-
Threads in this board should only be bumped once every four or more hours. Animal Crossing trading belongs in Nook's Cranny and other boards located here, even when using TBT Bells.
collectible tier list ★ (now closed)
- Thread starter mogyay
- Start date
- Status
togepixels
☆ﾟ.*･｡ dnd queen ☆
what's the difference between the cake and the tasty cake? i haven't been on in yonks and have just realised that i have cake but not tasty cake - is the regular one not available any more? x
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
toadsworthy's Creature:
yes, the one in your lineup is not available any more.... termed a "stale cake" for this reason.... the tasty cakes are the one slice of cake now
MasterM64
🍀 Mayor of PARADISE 🍀
The difference between them is just the look and one is more common than the other. Tasty Cakes replaced Cakes in the shop and Cakes are now discontinued/retired!
Hope that answers your question! o/
togepixels
☆ﾟ.*･｡ dnd queen ☆
The difference between them is just the look and one is more common than the other. Tasty Cakes replaced Cakes in the shop and Cakes are now discontinued/retired!
stale cake?? that's so sad oh no!!
but tysm for your help!! i'll hold onto him, he's an old boy x
mogyay
✨night night✨
helloooo, going to update this later today!
what are everyone's thoughts? seems as though dreamy has a bit of an edge on nightmare looking at the trades/sales thus far, also not sure where i'll put the zipper collectible yet but happy to hear what everyone thinks! : )
what are everyone's thoughts? seems as though dreamy has a bit of an edge on nightmare looking at the trades/sales thus far, also not sure where i'll put the zipper collectible yet but happy to hear what everyone thinks! : )
Last edited:
Miharu
Team Popsicle <3
Miharu's Creature:
Yeah I think dreamy egg also has an edge vs nightmare since it's in high demand. I'll think the nightmare may become worth more in the future though since both eggs are pretty popular and gorgeous! :3 As for the zipper I'll price around 150-200tbt!
MasterM64
🍀 Mayor of PARADISE 🍀
Hey Mogyay, in your opinion, do you think these should be in a New Tier for a month or so before promoting collectibles to actual tiers? When it comes to my input (especially about the Zipper Sakuras), my thoughts are below!
Thinking the order of desirability of the new Easter collectibles it definitely is in the following order from what I can tell (highest to lowest):
Dreamy -> Nightmare -> Pastel Disco -> Zipper Sakura -> Ditto -> Red Pikmin
When it comes to actual rarity (in terms of supply numbers), it is the following:
Red Pikmin -> Pastel Disco -> Nightmare -> Dreamy -> Ditto -> Zipper Sakura
What does everyone think of this conclusion?
Last edited:
Miharu
Team Popsicle <3
Miharu's Creature:
Hey Mogyay, in your opinion, do you think these should be in a New Tier for a month or so before promoting collectibles to actual tiers? When it comes to my input (especially about the Zipper Sakuras), my thoughts are below!
Thinking the order of desirability of the new Easter collectibles it definitely is in the following order from what I can tell (highest to lowest):
Dreamy -> Nightmare -> Pastel Disco -> Zipper Sakura -> Ditto -> Red Pikmin
When it comes to actual rarity (in terms of supply numbers), it is the following:
Red Pikmin -> Pastel Disco -> Nightmare -> Dreamy -> Ditto -> Zipper Sakura
What does everyone think of this conclusion?
I personally think for desirability it'll be similar to yours but Zipper at the end. It's so common since it's only 1 egg too haha. I'll say:
Dreamy -> Nightmare -> Pastel Disco -> Ditto -> Red Pikmin -> Zipper Sakura :3
MasterM64
🍀 Mayor of PARADISE 🍀
I definitely can see that now that I think on it more! I initially have seen the Zipper Sakuras selling quickly more often, but I think in the long run your scale on the desirability is more accurate.
I think the only thing I can see changing down the road is the desirability of the Red Pikmin going up a little potentially just because there are far fewer of them compared to the other eggs (I could be wrong of course and we have a similar story like the Rad Feather where it stays stuck at a certain point because rarity is just not enough to justify a higher value). What do you think?
Last edited:
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
cornimer's Creature:
My opinions from what I've seen in the market so far are:
Dreamy tier 3
Nightmare tier 4
Pastel disco top of tier 5
Ditto + pikmin tier 6
Zipper sakura top of tier 7 or bottom of tier 6
Dreamy tier 3
Nightmare tier 4
Pastel disco top of tier 5
Ditto + pikmin tier 6
Zipper sakura top of tier 7 or bottom of tier 6
idiotdoomspiral
=__=
dreamy definitely has the edge right now, probably a tier above. but theyll probably become more equal later (nightmare going up a tier)
ditto seems to be more high in demand right now than the pikmin, but the pikmin has a lot less sales so i see that becoming more valuable in the future. theyre being sold for 400-500. probably same tier but just a bit higher than the ditto (in the future that is, ditto definitely higher rn)
i dont think zipper sakuras will change from 150-250, in fact i dont think theyll be in demand that much after april so they might go up to 250 for the usual but they might just stay the same, idk
pastel disco egg will go up in the future i think, to about 1.5-2.1k? being sold for 1k-1.5k rn
some of it is just my thoughts and might not help but hopefully they do
ditto seems to be more high in demand right now than the pikmin, but the pikmin has a lot less sales so i see that becoming more valuable in the future. theyre being sold for 400-500. probably same tier but just a bit higher than the ditto (in the future that is, ditto definitely higher rn)
i dont think zipper sakuras will change from 150-250, in fact i dont think theyll be in demand that much after april so they might go up to 250 for the usual but they might just stay the same, idk
pastel disco egg will go up in the future i think, to about 1.5-2.1k? being sold for 1k-1.5k rn
some of it is just my thoughts and might not help but hopefully they do
Miharu
Team Popsicle <3
Miharu's Creature:
I definitely can see that now that I think on it more! I initially have seen the Zipper Sakuras selling quickly more often, but I think in the long run your scale on the desirability is more accurate.
