collectible tier list ★ (now closed)

Status
Not open for further replies.
i'm thinking of moving the star wand tbh, IS IT BECAUSE I HAVE TWO AND I WANNA FEEL IMPORTANT? probably. but black and boss feathers just don't really seem like they're particularly sought after and i've seen so many wand sales recently!!!
 
i'm thinking of moving the star wand tbh, IS IT BECAUSE I HAVE TWO AND I WANNA FEEL IMPORTANT? probably. but black and boss feathers just don't really seem like they're particularly sought after and i've seen so many wand sales recently!!!

tbh, the final boss feather's price feels like far more an indication of availability than desirability
 
Last edited:
tbh, the final boss feather's price feels like far more an indication of availability than desirability

very true, but then surely sellers would be willing to sell for less in this climate, every feather has seen a reduction in price except those ones, i think the true price of it now is probably a lot less than we think BUT in saying that i have no idea bc there's not a lot of sales, i was just remarking about moving wands bc there's been so many threads lately and the tier list ain't really all about the price. i'll keep it for now though, interesting to hear what other ppl think tho

- - - Post Merge - - -

tbh, the final boss feather's price feels like far more an indication of availability than desirability

wow i totally read ur comment wrong the first time i'm sorry! ye i 100% agree with u, idk if that means i should move it up or not tho : ( like does the rarity outweigh the popularity u kno
 
It's ok I care more about how much I personally value the collectibles than the trade being equal according to guide values. Like I traded my star wand for a yoshi egg back in 2016 lmao. I think I'm the only person who has been able to acquire a sweet feather in recent times so it's still a success for me
Actually nvm I think toads got one like last week but before that I was the only person

beech i acquired a sweet feather none too long ago
 
So.. Should we add the Spring Sakura's somewhere? :)

we should, i was thinking until all were in circulation though and they were removed from the shop until we have a clear idea of worth, what do you think? :) i'm happy to put it in now too though!
 
Last edited:
Bumping this to the front

we should, i was thinking until all were in circulation though and they were removed from the shop until we have a clear idea of worth, what do you think? :) i'm happy to put it in now too though!

I also think you should hold out on putting it in a tier, so people don’t lose out if their values increase/decrease dramatically. Especially with Easter coming, maybe there should be a new ‘tier’ of unvalued collectibles before we can place them anywhere else?
 
Bumping this to the front



I also think you should hold out on putting it in a tier, so people don’t lose out if their values increase/decrease dramatically. Especially with Easter coming, maybe there should be a new ‘tier’ of unvalued collectibles before we can place them anywhere else?

roger that, as soon as the eggs are released i'll make the new tier :) i don't want the sakura to feel too lonely
 
roger that, as soon as the eggs are released i'll make the new tier :) i don't want the sakura to feel too lonely

Just an idea to add alongside this New Tier, could we possibly make it so that all new collectibles released have to be in the tier for a complete month or 2 before being added to a designated tier so the market has more of a say in how they get classified? By doing this approach, I also think it will reduce the likelihood of the collectible getting moved in the future since it would have been classified through an ample amount of information. o/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top