can't make a decision.

[sigh]

so recently, i moved out raymond to bring fang back into my island because i missed him dearly - i was either going to move out raymond or pashmina, i chose raymond to leave because of a vote. i'm happy with this decision as i love fang, and i plan to keep him forever with most of my villagers. now, i have pashmina on my island who i like (and was a dreamie), but the thing is, i'm not very attached to her and considering moving her out for someone else. but i'm also not sure if i'd rather have another sisterly villager (like muffy) in her place, or another double of a different personality. i prefer to have one of each personality around at all times, however there are obviously villagers (especially of other personalities) that i would rather have over pashmina. for reference, i already have at least one of each personality, which 2 are snootys (diana and judy, who are NEVER leaving) and now two crankys (chief and fang, who are also NEVER leaving).

tldr: help me by voting on my poll!

 

[maria110]

Did you earn Pashmina's photo yet? I think you should wait until you get her photo and then decide whether to let her go. Also, do you have all the reactions and recipes from sisterly villagers yet? You might want to keep at least one sisterly until then.

I had Pashmina on my island and I liked her a lot but I did let her move once I got her photo. I've had several sisterly villagers. Now I have Muffy and Reneigh and I like them both a lot.

You could also consider which sisterly matches your island theme best or whose house looks nicest.

 

[Fye]

I love Pashmina, especially now that she has the singing hobby which few of my villagers have. But if you want to replace her then I say go for it - there are so many villagers out there that keeping one that you don't love feels like a waste. But I'd recommend switching her for another sisterly so that you will still have one of each personality type and can have more unique dialogue. And there are quite a few great sisterlys - Deirdre, Fuchsia, and Tammy are a few of my favorites. Good luck!

 

[moonchu]

i second what maria110 has said. also funny because fang is my favourite villager <3
once i got agnes' photo and all of the reactions, i've not had an uchi/sisterly personality since - but i have at least one of each of the others.

 

[Rika092]

Hmm personally I like to have at least one personality each on my island, so I voted to have another uchi villager instead. There are so many villagers though so if you wanted to have someone new then just go for it. If you tried another uchi and just decided they are not for you, you could always kick them out after gathering all reactions, and then just invite a different personality of your choice as a permanent dreamie instead.

 

[Livia]

You should let her go and look for a sisterly villager, but only after you get her photo and celebrate her birthday which is coming up in a couple days.

 

[sigh]

thank you all for voting and responding! currently, i'm highly considering keeping pashmina at least until i'm able to get her photo, because i do like her! unfortunately i don't think i'm high enough friendship level with her yet to receive it - based on experience i'm best friends (highest level) with zucker, diana and bonbon and i have yet to receive any of their pictures.

honestly i do think it's a good idea to get pashmina's photo before i move her out, as i kinda wish i got raymond's photo before i moved him out. so thanks everyone! i think i'll have her stay for now, but once i get her photo, move her out for another sisterly villager (preferably bc i like at least one of each personality at a time) or even another villager i like in general. i do wanna give her something nice for her birthday too!!! she really is a great villager and i've enjoyed having her around

 

[JKDOS]

I voted option 2. If you're not happy with Pashmina, you should give another villager of your choosing a try. I've learned all the emotions from each personality, and you can get the locked DIYs from campers and bottled messages, so I stopped keeping 1 of each type. My island now has no Smug and no Uchi at this time.

 

[sigh]

okay so, i know this is late, but i've been thinking about what to do. i have decided to keep pashmina until she gives me her photo, and after that moving her out for another cute villager like roald, BUT, i'm also considering letting random villagers move in so i can collect their posters, and eventually move in a 10th permanent villager. not sure who that 10th would be yet.

but as for multiple personality types: i've actually had quite various interactions with multiple personalities. i have 2 snootys, and they give me different dialogues (usually) and same with the crankys, and it's even more interesting when they interact with each other. like when i had both marshal and raymond they got along quite well to the point where raymond adopted "sulky" as his catchphrase and the two of them chatted about something only two smugs would

 

[DarkSlayer1331]

okay so, i know this is late, but i've been thinking about what to do. i have decided to keep pashmina until she gives me her photo, and after that moving her out for another cute villager like roald, BUT, i'm also considering letting random villagers move in so i can collect their posters, and eventually move in a 10th permanent villager. not sure who that 10th would be yet.

but as for multiple personality types: i've actually had quite various interactions with multiple personalities. i have 2 snootys, and they give me different dialogues (usually) and same with the crankys, and it's even more interesting when they interact with each other. like when i had both marshal and raymond they got along quite well to the point where raymond adopted "sulky" as his catchphrase and the two of them chatted about something only two smugs would

Just remember, if that 10th villager is the only spot that you're willing to rotate, you'll never be able to do it randomly. Because the 10th villager will NEVER naturally ask you to move out. The only ways to get them to move out is to use the campsite. Either an amiibo, or a random campsite villager. And then with the campsite villager you have to do all that work of playing games to get them to want to move in, and then hoping that they pick the 10th villager as the one to move out. You'll have to keep resetting the game until they finally do pick the 10th one.

 

[RedPanda]

I love Pashmina - as others have said she has the singing hobby, which is the best hobby in my opinion. She also looks really cute in hats. Many of the villagers look weird in hats but goats look adorable!

 

[moo_nieu]

i think you should hold on to her until you really want her out. if you're unsure, i'd say just wait. either you'll be happy to continue to see her, or you'll start thinking you wished she was some other villager and you'll have an answer. if you want to decide now, i'd say flip a coin or use a random number generator to pick from your replacement villager options. If you don't like what the rng decides, then at least you know how you feel a bit more