Tessa trusted dolby to be town. Shout out to tessa in the graveyard - I'm following this lead. If dan/dolby are wolfy, I blame tessa, lol...
So. I know it ain't me. That leaves me to vote frosty or kiko...
Theoretically- if it's 1 maf, we still have 1 chance for miselim, and it wouldn't matter which I vote first. If it's 2, theyd have to be the team, and it wouldn't matter which I vote.
So I would have to vote either frosty or kiko. But that's from my perspective, knowing I'm town, and trusting dolby.
i find it a little off putting that betsy mentions the possibility of us being teamed twice, but still trusts dolby and doesn’t consider either of us for vote really. comes off as an empty tinfoil
Oooh, okay. Then I won't ask about it anymore because it sounds like you can't mention why. Aka just still be suspicious about him but no need to rush votes on him.
Right now my main suspicion is on Kiko. But I'm a little confused about what I just quoted you about so whenever you can check in Kiko?
i find it a little off putting that betsy mentions the possibility of us being teamed twice, but still trusts dolby and doesn’t consider either of us for vote really. comes off as an empty tinfoil
I've tried rewriting this like 5 times but I feel like anything I would say would be guilting you away from assuming me as mafia Betsy, so all I'm going to say about my silence yesterday is I was overwhelmed by the pace and I can't defend beyond that right now. And I will elaborate on it after the game is done (or we both are hanging out in the graveyard).
I've tried rewriting this like 5 times but I feel like anything I would say would be guilting you away from assuming me as mafia Betsy, so all I'm going to say about my silence yesterday is I was overwhelmed by the pace and I can't defend beyond that right now. And I will elaborate on it after the game is done (or we both are hanging out in the graveyard).
I'm usually pretty lost trying to figure it all out anyway. I do appreciate when people make the effort to clear themselves though. I view that as more town behavior than not. With my current reads, I'd be more likely to vote kiko first, as of now.
But otherwise, I am really assuming this is a 1 maf game too (if it isn't man this is going to be super hard to win).
Right now I feel I trust Dolby as town the most. I was hoping for more of a direct confirmation with the item he used that it was a town benefit, but we aren't going to get it. But my reason for believing he was mafia was wholly dependent on a 2 mafia game. So if we hit mafia tonight and it isn't game over, I think I would go back to suspecting you, but right now I'm trusting you.
I'm also going to lean more on trusting Dan because of whatever the item told Dolby. I don't see this as a big brain play that they are teamed because Dolby was really wanting Dan out yesterday, so I don't see the connection between them, but I will look back for hints I may have missed.
Kiko is my main mafia read today, I felt really uneasy about him yesterday, the chaotic persona really had me questioning what side he was. But I feel more clear that he could be mafia. I don't really like that he said nothing about Tessa's last minute vote switch. Even if she did role town he didn't say anything about it at all when he was talking a lot about wanting to read last minute vote changes. I just feel like since the vote change worked in his favour he didn't want to press it, and that makes me suspicious. I'd really like to hear your thoughts about it Kiko.
Betsy, if it's a one person game I don't fully town read you anymore. But more of an, I'm weary of but I don't suspect nearly as much as Kiko so I will be cautious, but like same cautious as I am about Dan.
I'm usually pretty lost trying to figure it all out anyway. I do appreciate when people make the effort to clear themselves though. I view that as more town behavior than not. With my current reads, I'd be more likely to vote kiko first, as of now.
Same hat. I was NOT prepared for the full page in ten minutes rush, and by the time it slowed down I was just like....what? Next game I will be sitting in as an observer.
Right now I feel I trust Dolby as town the most. I was hoping for more of a direct confirmation with the item he used that it was a town benefit, but we aren't going to get it. But my reason for believing he was mafia was wholly dependent on a 2 mafia game. So if we hit mafia tonight and it isn't game over, I think I would go back to suspecting you, but right now I'm trusting you.
I think if it's a 1 person mafia, I agree it wouldn't be dolby.
I understand not trusting anybody, lol. I'm gonna work to clear myself today. So definitely question and theorize today. I may be offline at times, but I'll come back to check on things here.
Betsy, if it's a one person game I don't fully town read you anymore. But more of an, I'm weary of but I don't suspect nearly as much as Kiko so I will be cautious, but like same cautious as I am about Dan
Same hat. I was NOT prepared for the full page in ten minutes rush, and by the time it slowed down I was just like....what? Next game I will be sitting in as an observer.
You blessed me with words of wisdom and I will take it to the grave.
Post automatically merged:
Yeah. If we never sus the betrayal would be so much worse. I don't have a strong reason to suspect you, but it's pretty much the flip of Dolby, where he was in a 2 maf team, I trusted you because I didn't think you were big brain playing with the fake claim that a mafia partner never contacted you. It would make sense that no one did if you were a solo maf though.
I mean, it wouldn't be mafia if we didn't suspect everyone, that's the fun.
Post automatically merged:
Have a good night!
I'll be around a bit longer while I'm working if anyone else is, but seems like the activity will start up tomorrow.
Woke up to a couple thoughts today and wanted to leave them here before I'll be out for a while.
