MyLifeIsCake
~Impossomble~
I know I'm not feeling paranoid, Bianca's face wasn't red with anger to me. She looked more like a green-eyed monster
-
Guest, can you feel the love in the air? Valentine's Week at The Bell Tree has begun with a new mini-event featuring four activities to enjoy -- new and returning collectibles are up for grabs! Dive in to the love here.
Mafia Dethy (Quick micro game)
- Thread starter Damniel
- Start date
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
Mylifecake is definitely a sane cop just saying
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
sorry, I was cleaning my house all day yesterday because my aunt is coming today and the dog hair can be bad on her allergies
Bianca came back as a scummy scummerson to me
I like how you are waiting for me to give my result... but have not said you're own. Waiting to see what everyone else says before making up your own?
probably because you are insane or paranoid? like no one is going to truly know their sanity on day 1? hence why we need to go off other things for this ya'll... I'm sorry, I'm not gonna read much into statements like "I'm not feeling paranoid" or "cake is def a sane cop" because thats just not possible to know right now lol
if going off play alone, I put bianca as town for her honest and genuine play so far on top of agreeing to be the guinea pig shows she has nothing to hide.
Cake's posts are cryptic but nothing seems really out of place - reads more newbie than anything else
Teddy's investigation post seem very nondescript and almost scripted. The wording of it plays off that bianca also got a scum read, which is weird to me. I know you were shooketh after the last game, but it does feel different than your tone from the last game
Dino on the other hand has been talking about being calculated and withholding information this whole time. You are also the only person who didn't give your investigation in your first post which really reads poorly to me.
Bianca came back as a scummy scummerson to me
Post automatically merged:
I like how you are waiting for me to give my result... but have not said you're own. Waiting to see what everyone else says before making up your own?
Post automatically merged:
probably because you are insane or paranoid? like no one is going to truly know their sanity on day 1? hence why we need to go off other things for this ya'll... I'm sorry, I'm not gonna read much into statements like "I'm not feeling paranoid" or "cake is def a sane cop" because thats just not possible to know right now lol
Post automatically merged:
if going off play alone, I put bianca as town for her honest and genuine play so far on top of agreeing to be the guinea pig shows she has nothing to hide.
Cake's posts are cryptic but nothing seems really out of place - reads more newbie than anything else
Teddy's investigation post seem very nondescript and almost scripted. The wording of it plays off that bianca also got a scum read, which is weird to me. I know you were shooketh after the last game, but it does feel different than your tone from the last game
Dino on the other hand has been talking about being calculated and withholding information this whole time. You are also the only person who didn't give your investigation in your first post which really reads poorly to me.
Last edited:
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
- Joined
- May 5, 2019
- Posts
- 1,524
- Bells
- 218
- Love Tokens
- 0
- Heart Dust
- 0
- Switch
- 5672-8488-5007
- Island
- Archaia
Actually, I was holding back on my result for a similar reason, because I didn't want to let the mafia know how to ruin it.
Bianca is basically cleared to me, now.
If all four REAL investigators checked out someone, we would get exactly 2 town and 2 mafia reads back.
Town - sane says town, insane says maf, naive says town, para says maf (I know four real invests can never dogpile onto another invest but I'm trying to get a point across here.)
Maf - sane says maf, insane says town, naive says town, para says maf
I also have Bianca come back as scummy.
So Bianca got 3 scum reads and 1 town read, a.k.a not what we would get for a dogpile made of only real investigators.
Meaning one of those reads - most likely one of the sum readers but can't be sure - is lying. I see absolutely no reason for any real investigator to lie about their results, but the mafia absolutely lies.
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
interesting......3 mafia reads and 1 town...dino is right someone's lying..
so they lynch option is teddy, toads and dinotown
lets discuss
Post automatically merged:
so they lynch option is teddy, toads and dinotown
lets discuss
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
- Joined
- May 5, 2019
- Posts
- 1,524
- Bells
- 218
- Love Tokens
- 0
- Heart Dust
- 0
- Switch
- 5672-8488-5007
- Island
- Archaia
I think Toad's insistence for saying I'm the scummy one when not all the reads on you were out is a little odd TBH. I am well aware that purposefully withholding my read wasn't the best look, but at the same time, I didn't want to say because I didn't want the mafia to have worked out that the correct way to avoid suspicion was to lie and give you the 2/2 reads.interesting......3 mafia reads and 1 town...dino is right someone's lying..
Post automatically merged:
so they lynch option is teddy, toads and dinotown
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
agreed that is not right... I don't know why dinotown would purposefully put themselves in that situation, but I also don't put it past them to put himself in a situation like this to get town credit and try to get through the two lynches by throwing me and teddy under the bus. I don't think it clears him just to say all that. Dino wanted something though, since he withheld his investigation for a few hours... I'm inclined to vote Teddy over him though if we wanna stick to the theory of one of the mafia invests is the scum.
this is all betting that we can trust all the investigations, which I don't know why someone would lie as town?
this is all betting that we can trust all the investigations, which I don't know why someone would lie as town?
