collectible tier list ★ (now closed)

[EpicGamer12]

rad feather

[moving up]: i do agree that it probably should be placed a bit higher but i don't believe it's particularly sought after, recent sales (correct me if i'm wrong) from jacob to trundle are at 2.5k which is where it's at in the tier list, will move it up slightly

I believe the sale was actually 3.2k TBT Bells, so yeah it's in the correct spot in the list from the 3k-6k range.

 

[mogyay]

I believe the sale was actually 3.2k TBT Bells, so yeah it's in the correct spot in the list from the 3k-6k range.

ahh thanks for letting me know trundle glad i moved it up then, it could probably go above the clover tbh but i'll wait until all of the clover hype dies down to decide that

 

[Biancasbotique]

i think you should move the sweet feather to tier 10 so i can afford one


please? lol

 

[Moonfish]

i think you should move the sweet feather to tier 10 so i can afford one


please? lol

That’s not how it works lol.

 

[toadsworthy]

i bought my party popper for 9k? and i think thats the most recent one.... idk if i would pay 10k and if anyone could get that for it nowadays

 

[lizardon]

Just realized I have 6 pieces of Tier 1

 

[Lancelot]

i bought my party popper for 9k? and i think thats the most recent one.... idk if i would pay 10k and if anyone could get that for it nowadays

I'd out it at the bottom of tier one under the yellow house, cause this isnt a price guide really. Not really about how much they sell for

 

[cornimer]

i bought my party popper for 9k? and i think thats the most recent one.... idk if i would pay 10k and if anyone could get that for it nowadays

I got mine a couple weeks ago for a disco egg + leaf ticket egg + regular easter egg + chocolate cake + 1.3ktbt. Idek what monetary value that ends up being but I think the bottom of tier 1 is a good place for it because it's still rare, desirable, and fairly expensive.

 

[Heyden]

I traded my final boss feather for a party popper, then that popper for a star wand, so I’d say the party popper is definitely a stable Tier 1.

 

[Bcat]

....I question the sweet feather. All the sales in the spreadsheet are around 5k. Though I guess it's there because it's so rarely sold.

- - - Post Merge - - -

and popsicles for 1.5k??? dude I see those go for 500-750

 

[cornimer]

....I question the sweet feather. All the sales in the spreadsheet are around 5k. Though I guess it's there because it's so rarely sold.

- - - Post Merge - - -

and popsicles for 1.5k??? dude I see those go for 500-750

Sweet feathers definitely deserve to be tier 1, I traded a yellow house and pink feather for mine (I was a bit desperate but like that just shows how unwilling most people are to give them up)

5k may have been accurate around the time of the fair when there were more in circulation but nobody is selling/trading them anymore

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Sweet feathers definitely deserve to be tier 1, I traded a yellow house and pink feather for mine (I was a bit desperate but like that just shows how unwilling most people are to give them up)

5k may have been accurate around the time of the fair when there were more in circulation but nobody is selling/trading them anymore

I still feel kinda bad about that trade...I know it wasn't really equal

 

[cornimer]

I still feel kinda bad about that trade...I know it wasn't really equal

It's ok I care more about how much I personally value the collectibles than the trade being equal according to guide values. Like I traded my star wand for a yoshi egg back in 2016 lmao. I think I'm the only person who has been able to acquire a sweet feather in recent times so it's still a success for me
Actually nvm I think toads got one like last week but before that I was the only person

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

It's ok I care more about how much I personally value the collectibles than the trade being equal according to guide values. Like I traded my star wand for a yoshi egg back in 2016 lmao. I think I'm the only person who has been able to acquire a sweet feather in recent times so it's still a success for me
Actually nvm I think toads got one like last week but before that I was the only person

Well I'm glad you don't feel ripped off. That Sweet Feather was my most prized collectible before I traded it off, so it's great you're getting just as much enjoyment out of it as I did. c:

 

[digimon]

and popsicles for 1.5k??? dude I see those go for 500-750

i think i bought mine for 1.1k (or maybe 1k, i gotta double check) and i feel like i’ve seen one being sold for 1k recently

edit: double checked and i got mine for 1.1k c:

 

[moonbyu]

thanks for this!

 

[Bcat]

I guess I’m just out of touch with the collectibles market then bc dang

 

[lizardon]

Well, I haven't collected collectables for over 2 years I think, so I didn't work on any new ones for long time.. Anyways, i will just keep my old ones..

 

[LambdaDelta]

Just realized I have 6 pieces of Tier 1

seeing your lineup, is that 6 different or 6 total?

I'm guessing the latter, but maybe you just *really* want to show off that double pinwheel while keeping it all to one line

 

[lizardon]

seeing your lineup, is that 6 different or 6 total?

I'm guessing the latter, but maybe you just *really* want to show off that double pinwheel while keeping it all to one line

6 total..
That letter? Well, that was the first one I was working hard to get