I don't think I'm really comfortable with the item going to dolby for the second night in a row. I think it puts the whole game on one person, which isn't a great town play, either trusting one person that much or having all the possible town advantages/information placed on just one person.
I'm still thinking it over, though, so if there's some advantage it would give, let me know what I'm missing? But as of now I just see possible disadvantages.
This feels like putting a target on me for some reason. So I think I'd like to hear how your read on me evolved from a strong tr to a sudden flip. If you still think I'm town but are just painting a target - don't. That's not a smart town play.
Ok - officially tossing my hat in the ring for the power/item vote.
I think we need to spread out the advantages today. If at this point in time dolby and/or dan have some access to info, it doesn't make sense to keep it concentrated with just those 2. Dolby and dan are my strongest tr now, but it is unconfirmed.I think we need a 3rd town to to have the item, giving us 3 who will have advantages d3 in case the game doesn't end tonight.
Fmp- I'm my only confirmed town, so I'm voting myself for the item. I will not vote dolby or dan for elim today (barring any crazy, unforeseen changes).
Where's kiko? That's my most likely elim vote atm, so they need to come work some defense if they're actually town...
not sure if that kill was meant to throw us off the scent or was an earnest kill
if earnest, frosty is my prime suspect rn
hopefully the things between the lines can be read, will not play chaotically today
Post automatically merged:
Hopefully this is enough for people, but: I truly am playing this game pretty similarly to baby park. If anything, I just turned my acting up a bit more for the fun of it.
Everything I've done and asked for so far was to help the townies. Consider in what scenarios that could be the case
Post automatically merged:
I am still weary about Dan though, I feel like he's just playing under the radar and letting me take all the maf hear
Post automatically merged:
heat*
Post automatically merged:
I doubt I'll get it, but I'd like to campaign for the item tonight
I haven't ran the scenarios yet so am not sure if it's an insta win in the case I'm the mafia yet, but do think me having the item is necessary to turn the tide for the town, if the item can give us information.
If I get the item and don't end up dying, y'all can vote to elim me the next day
not sure if that kill was meant to throw us off the scent or was an earnest kill
if earnest, frosty is my prime suspect rn
hopefully the things between the lines can be read, will not play chaotically today
Post automatically merged:
Hopefully this is enough for people, but: I truly am playing this game pretty similarly to baby park. If anything, I just turned my acting up a bit more for the fun of it.
Everything I've done and asked for so far was to help the townies. Consider in what scenarios that could be the case
Post automatically merged:
I am still weary about Dan though, I feel like he's just playing under the radar and letting me take all the maf hear
Post automatically merged:
heat*
Post automatically merged:
I doubt I'll get it, but I'd like to campaign for the item tonight
I haven't ran the scenarios yet so am not sure if it's an insta win in the case I'm the mafia yet, but do think me having the item is necessary to turn the tide for the town, if the item can give us information.
If I get the item and don't end up dying, y'all can vote to elim me the next day
ngl with you I'm also slightly maf-reading but I can't just maf read anyone
my thing with you is you've given no real info about yourself either directly or implicitly via gameplay that could help the townies.
After both townies dying having roles, I'm hard-pressed to believe that playing a game which alludes to no-role is truly what you'd think is best for the town
I'm more surprised by the implications of her death if that makes sense, what that means for existing powers and what the mafia believes atm
Post automatically merged:
If I was mafia, and if there was only one of me, I would not have targeted her and risked wasting a kill after being basically the only heal-target in the case there's a medic in the game.
mafia either didn't take that into account (why I'd believe it's frosty (just cuz it's your first game)) or made the bet there just isn't a medic at all, or knew that them killing tessa would put heat on frosty after following that logic (assuming now that they do think there's a medic in this game and the maf thought that the medic was also thinking the mafia wouldn't risk wasting a kill on the most obvious heal target so went for the most obv one thinking that the medic would take a chance on healing someone else at risk instead of who they thought the maf wouldn't go for)
princess bride stuff
Post automatically merged:
but now tessa died and idk if we have that role on our side at all or jow far that decision rabbit hole actually went
ngl with you I'm also slightly maf-reading but I can't just maf read anyone
my thing with you is you've given no real info about yourself either directly or implicitly via gameplay that could help the townies.
After both townies dying having roles, I'm hard-pressed to believe that playing a game which alludes to no-role is truly what you'd think is best for the town
I try to play using a strategy of finding town, because everyone is always sus. I was a bit frustrated dolby couldn't talk about the item, but with both he and dan coming back with stronger tr on each other, I think they benefited from items/roles, so I do tr them currently. Unless they are devious, bold masterminds, lol.
In the beginning, I did play more neutrally, but as I get more insight (hopefully correct) through the day I hope to be more helpful. While it does seem like everyone has roles of some sort, it also seems like some roles could be risky, like raven's, for example.
I don't think I'm the only one not claiming a strong pr, I don't think you or frosty have either. I'm also a little uncomfortable with that comment, as it seems a bit like role fishing, no offense.
If I was mafia, and if there was only one of me, I would not have targeted her and risked wasting a kill after being basically the only heal-target in the case there's a medic in the game.
