LISTEN HERE YOU LITTLE NAUGHTIES
WHO TRIED TO KILL ME
btw i was hit last night and protected
Something seems off here. Three kills in one night? The only plausible way I can think of where that would be possible is if there were a 3rd party on the loose, and the mafia had 2 KP left. But I don’t think that’s true. This is a 15-player game. To have a four-person mafia, plus a 3rd party killing role is quite mafia-sided.
Well, what if the kill came from a town killing role? Again, I don’t think that’s true. Because Ender was a town killing role, and Ender’s been dead for a while now. There could be another, but I doubt it.
So. The only other conclusion is that someone is lying about being saved. And I’m pretty sure it’s Oath.
I’m going to start in reverse here.
Why not Ashtot? Simple. If Ashtot were mafia, why would he claim to be saved, thus causing me to question it in the first place? He could’ve sat back and watched me get lynched easily, but he didn’t. The only thing I can think of is that he thought being supposedly saved would make him appear town, but given the circumstances (Dad dead, Oath claiming to have been saved), I don’t think he’d risk it.
So.
Why would Oath claim to be saved? Because he thought he could get away with it. Because as mafia, he would know what the exact KP of the scum team was. And I’m guessing it’s at 1, thus the fake save. We see two ‘kills', we think 2 KP for scum team, since our Vig is dead. But scum don’t know who the 3rd parties are, or if there’s a third party to begin with. And apparently, so there is. And Ashtot gets targeted. Oops?
But there were only two kills night one! My guess is either the 3rd party tried to kill the same person the mafia did, or they were inactive. Which points to someone like Pusheen or Capella (but that’s just conjecture which I have nothing to back up).
As Panda so kindly linked, I read you as scummy D1 for your general lack of anything. N1/D2 was obviously overshadowed by Trojan announcing his alliance. Even before that, you were still protecting him.
It's a small game, so multiple vigilantes...Idk. It is possible for two-one-shots.
For the entire 72 hours leading up to Trojan’s lynch, you were making little posts, doubting Trojan was actually mafia, throwing around jester as a suggestion, and suspecting Tom & Dad. Very much like a mafian trying to save their teammate without getting any blood on their hands. Then, N2. Apart from your little apology, all you did was call out Daniel for no reason at all (that I can see).
I want to reiterate a point that Daniel made as well - the killing pattern.
Like in my reads before, tom was killed do to game history together, and dad was killed for the same reason. Killing off all players who know him and would be his biggest threat would leave us players perfectly innocent and able to be swayed be you, something a player will past with you would not fall for so easily.
Everyone left has never played mafia with you before. So now it comes down to keeping the people who will follow you & eliminating the ones who won't, i.e. the talkers and the people who could potentially go after you.
Now, we’re here, D3. I have no idea why you would risk claiming detective, and it’s the only thing confusing me right now. If someone CC’d you, you’d be done for. There's only one reason I can think of - you knew I would be an easy lynch (since Dad suspected me and died shortly thereafter), and you could buy yourself & the scum team time later on in the confusion.
