Mafia Dethy in July- Mafioso win!
- Thread starter Damniel
- Start date
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
haha sorry!! trying to get the most out of d1
wait I thought it was like this:
if catharina mafia
guava normal / inverse / naive
volt normal / inverse / naive
misty normal / inverse / naive
antonio paranoid
why can't misty, volt or guava be inverse?
but I also had problems at assuming catharina is town so someone is lying
Or am I doing things wrong?
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
because if catharina is mafia, everyone else is town, and guava volt and misty got all town inspections, hence why they cant be inverse (they would get mafia if they were inverse)
Post automatically merged:
if you are town, then it would be the any of the other cases
Oooh yes ofc I forgot to use the invests my bad lol now I'm lucky that you posted first.
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
trying to make my train of thought clear:
we are already got figured out naive/paranoid, so let's look at normal/inverse
I can only be normal if antonio is town, and inverse if antonio is mafia
guava is the same
misty can only be normal if im town, and inverse if im mafia
antonio can only be normal if im mafia, and inverse if im town
same for catharina
making a chart only makes it easier to find inconsistencies aka catharina seemly cant be mafia
also suggestion to all inspect catharina tonight, catharina just pick someone at random or maybe antonio? haha idk leave suggestions guys
we are already got figured out naive/paranoid, so let's look at normal/inverse
I can only be normal if antonio is town, and inverse if antonio is mafia
guava is the same
misty can only be normal if im town, and inverse if im mafia
antonio can only be normal if im mafia, and inverse if im town
same for catharina
making a chart only makes it easier to find inconsistencies aka catharina seemly cant be mafia
Post automatically merged:
corrected. gonna sleep now
also suggestion to all inspect catharina tonight, catharina just pick someone at random or maybe antonio? haha idk leave suggestions guys
Last edited:
Miss Misty
Senior Member
I like the idea of everyone inspecting Catharina. Like you said in your breakdown, Catharina is the closest we have to someone being cleared so it'll help narrow things down a little more.
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
it's okay, I'll try my best
We will try to imagine situations where each person is town and 1 person is mafia.
For example, if I'm mafia:
You are either paranoid or normal (since you got volt is mafia)
Guava is normal or naive (she got antonio is town, she would be right in this scenario, but it doesn't prove she's normal because she still can be naive)
Catharine is normal or paranoid (she got volt is mafia)
Misty is inverse or naive (she go volt is town)
Misty is the only one that can be inverse, so she should be inverse. Guava is the only then that could be naive. You and catharina can both be normal or paranoid, so if you are normal, she's paranoid, and vice-versa.
The intricacies don't really matter, what matter is that this scenario *can* exist, so I can be mafia.
For catharina, if she's mafia
I'm normal or naive (antonio is town, in this scenario, you would be town indeed, hence why I can be normal)
guava is normal or naive (same reason)
misty is normal or naive (same reason, but she got volt is town)
you are inverse or paranoid (you got volt is mafia, and in this scenario I'm town, so you are either inverse or paranoid)
See how in this scenario, if you paranoid, no one will be inverse. So this scenario is impossible, then catharina can't be mafia.
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
I'm still failing to grasp the correlation with the two?
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
They don't have correlation, they are independent scenarios. First one is an example of a possible scenario, second is an example of an impossible scenario
Post automatically merged:
think abt it as you assume someone is mafia and make an hypothesis
because you only get 1 mafia, you can only get 5 different scenarios, so it's easy to test
Last edited:
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
since u are town we would have more clues on who is each detective. if we get find out even just 1 detective, it can already clear or condemn me or antonio (if we find normal or inverse)
Post automatically merged:
another idea is for the misty and cath go for antonio, guava go for me and me and antonio go for someone else
Post automatically merged:
i actually thinking this is a better option. if for example we get antonio is town / town / town / mafia we will know someone is lying hence clearing antonio. also someone will die tonight and results from investigating cath will be useful if we get all the 4 investigations. i was kinda betting on cath dying tonight but im not sure
Last edited:
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
yeah if people agree you and misty would go for antonio
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
hi all. I will be driving soon so I won’t be able to make the post for 7pm est (37 min from now). I will have to end the day for now.
No one was eliminated.
You have 24 hours to send me your action (inspections or the kill!)
No one was eliminated.
You have 24 hours to send me your action (inspections or the kill!)
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
Hi all.
@voltairenism
@Miss Misty
@Antonio
@Catharina266
@guav@
I was asked to elaborate on a rule in the game
that i failed to elaborate on in my OP post. Since this question is coming pretty close to deadline and may change people’s perspective on their action. I will be extending the
night so it will end at tomorrow, 2PM EST, to give everyone time to read this. I plan to now base phase deadlines around this time to stay within everyone’s time zones. Please let me know if this is an issue with anyone.
If a detective’s target is killed that night, they will NOT get back an inspection result on them.
Please do not read into the context of this question. it was asked by an observer, but I felt the information was important to convey to the players. Like before, you are free to change your actions until the deadline.
Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns. Enjoy the remaining of your sundays.
@voltairenism
@Miss Misty
@Antonio
@Catharina266
@guav@
I was asked to elaborate on a rule in the game
that i failed to elaborate on in my OP post. Since this question is coming pretty close to deadline and may change people’s perspective on their action. I will be extending the
night so it will end at tomorrow, 2PM EST, to give everyone time to read this. I plan to now base phase deadlines around this time to stay within everyone’s time zones. Please let me know if this is an issue with anyone.
If a detective’s target is killed that night, they will NOT get back an inspection result on them.
Please do not read into the context of this question. it was asked by an observer, but I felt the information was important to convey to the players. Like before, you are free to change your actions until the deadline.
Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns. Enjoy the remaining of your sundays.
Last edited:
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
got guava as town
this might not be as coordinated today be we still can get good info
i still can be naive or normal. i cant be inverse bc both antonio and guava needed to be mafia
this might not be as coordinated today be we still can get good info
i still can be naive or normal. i cant be inverse bc both antonio and guava needed to be mafia
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
It was a terrible decision to all post who we were going to target and the fact that @Damniel won't show us which kind of detective Cassandra was gives off the vibe that her detective role was crucial to ending this game extremely early. Atleast, that's my theory. I doubt we can determine which role is assigned to who anymore so using that to our advantage is ultimately useless w/o a process of elimination.
I'm starting to think volt is Mafia, I'm going to look back into their posts and determine if my hunch is correct or not. Give me time to form a SoS.
BTW, I stuck with my vote on Cassandra just in case mafia wouldn't vote them off.
I'm starting to think volt is Mafia, I'm going to look back into their posts and determine if my hunch is correct or not. Give me time to form a SoS.
Post automatically merged:
BTW, I stuck with my vote on Cassandra just in case mafia wouldn't vote them off.
Last edited:
