa!)

Hello, I think you should reconsider, if you read through Ryumia's post filter in the Wrath of the Egyptian Gods Kingmaker game she said the exact same things that she is saying this game. And she was town in that game

 

[Heyden]

Am I a sheep if I say I wouldn't mind lynching Dolby as well.

 

[Ghostkid]

All of this is happining too fast @_@

 

[cornimer]

Am I a sheep if I say I wouldn't mind lynching Dolby as well.

No you're a smart person

 

[Kamzitty]

Hello, I think you should reconsider, if you read through Ryumia's post filter in the Wrath of the Egyptian Gods Kingmaker game she said the exact same things that she is saying this game. And she was town in that game

I'll definitely check those out tomorrow! However I don't believe that just because someone acted a certain way in one game when they were town,means they're definitely still town if they act the same way again.. (if that made sense) it's still definitely something I'll look into. Thank you!

 

[iLoveYou]

Dolby we need to hear from you as equally as we do from Tom.

 

[illunie]

Dolby we need to hear from you as equally as we do from Tom.

oooo the flop onto sussing dolby, me likey

 

[Ghostkid]

Wait what happened to trundle? I havnt seen him in a while...

 

[cornimer]

Dolby lynch hype train go go go