I personally love the pikmin collectible. I love them just as much as I love my popsicle collectibles and that says a lot hahaha but that's my personal taste, as for what others might think I'm not sure if they will become popular or not, depending on whether or not they release more pikmin collectibles in the future. c: If they do release more pikmins in the future then I think it'll definitely become more popular, if not then I'm not so sure if they will be popular or not depending on the community's interest regardless of rarity since there are so many new collectibles and amazing ones out there as well.
mogyay
✨night night✨
omg i'm so happy people are helping and contributing, this is what me and jacob imagined and hoped for! ok all of yours thoughts sound good, i'm gonna wait to see if anyone else chimes in and then later on tonight i'll pop them in at the consensus! and yes absolutely i'm just putting them in atm to give people a vague idea of their tiers as of right now, i'll move them up and down in the future if needed
what do u guys think about disco? do u think desirability will be the same or less or more now that it has a partner? (obv can't do much about it bc we've seen no sales or no apparent change in desirability but i'm moreso just curious about it myself)
what do u guys think about disco? do u think desirability will be the same or less or more now that it has a partner? (obv can't do much about it bc we've seen no sales or no apparent change in desirability but i'm moreso just curious about it myself)
Miharu
Team Popsicle <3
Miharu's Creature:
I definitely think desirability will be more in the future since it now has a partner! Sales I've seen it go for has been around 1.5k tbt. :3
Jacob
Senior Member
I would say Dreamy T3, Nightmare and Disco at opposite ends of T4, pikmin and ditto next to eachother on T5 (but they’ll probably split in a few days)
MasterM64
🍀 Mayor of PARADISE 🍀
I definitely love the Pikmin Egg as well and it is up there with the Kaleidoclover and Spring Shamrock in my eyes!
I definitely can see the Pikmin Egg value spike if they make more of them for the different colors. o/ We definitely will see what the future holds though! I think that is a very accurate assessment for the present and near future Jacob!
The only thing I can see changing down the line (depending on if they follow a similar trend Love & Moon Balls) is Dreamy going to tier 2 and Nightmare going to tier 3. What do you think on that hypothesis my friend?
King Dorado
you can do anything
King Dorado's Creature:
hadn't looked closely at this before. going through the thread-- i agree with BCat, that sweet feather really stands out to me as being inaccurately classified by a good margin. I would drop it at least a tier spot, it isn't at same level as the the others in Tier 1 at all. i've always viewed it as a 3k to 5k tbt value collectible. I'm not aware of anyone paying 10k for one, I would think that would have been an outlier. seems like most people who wanted one got one for 3 to 5k tbt within a few months of that Fair without much difficulty. I know one was traded like only thirty days ago in my thread to Toads for a kaleidoclover and 1500 tbt, which would put it right in the 5k tbt range I would expect.
other than that, I would say move moon ball up with love ball. and I would probably put original disco ball up in Tier 1.
here's a Fun fact-- Weird Doll has indeed been traded for tbt, you just have to search for old threads to find.
btw, Chickensmoothie has a member-made tier list for their rarest collectibles that's been ongoing for like 10 years. it doesn't have prices on it and i would recommend removing them from this one too. i've only been on there a year, and havent gotten into any high-end collectible things there (they have thousands of collectibles) so i havent paid attention to their tier list contents or to the methodology. but my overall impression is the older members feel it causes too much rigidity in trading fwtw. i'm pretty sure you don't have to be a member there to view threads, so if anyone has time and is curious it may be worth looking into how they created and managed theirs over the years...
other than that, I would say move moon ball up with love ball. and I would probably put original disco ball up in Tier 1.
here's a Fun fact-- Weird Doll has indeed been traded for tbt, you just have to search for old threads to find.
btw, Chickensmoothie has a member-made tier list for their rarest collectibles that's been ongoing for like 10 years. it doesn't have prices on it and i would recommend removing them from this one too. i've only been on there a year, and havent gotten into any high-end collectible things there (they have thousands of collectibles) so i havent paid attention to their tier list contents or to the methodology. but my overall impression is the older members feel it causes too much rigidity in trading fwtw. i'm pretty sure you don't have to be a member there to view threads, so if anyone has time and is curious it may be worth looking into how they created and managed theirs over the years...
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
toadsworthy's Creature:
why is yellow feather so much better than the others.... just because no one really buys it, doesn't mean its really sought after or more valuable
- Status