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
so are you scum reading me or not? because you contradicted yourself in your two sentences saying that what I said was odd... but that you understand why i would say it. Its absolutely fishy for someone to inquire about someone else investigation without saying their own no matter the circumstances
Post automatically merged:
sorry, I'll fix it from this point on... we never posted about pronouns
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
- Joined
- May 5, 2019
- Posts
- 1,524
- Bells
- 218
- Love Tokens
- 0
- Heart Dust
- 0
- Switch
- 5672-8488-5007
- Island
- Archaia
Actually, it must be one of the scum readers.
If the town is a lie and the 3 mafia reads are all truthful... that still doesn't really work out because a proper dogpile on Bianca should give 2/2, 3 truthful scumreads is basically impossible.
I'm happy to vote Teddy, the reply to Bianca at their first post was genuinely off - asking to explain a certain read when we know at least 2 of us are basically always wrong is weird. It was weird of Bianca too and I'd probably push that for the same reason but Bianca is kinda clear after that.
Teddy did something else which may or may not have been iffy yesterday, let me go find it
so if Teddy really did mean he wanted to lynch Bianca straight off... what would be the logic behind that, especially with the new knowledge that Bianca is like 99% chance townie.
If the town is a lie and the 3 mafia reads are all truthful... that still doesn't really work out because a proper dogpile on Bianca should give 2/2, 3 truthful scumreads is basically impossible.
Post automatically merged:
No, I'm not scumreading you, I just thought it was a little odd to start pointing out the obviously poor look on me before I'd even had a chance to say what I actually did get as a Bianca read. But if I'm out here making iffy-looking choices as an actual detective, you can too lol
Post automatically merged:
I'm happy to vote Teddy, the reply to Bianca at their first post was genuinely off - asking to explain a certain read when we know at least 2 of us are basically always wrong is weird. It was weird of Bianca too and I'd probably push that for the same reason but Bianca is kinda clear after that.
Teddy did something else which may or may not have been iffy yesterday, let me go find it
Post automatically merged:
I'm willing to give the benefit of the doubt as say Teddy meant investigate here, but the reply when asked this by Toads was:
which does seems pretty weird to me when I think most other people would have said "oh yea I meant investigate lol my bad"
so if Teddy really did mean he wanted to lynch Bianca straight off... what would be the logic behind that, especially with the new knowledge that Bianca is like 99% chance townie.
Last edited:
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
so to summarize so far:
1) so my reading could implicates toads if i am a safe cop
2) dino's reading late could implicate her because she could be strategizing and trying to get townie points
we need to hear from teddy and mylife
1) so my reading could implicates toads if i am a safe cop
2) dino's reading late could implicate her because she could be strategizing and trying to get townie points
we need to hear from teddy and mylife
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
this post was weird because a paranoid cop would not "know their role" night 2? If an insane cop investigates a town person (which statistically it would) it will mimic a paranoid cop.
I also don't see a point to publicly announcing anything like this
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
- Joined
- May 5, 2019
- Posts
- 1,524
- Bells
- 218
- Love Tokens
- 0
- Heart Dust
- 0
- Switch
- 5672-8488-5007
- Island
- Archaia
While I don't doubt you are a detective, you still have every chance of being the insane or paranoid, so I don't think it's a bad look on Toads. However, we could do another dogpile on Toads if we have another night. That's probably best figured out later.
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
bianca what do you think of the investigation results as a whole? like the quality of them and such?
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
so lets say i am insane or paranoid, and toads is town.
okay i see the logic...teddy or dino we have to lynch either one of you.
I think it is clear someone's lying. If we dogpile on you next night, that would absolutely give us the correct reads. dino's strategy is to me screaming townie but I can see your point on why it could it also be a mafia move..
okay i see the logic...teddy or dino we have to lynch either one of you.
Post automatically merged:
I think it is clear someone's lying. If we dogpile on you next night, that would absolutely give us the correct reads. dino's strategy is to me screaming townie but I can see your point on why it could it also be a mafia move..
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
regardless though, if we mislynch, then two of the cops are taken out which leaves each person's sanity up to question and everything is still just a speculation
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
- Joined
- May 5, 2019
- Posts
- 1,524
- Bells
- 218
- Love Tokens
- 0
- Heart Dust
- 0
- Switch
- 5672-8488-5007
- Island
- Archaia
True, I'm not sure another dogpile of reads will help get us anywhere like Bianca said it would - but figuring out who will read who is probably best left for after a lynch - I'm assuming we get night chat on again lol.
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
if i get nighted, the strategy for the 3 remaining cops is to dogpile on toads and know that I am detective , but I am just not sure if he is mafia or town but at least i have a read on him
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
while yes it is odd to put oneself in that situation that dino did... she could be very well aware of all of this too. So she purposefully waited for all the other investigations, so to say "well I also got a scum investigation". Then she can white knight the whole game by saying "why would i do that and put myself in danger" knowing very well thats a strong argument and then bulldoze this whole game.
