the spreadsheet was made because mog kept being bugged to update the list, it's not completely up to date hence asking users for their input. i'll probably do one big haul after discussion has died down.
For some reason I was pretty sure I thought I someone had trouble selling it for 10k so I felt that it would be appropriate to place it there. Now that i actually checked, I saw that it can actually sell for 16k and even up to 20k (this is just an outlier though). I'll edit my comment on that part but I believe the other parts of the collectibles I mentioned were accurate, but let me know if anything else is wrong thank you ^_^
This is a good observation!! My original pitch when we came up with the tier list idea was to not include ANY price suggestions what-so ever, but i think the first step is to definitely find where all the current collectibles fit on the list accurately..., but also i wonder if theres a better way to go about representing each of the tier’s values?definitely agree that some people are just pricing based on the chart, but it doesn't reflect current buying or selling trends. ex. collectibles like famous mushrooms which exist in btf market in large quantities, but with little purchasing interest. people selling them price them at 400-500, because of the tier, but little to no sales occur from it.
also to add to the houses discussions, i agree with all of them being moved significantly down. i bought my mori after it sat on the market for a long while, at just 1.6k? which is very far below the tier amount. interest for them just isn't as high as it once was! i think eggies have replaced them haha.
this is all fine, sellers have a total right to sell at whatever rate, but i think has the bigger interesting action of making sellers feel reluctant to accept less for items than they are listed for - as if the price of the collectible is SET and anything less than that, even if they're not getting any other offers, is unacceptable, rather than a sign of a changing collectible economy. i've been around a long time and watched a lot of collectibles rise and fall in ranks and i always think the changes are so compelling! thanks @seliph for taking this on in a new way
if the medium isn't possible? google maps style, like with $, $$, $$$, $$$$ tiers ? to indicate proportional value, and then a column highlighting recent sales(and maybe also offers??) with dates so people can make their own judgements? in conjunction maybe with the amount of that particular collectible released? don't remember the website, but there's a place that aggregates both total sold/given of a collectible, plus the date it was released, which obvs really heavily plays into demand/availability to determine price.
I mean, we don't know when that might be, it could still be a couple months away
as karma said we don't know if that'll be any time soon, so it's best for them to be as accurate as possible right now and they can move around if/when the fair does affect them
