Mafia DA:I Mafia

Hello.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If ashot was almost killed, that definetldu means that the killing pattern I brought up was right, the experienced players with a past are being killed.

- - - Post Merge - - -



You didn't need to say anything. Just keep it quiet and no one will realize you were the cop. I think you wanted the cop to waste their inspection on a basically confirmed mafia.

Basically confirmed? Really? They were 100% confirmed in their post,

Honestly when I claimed 1 shot vig it was a joke and I wasn't trying to make it work..... Thanks for the free vig kill though town!

which was four minutes after me saying to inspect them. I didn't know they were confirmed mafia, and I was still stupid and thinking that they were third-party.

Why am I even answering you? Reading through your posts, you have had two mass lists of scum reads.

Gonna do my reads first, doing a color spectrum thing I did last game so its from green(Innocent) to red(Most scum)
Capella- Has only posted to say hi so... no read yet.
Labelle- Hasn't posted a lot so I don't have much to go on as of now.
Tom- Has really only posted to fool around, but i haven't seen any thing scummy yet.
Oath2Order- Same as tom, really has only posted to fool around, while a couple of gut feelings get me about him, i have no evidence so far.
Ashot- Yet again has been fooling around, but seems to have some important opinions I would like to hear.
SarsaKat- Questions a lot, similar to last game. If they're scum i wouldn't be too suprised though, but i just see it as townie questioning.
Ender- Eh, nothing scummy in particular I'm getting, but I wouldn't say your 100% innocent for me.
Dad- Basically the same as sarsa, kinda neutral opinion on both, but leaning more with Town.
Ahpo- Sometimes your posts are a little weird, but since it's your first game I just see it as a innonent mistake and I don't think you would be good at lying your first game.
Pusheen the Cat- Hasn't posted a lot, but what your opinions are really unclear and unsure. You seem to be very wishy washy but I don't have much evidence for now.
Runeraider- Has really only teased Trojan, but you have a couple of weird posts, but i'd like to see you post more and your reads on everyone.
Panda- You seem confused on a lot of stuff, but your opinion on the suspect isn't really clear and alot of your posts have .... which strikes me a bit odd.
Slammint you've only posted today but what you've posted seems really suspicious like
Okay you didn't get a good read yet you were willing to jump on the bandwagon to lynch me?

You can just wait off on voting or just say no lynch you know....kinda weird to me.

But then you change your mind, you think Dad is scum yet you still wanted to vote on me? Seems more like your trying to play it safe if you ask me.

Okay wayyyy to wishy washy on your vote, your either not reading or trying to look as innocent as possible.
All this stuff and more still rubs me the wrong way and your my #2 suspect.
Trojan- Has been acting really weird like this whole game, theres a bunch of evidence i don't like, but here's a few that strike me weird.
TO be honest here, I have no idea why you said this, i never really talked to you last game. And we were joking at the beginning so i assumed you were joking here(which is why i said what i said before) but it really strikes me odd now.

Dad was really only questioning like Sarsa and ender have, he realy hasn't been pointing fingers. Little weird to me.
I love Undertale Best game of 2015 ahead of Fallout 4!
Started getting off topic really quickly, but granted i did ask where the avatar was from, but before then people were asking you why you were suspicious of dad, but you were very eager to change the topic, maybe because you actually dont have a good reason why you were suspicious.

That came out of no where, a very salty comment when i was just asking why i was being accused. You also voted for me without good reason so you are probably just hopping on the bandwagon to get a townie dead.
Realllyyy suspicous if you ask me, i don't know why no one else picked up on this but yeah, my #1 suspect and who i'll probably be voting for.
But yeah that's all my reads for now. If anything seems weird or doesn't make sense, let me know.

Okay here are my scum reads, i only put people i find somewhat suspicious so if your not on it, your townie for now.
Somethings to keep it mind are the interactions with Trojan and why did the Mafia kill Tom and Rune?
Trojan- Basically confirm Mafia, but just so no one tries to sway the lynching today heres some evidence to go on top of my previous reads here:http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?326052-DA-I-Mafia&p=5799954&viewfull=1#post5799954
Okay so he is clearly lying about being a vig, plus the fact that no one was shot, Its odvious that he's been lying about the role, he could of just said he was townie.

Basically confirming he's mafia, you might as well have Al Pacino as your avatar. Also trying to act funny and weird to throw off people to not vote for you if your a third party role like jester.
Sorry for stating the obvious, but its just so people don't doubt lynching him. So its Trojan/? team, So who could the other one be?
Well, I'm assuming that Trojan wanted Rune dead, most likely because they were going
Why Rune is dead
after Trojan the whole game, and even voted for them at first.

and

Shows that they would go after Trojan no matter what, while everyone else went to ender, maybe he thought it would be easier to kill someone that would be harder to convince.
Why Tom is Dead
Tom didn't really post a lot, which makes mw think that he wasn't killed because of what he said this game, but for the possibility that he knows how the other Mafian plays, and would be able to detect them and convince us to lynch them.

This would be dangerous to the mafia if Tom got a scum read on one of them and convinced us to lynch them, this would be a big threat and it would be easier to kill off that threat.
Who could have killed tom?
Well if i believe that it was to kill tom to prevent the risk of him swaying a lynch for them, Tom has had a couple of suspicions

He had suspicious on Pusheen, and when you think about it Pusheen has been acting strange the whole game, not posting alot, yet they have switched their opinions and vote to whoever was getting the most votes, from Me, to Trojan, to Ender clearly Bandwagoning. Seems very suspicious to me and I don't trust it... Especially since Tom was one of the few people who have been suspicious of Pusheen.
So yeah it could also be Oath or Dad because of previous game history but i don't have much evidence on that.
Panda- There is no denying that you have been acting really weird this whole game, not only has your opinions been swayed a lot, but the way you've were talking to Trojan was very odd.
Sounds to me like your blaming Dad for the lynch, when you also were one of the first to side with him and possibly eager to get the suspicion off your team mate, and on to a townie.

