Aww... Jacob.
I did put you as town on my read list, so I am glad that you really were town in the end.Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
I did put you as town on my read list, so I am glad that you really were town in the end.
ok, so apparently since noone else, not even punchy, is willing to defend him, i guess its on me to try and make a case for him. rn im thinking theres about a 60 percent chance of punchy being town, not great ik but its a start.
im pretty sure that this proves that his role is at least real and not a fakeclaim or smth he made up, bc:
1. the flavour text is consisntent with the rest of it in the game
2. the writing style is consistent with tina's ('the lighthouse closes, and ghosts will haunt the island')
3. the flavour text is consistent with his role, as a lighthouse keeper would probably be paranoid enough to be a vet
4. the flavour text is too complex for it to be a fakeclaim, and im not sure enough about the writing abilities of the scumteam to call it a fake with any certainty
this should definitely prove that it is at least a real role, but it doesnt necessarily prove that its a town related role. for that, i think we should point to the name of the role and cross-reference it to toms name. remember that tom's role flavour is a supernatural creature? now look at punchys role, where it says that upon his death, ghosts would be released on the town due to his relationship with a lover. this seems to suggest that the lighthouse keeper is keeping the ghosts away from the town, and that if the ghosts were released it would hurt the town and benefit the ghosts. seeing as tom was a supernatural creature, i think its safe to say the town is normal ppl and that maf are the ghosts and monsters, which would mean that his characther is against the maf.
the only counterargument that i can think of is that he used a fakeclaim and combined it with his own story written to be like tina, to which i would say that he would probably be more likely to just use his own role pm instead of smth original, and the flavour is too anti ghosts (and therefore anti mafia) to be coming from a mafia alligned role
ikik im just analyising his flavour text of all things, but i still feel like it has merit as an argument. if im still alive after night ends ill try and do an iso on him to see how his actions hold up
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
Personally I think they killed Dolby to try to frame me since he sussed me the most so it would look like I want to get rid of him
It's very likely that Jacob and Dolby were on to something and the mafia felt the need to silence them.
theres no reason for dolby not to take a shot at him tbh, maybe thats how he was killed?
Wait actually, they could have been Night Two kills to make sure no doctor was protecting them ( assuming they would be protected Night One ).
- - - Post Merge - - -
But wouldn't Punchy die too ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
But wouldn't Punchy die too ?
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
I feel like Dolby would know that shooting him might kill him, what with Punchy being a bomb or something
Also if he actually has a vest then Dolby would know his shot is wasted
i cant remember exactly how vet works, either they get an extra nightlife or they kill ppl who visit or both, im waiting for punchy to answer it tbh
- - - Post Merge - - -
he said that he didnt believe the role was real tho, so maybe he thought that punchy was a bluffing maf or smth
Disagree, Dolby specifically stated earlier that he thought that Punchy's vest thing was a hoax in an attempt to dissuade any remaining killing roles in the game. That, and I feel like it would have to be either a vig shot or some other 3rd party role since we lost a mafia yesterday. Assuming this is five mafia 3 KP, then losing Tom would set them back to 2 KP.
amanda1983
Senior Member
This doesn't make sense to me. In the first place I'm not sure why Dolby would think this is the best use of his shot, given Punchy was already up for today's lynch.
But secondly.. where's the other kill/s?? Only two people died. Seems odd to assume one of the two that died actually did so from a different mechanic in the circumstances..
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
That's possible tbh
what
why are you assuming there was only 1 mafia kill, there are 3 supposed kills at night
amanda1983
Senior Member
Wait, so Punchy might have actually been hit? I read that as pretty clearly false giving the timing and circumstances.
