Mafia DA:I Mafia

[PandaDarling]

Yea you're good haha.

what u mean hes good ?

 

[Arstotzkan]

what u mean hes good ?

He was saying he didn't see the WOTC, so I was saying he doesn't need to worry about it

- - - Post Merge - - -

I am curious though - what's your take on Oath's sheriff results?

 

[N e s s]

Honestly I don't know what to do right now

- - - Post Merge - - -

What's a wotc?

 

[Arstotzkan]

It stands for "Wisdom of the Crowds". Basically, if the general consensus is that they don't want a certain player to play in the game, they get kicked out. It's usually done when you sign up, from my understanding, but I guess it doesn't always have to be like that haha.

Here's some other abbreviations that might make life easier.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Honestly I don't know what to do right now

- - - Post Merge - - -

What's a wotc?

You said you wanted more evidence to vote LaBelle, right? What's your take on this:

You do realize that Oath has little motivation to lie, right? If LaBelle flips town, that pretty much writes off Oath as scum. The only chance that wouldn't be the case is if he's pulling some sort of gambit here (which idk how he'd be so confident in Labelle's suspicion, considering he wasn't vocal about her suspicion before this) or LaBelle got framed (which would kind of be a miracle in of itself).

 

[N e s s]

Well I may look into all of this later when I have time, I have a math and history benchmark tomorrow and I need A's or I'm toast irl.

But so far, I've seen that Oath was suspicious of tom before he died, and dad had suspicions of oath before his death as well. It isn't a direct read, but oath has been in my attention span for parts of the game but I've just been putting them off as coincidences.

I just want to know directly who the best out of all the players before I follow the herd. If we mislynch today than there will be 3 mafia left. And if we don't find scum today we're in trouble.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Our atleast 3 mafia anyway, I'm assuming from science.

- - - Post Merge - - -

God not science...MATH.

if oath is telling the truth of almost being killed last night, than that does make 3 mafia right?

 

[Arstotzkan]

I can see your second point, but as for your first one, wouldn't Oath being sus of someone who died be a town correlation? That gives him less material to work with in Day. If you're really that suspicious of him, can you find evidence of how he's actually being scummy?

Other than that, I have two things to say.

1) Why is who's the best matter? Skill shouldn't matter - it's how scummy or townie people are.
2) How does this have to do with Oath's motivation (or lack thereof) to lie?

 

[Damniel]

Wait how many Mafians are left?

 

[Arstotzkan]

Either two or three, depending on who shot Oath/Dad. If one of those shots were from a Vig or something, we'd have a two person mafia left. If both of those shots were from the mafia, we'd have a three person mafia left.

 

[PandaDarling]

how come i asked that question 2-3 times and no one answered me !!! and daniel gets an answer straight away.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Huh, I never saw you ask. Sorry ^^"

The formula's Num of mafia/2, rounded up, for future ref.

 

[N e s s]

how come i asked that question 2-3 times and no one answered me !!! and daniel gets an answer straight away.

You really are a hypocrite.

What's you're question and I'll answer it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Nvm sans answered before me.

 

[Damniel]

Oh damn there's 2-3 mafia left...this game is gonna take a long time...

 

[Ashtot]

kill labelle the scumbag

- - - Post Merge - - -

btw i was hit last night and protected

 

[Arstotzkan]

kill labelle the scumbag

- - - Post Merge - - -

btw i was hit last night and protected

Woah ok that's big. So that would mean 3 shots were fired last night.

Confused as to why someone would shoot you though.

 

[PandaDarling]

Hi hello reads (that I started before all of this Ender madness so I realize it's a bit out of place, LOL).

EnderWiggin
You didn't stick out as scummy to me until I started reading back to answer Kat's question on what I thought of Trojan. From your very first post, you had it out for Trojan, barely acknowledging the suspicion around Daniel. It just gave off a weird, different vibe from how you've played before. Then, Dad posted his ISO that backed up all of my gut feelings and turned them into logical thoughts. I hope you return before lynch because I'd like to hear your defence.

SarasaKat
Your posts are logical and the questions are plentiful as always. Nothing you've posted has sent up red flags, so I'm willing to soft town-read you for now, but like Dad, I know you're very good at this game and could easily be mafia masquerading as helpful town.

Call Me Daniel
My main reasons for scum-reading you were the fact that you were bandwagoning on everyone & hadn't given any of your own reads yet. You've since done so. While I'm not going to town-read you quite yet, I don't think you're a priority lynch anymore.

Pusheen the Cat
Null because you haven't contributed much yet, but you've posted here and there with things other than illuminati so. We'll see I suppose.