Seems like your getting a bit mad or confused why your team mate is admitting he's mafia.

Now your getting really mad at him for no reason...A townie would be glad that he's confessing but your getting upset by him doing so as it seems.

WHAT ARE YOU DOING?! are you trying to get another mislynch? he's clearly mafia and has to be Lynched asap...

And these are a few weird thing she says, just look back on their little chat and it gets weirder and more angry on her side.


Trying to keep Suspicions off of you and get someone on your side much?

If Panda isn't scum i don't know what your doing this game to be honest.
So yeah My scum reads are on a Trojan/Pusheen and Trojan/Panda team. So please keep this in the back of your mind when looking for the other Mafian.
(hoepfully this post doesn't look like a mess of spoilers and quotes)

You clearly have had no suspicions of me other than "gut feelings" and "past game history", yet all of that has changed once I come out as Detective with my inspect result of LaBelleFleur being scum. Isn't that interesting? The only time you're suspicious is when I find scum.
 
Basically confirmed? Really? They were 100% confirmed in their post,



which was four minutes after me saying to inspect them. I didn't know they were confirmed mafia, and I was still stupid and thinking that they were third-party.

Why am I even answering you? Reading through your posts, you have had two mass lists of scum reads.





You clearly have had no suspicions of me other than "gut feelings" and "past game history", yet all of that has changed once I come out as Detective with my inspect result of LaBelleFleur being scum. Isn't that interesting? The only time you're suspicious is when I find scum.

If you think Daniel is scummy can you give some valid reasons as to why this is?

I would like to hear your view of this.
 
I am honestly confused as to what Daniel is asking.

If I was scum faking a Detective claik, that would be insanely stupid as it would result in my death the next lynch.
More or less, he's saying that you're more likely scum because of your actions, rather than looking at the Sheriff results. What exactly, I'd like to hear from him. That's interesting that he's never scum read you before.

Daniel, why're you acting like you've been suspicious of Oath all game, when you only started becoming suspicious of him just now?

But at least for me, you're someone who doesn't really speak out. Before this, you've shown a lot of tendency to just pop in, say a few things we all already knew or didn't have a lot of substance, and pop back out (mainly in the Ender lynch). Then there's also the fact that you were so insistent on a potential Jester (and you tunneled on this topic. You didn't want to talk about anything else.), and that Dad, someone who showed suspicion against you, died the next day.

There would definitely be reason to suspect you, but given that you don't have any reason to claim Sheriff at a time like this if you were scum, I believe you're town.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If you think Daniel is scummy can you give some valid reasons as to why this is?

I would like to hear your view of this.
Didn't he just give some reasons?

What's your take on Daniel's theory?
 
Also I haven't seen why ashtot is suspicious of her.

besides oaths detective claim (which I'm still iffy about.) Why would you be suspicious of labelle?
 
If you think Daniel is scummy can you give some valid reasons as to why this is?

I would like to hear your view of this.

My last paragraph is why. He hasn't read me as scummy all game, but the minute I say I'm Detective and announce my results, he suddenly believes that I'm faking it and that I'm scum.
 
Also I haven't seen why ashtot is suspicious of her.

besides oaths detective claim (which I'm still iffy about.) Why would you be suspicious of labelle?
They're sheriff results. Sheriff results are pretty damn absolute lol.

But yeah sure I'll go look back. Give me a moment. Answer my question in the meantime.
 
Alright well while that sounds believable, can you give me some reasons besides that? What I meant by valid was more reasons.
 
I got a flight rising account so i won't be here a lot, i'll check back every now and then but now i must feed my addiction.
 
I just find it weird that it's only shortly after I explain why I think Daniel is scum, instead of responding, he decides to go to Flight Rising.

And...?

You're attacking him for literally only being suspicious of you, and let's see, current score Oath < LaBelle.

I think you're acting sorta nervous after the defense labelle said, I'm going to wait a little bit longer before my final choice.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I just find it weird that it's only shortly after I explain why I think Daniel is scum, instead of responding, he decides to go to Flight Rising.

And...?

You're attacking him for literally only being suspicious of you, and let's see, current score Oath < LaBelle.

I think you're acting sorta nervous after the defense labelle said, I'm going to wait a little bit longer before my final choice.
 
I just find it weird that it's only shortly after I explain why I think Daniel is scum, instead of responding, he decides to go to Flight Rising.

Because im getting really cool dragons. But i don't know why you would find me scum, i finf it weird how you swayed everyone to lynch LaBelle with no evidence, another Ender incident i'm guessing.
 
Because im getting really cool dragons. But i don't know why you would find me scum, i finf it weird how you swayed everyone to lynch LaBelle with no evidence, another Ender incident i'm guessing.
I think that's a bit exaggerated, his evidence is that he's detective, almost died last night, and dad stated he was suspicious if LaBelle.

Although, he could be BSing those first two claims. And dads suspicion was merely only a statement, correct me if I'm wrong.
 
I don't have any other reasons, other than what my inspection over the next night will end up telling me.
I'm surprised you're so confident you'll make it through the night. I'd assume mafia would want to kill you now that you've outed yourself... unless you know for a fact you won't be targeted.

Will write more later, still at work. >.<
 
I'm surprised you're so confident you'll make it through the night. I'd assume mafia would want to kill you now that you've outed yourself... unless you know for a fact you won't be targeted.

Will write more later, still at work. >.<

Oh, no, I know full well I'm likely to be either be roleblocked tonight or killed overnight.

But, one can hope.
 
Back
Top