Cranky villager tier list

[Bugs]

I love crankies so much, my second favourite personality! Here's my list:

 

[cucumberzest]

I'm not the best at tier lists, but here ya go.
Rasher's my baby.

 

[0019293893]

 

[Corndoggy]

 

[Sarabelle]

Crankies are one of my favorite personalities. I wish I had room on my island for more of them.

 

[jo_electric]

Just popping in to say that I love Kabuki and I’m glad he’s ranking high in lists. He was a total random move in that took me by surprise and I said I would move him out immediately, but he won me over and is now here to stay.

 

[Corrie]

Same with crankies lolol oh man.

 

[patchworkbunny]

Ah so many good designs for crankies, was the last personality for me to get but I'm starting to love them.

 

[Duu]

Honestly considering not having any jocks so I can have 3 crankies

 

[Ciary]

 

[Jhine7]

Apollo and Octavian are definitely top tier for me here!

 

[pup]

cranky is king. best personality. everyone is dad.

 

[AlexSilverpen]

I love so many of the crankies, but I was surprised at how many I put at the bottom. Butch and Kabuki are super high as far as favorite crankies.

 

[JunoHorizon]

 

[Flunkifera]

This was way too hard. Crankies are my favorites.

 

[Aromatisse]

Elvis is my absolute favorite cranky. <3

 

[Yujian]

 

[Serabee]

Here's mine! Dobie is forever my favorite grumpy grandpa

And... I know some people love Kabuki and Camofrog, but I tend not to like super "themed" villagers. But I like Camofrog a bit 'cause I had him so long in... Wild World, I think? I've had Kabuki in games, too, but I never liked him- even after I knew what was up with the design (as a little kid I had NO idea what "kabuki" was )

 

[Halloqueen]

S Tier: Tough to put these guys in a solid order, but gave Hopper the top spot because penguins are my favorite animal and he has a really gorgeous, unique design. He narrowly edged out Lobo, who almost claimed that spot due to his awesome eyes, but I put him in second place. Octavian holds a special place in my heart and secures third place because he was originally the only Octopus villager because in the GameCube days, and I've been fond of him since then. Del's cool metallic (and, as of New Horizons, apparently robotic) design is really nice. Knox has to be here because of his cool knight design, since I love the aesthetic of knights in general, and he pairs well with Sterling. Dobie's elderly design is fantastic, I love Boris' tusks (and my headcanon that he's a vampire), and I also love Rasher's scar and amazing grin.

A Tier: A real solid batch of boys right here. Kabuki could have been S tier, but I felt like it was a bit too packed as it was. Everyone here is really great, they just aren't S tier.

B Tier: Pretty good.

C Tier: Decent. Fang through to Cyd are the standouts here, everyone after that is just okay enough that they escape D Tier.

D Tier: No thanks. Especially you, Wart Jr. Why did you feel the need to show up in so many of my New Leaf towns, man?

 

[cabbagehead]

A mix between me and my sister's opinion. Roscoe was a pleasant surprise for my sister, she invited him when she would've invited any cranky villager, and now she's one of her favourites. And hopefully one of us will come over Kabuki soon, while island hopping.