Runeraider
You indirectly answered my question and you've posted enough (somewhat) decent content that I'm okay soft town-reading you.

Trojan
This feels very much like a Dolby situation. First person to ask about suspicions, bring up suspicions, basically do anything to start the game gets boinked. Your nonchalant attitude from there didn't really help you out, though - the suspicions brought up on you hold some water (as much water as a D1 conjecture-based case can hold, that is). Your vigilante claim is super shady which is the reason why you're my second-biggest scum-read but that will be either proven or disproven rather quickly, and as of right now Ender is much scummier.

Slammint
I have absolutely no idea what you were trying to accomplish today. Not a clue. Just thinking about it makes my brain hurt. I don't think it comes from a scummy place though, just confusion and foolishness? Basically, I'm lost and I need to see more posts from you to get a better read.

Dad
Was town-reading you early on for the way you were pushing at the get-go and your reasonings along the way. Your ISO on Ender makes logical sense and backs up my own thoughts from when I was looking back at Trojan to answer Kat's question. Strong town-read for now (if you're mafia fooling me again I STG I will quit forever).

Panda1376
You're a bit wishy-washy and all over the place with your thoughts. I will reference a wonderful quote from Tom:I don't get a scum vibe from you, though. Just a 'trying to stay afloat' kind of sense.

Tom
Fairly typical D1 Tom. I do like that he's shone a light on the quieter people, like Pusheen, and put together some half-decent thoughts. Slight town.

Capella
Null, because nothing.

Ashtot
The way you attacked me for putting the pressure on Pusheen really bothered me. Putting pressure on people and asking questions is how you get information and find scum. For example, Dad putting the pressure on Trojan & Daniel at the beginning of the day. I ask one question and suddenly I'm scum for making everyone believe the newbies are scum (which, if you'd actually read what I said instead of responding with an incoherent wall of text, you'd see I didn't do at all). I don't know if it's enough to scum-read you and I doubt anyone else would consider lynching you today anyways... just something I'm definitely going to keep in mind. Your response was just so over-the-top that I have a hard time believing there were good intentions there.

TheAhPoCawdOh
Like Panda, you're a bit all over the place. I'm having a hard time following your train of thought, 'cause it's a tad wishy-washy. But nothing's stuck out to me as particularly scummy. It's your first game and you're asking questions and forming opinions, which is good. Null/slight town.

oath2order
I want to hear more from you. You hopped on the Daniel bandwagon and have been pretty quiet since then. Looking back at your posts, it's basically ****-posting, explaining bussing, jumping on the Danielwagon, and the bit about Dad & Tom being scum buddies (which I don't believe, but whatever). Although you've been posting I feel like you're sailing under the radar and I don't like it.

So, biggest suspects right now? Ender, Trojan, Ashtot, Oath, in that order.

these were Labellefleur's reads from Day 1... just going through them now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

so if we have any other size=7]ONE SHOT VIGILANTES[/size] they know who to kill

or a cop inspect them

why did you say this if you are the detective ?

 

[oath2order]

these were Labellefleur's reads from Day 1... just going through them now.

- - - Post Merge - - -



why did you say this if you are the detective ?

To make the scum team think that I'm not the detective...?

 

[PandaDarling]

oath ??

 

[N e s s]

I can see your second point, but as for your first one, wouldn't Oath being sus of someone who died be a town correlation? That gives him less material to work with in Day. If you're really that suspicious of him, can you find evidence of how he's actually being scummy?

Other than that, I have two things to say.

1) Why is who's the best matter? Skill shouldn't matter - it's how scummy or townie people are.
2) How does this have to do with Oath's motivation (or lack thereof) to lie?

Alright, well if its a town correlation, he nevertheless still seems to have been kinda nervous for a few reasons.

1. He's the only one who had actually thought trojan could have been jester, it just leaves an undescribable taste in my mouth. Why would he be so scared of him being jester anyway?
2. even if it narrows down scum pool, he was still suspicious of tom before his death. It also leads me to believe that when dad was suspicious of him that he decided to take him down because if him being such a strong analyst.

And Kat, to answer your bottom 2 questions, here's the answers.

A. Since we're on that topic, I think that the more experienced players seem to have an easier time lying, I think I want to know the general skill levels of people before I vote.
B. I never said I thought that he was scummy, just that its all kinda odd to me. I am suspicious of LaBelle but its still not enough for me to vote her just yet.

 

[PandaDarling]

oh sorry..to not give your role away... ok...

 

[Damniel]

Well if Trojan was a jester, he would win if he was lynched.