Mafia Forest Fire Mafia - Town Win- Endgame

[Trojan]

she hasnt lived too long cause I shot her

 

[Minties]

if starry was mafia I feel like she'd be more inclined to be active. IMO the best lynch choice is Daniel, although he's one of the only ones making contributions rn lol. mostly bc of his bandwagoning Starry just for being half inactive, there are people that haven't posted at all. starry is going to be active when she can but the others haven't said anything.

Trundle is suspicious to me too, mostly based on his reply to my suspicion of Daniel, and that he voted me for no apparent reason

Trundle always does dumb stuff like that.

I do sort of follow Daniel's reasoning that we should just do the d1 lynch on someone inactive. Learned that lesson the hard way by letting Dolby slip through with silence in past games. Considering there has only been spam and inactivity, there's not much to go on here. I haven't played with most of the new players in the game, so I have to do some research.

Will day be extended at all due to half the game being inactive?

 

[N e s s]

Trundle always does dumb stuff like that.

I do sort of follow Daniel's reasoning that we should just do the d1 lynch on someone inactive. Learned that lesson the hard way by letting Dolby slip through with silence in past games. Considering there has only been spam and inactivity, there's not much to go on here. I haven't played with most of the new players in the game, so I have to do some research.

Will day be extended at all due to half the game being inactive?

No. Players have posted, and they're somewhat active. I'm giving everybody a chance, but theres 2 people that are going to replace Piichinu and Aelia soon.

 

[PandaDarling]

Trundle always does dumb stuff like that.

I do sort of follow Daniel's reasoning that we should just do the d1 lynch on someone inactive. Learned that lesson the hard way by letting Dolby slip through with silence in past games. Considering there has only been spam and inactivity, there's not much to go on here. I haven't played with most of the new players in the game, so I have to do some research.

Will day be extended at all due to half the game being inactive?

i understand Daniels reasoning but why do after Starry for inactivity when theres half of the plays that have been more inactive then them even just with her 1 post theres others that haven't posted at all...

- - - Post Merge - - -

so pretty much his reason contradict itself if he wants to lynch the most inactive person it would no be Starry.

 

[Damniel]

i understand Daniels reasoning but why do after Starry for inactivity when theres half of the plays that have been more inactive then them even just with her 1 post theres others that haven't posted at all...

- - - Post Merge - - -

so pretty much his reason contradict itself if he wants to lynch the most inactive person it would no be Starry.

The only ones who literally haven't posted at all are aelia and piichu, and piichu is banned and aelia hasn't been online for like a week so I'm not worrying about them.

 

[Trojan]

you guys have to understand, the only good vote right now is danny.

 

[Minties]

you guys have to understand, the only good vote right now is danny.

And why's that?

 

[PandaDarling]

you guys have to understand, the only good vote right now is danny.

care to explain?

 

[Damniel]

you guys have to understand, the only good vote right now is danny.

If you're going to bring me up as a lynch candidate, the least you could do is make an actually case instead of senseless blurts and accusations of me being scum.

 

[PandaDarling]

i agree.... trojan can yu put at least a few sentences together so we can understand your thought process.... if not it just seems scummy.

 

[EpicGamer12]

It's not dumb stuff. You instantly pointed out Daniel's town behaviour as scum behaviour and I do not believe from his posts that he is mafia. I think the fact that you are completely off putting my post without any reason behind it shows you have something to hide. I can understand the Starry lynch for sure because it creates confusion in every game. I'm not sure why hosts let him into games because they can't even play, it's pretty ridiculous to me.

Regardless, your reaction was very scummy in my opinion, m30w_. If you are lynched today you will surely be struck down eventually for your refusal to reason based on behaviour.

 

[Damniel]

I see I'm set to be lyched, and I still don't know why. I have like no case on me expect meow's suspicions which doesn't have a lot of merit. I'd rather not let town get a mislynch.
Starry is a good candidate because:
Her inactivity will cause confusion
If she votes, she won't be online to change it which may become vital

- - - Post Merge - - -

If you guys have other candidate with a case for them to lynch, I'm all ears.

 

[PandaDarling]

I see I'm set to be lyched, and I still don't know why. I have like no case on me expect meow's suspicions which doesn't have a lot of merit. I'd rather not let town get a mislynch.
Starry is a good candidate because:
Her inactivity will cause confusion
If she votes, she won't be online to change it which may become vital

- - - Post Merge - - -

If you guys have other candidate with a case for them to lynch, I'm all ears.

so you're telling me your town and you are willing to lynch another town player cause it will make the game confusing ? you aren't saying you wanna lynch her cause you think she's scum you want to lynch her cause she won't be as active as you want her to be. i don't think thats a very town way to think, sorry.

- - - Post Merge - - -

"another town player cause it will make the game LESS confusing?" ****

 

[Kit]

I see I'm set to be lyched, and I still don't know why. I have like no case on me expect meow's suspicions which doesn't have a lot of merit. I'd rather not let town get a mislynch.
Starry is a good candidate because:
Her inactivity will cause confusion
If she votes, she won't be online to change it which may become vital

So you're saying we should lynch Starry over you because there's a chance we hit scum?
The same argument could be used to justify your lynch too, granted that we really don't have much to go off of at the moment.
What I really don't understand is why you're so hard-pressed to take Starry down?
I'm going to have to place a real vote on someone soon, but it won't matter because you got majority first. Unless someone unvotes you.
Honestly D1 really didn't turn out very much and if I'm to be honest, I don't think either of you are scum. Starry seems like a more likely candidate in my eyes and at least we'd be ridding ourselves of a barely-active player. But, once again, my vote won't make a difference.
It's up to the rest of you I guess. There was that m3ow case Trundle brought up earlier I believe (I didn't actually check and see one, just saw that's where he placed his vote) that might be worth looking into in the next day cycle if we don't have anything else to discuss..
Feeling really indifferent towards this whole thing at the moment. I'd like to see some more activity from the quiet/almost inactive players... Like Minties has been saying, we're at a real disadvantage today with almost HALF the playerlist inactive.

 

[Damniel]

so you're telling me your town and you are willing to lynch another town player cause it will make the game confusing ? you aren't saying you wanna lynch her cause you think she's scum you want to lynch her cause she won't be as active as you want her to be. i don't think thats a very town way to think, sorry.

- - - Post Merge - - -

"another town player cause it will make the game LESS confusing?" ****

I have been saying she's scum? But if she isn't it's will help us anyways.

More town may be beneficial, but inactivity is just harmful to town in every game.

Also possible results in Starry's lynch:
She's scum, good.
She's a townie/unlynchable, she becomes a stump and her inactivity won't confuse us.
She's a blue role, but she wouldn't be active to actually send in the action so it's not to harmful.

 

[glow]

It's not dumb stuff. You instantly pointed out Daniel's town behaviour as scum behaviour and I do not believe from his posts that he is mafia. I think the fact that you are completely off putting my post without any reason behind it shows you have something to hide. I can understand the Starry lynch for sure because it creates confusion in every game. I'm not sure why hosts let him into games because they can't even play, it's pretty ridiculous to me.

Regardless, your reaction was very scummy in my opinion, m30w_. If you are lynched today you will surely be struck down eventually for your refusal to reason based on behaviour.

when I first accused Daniel I wasn't sure at all (and I still am not). just wanted to see some reactions. I didn't write your post off without reason, I stated that just because he's joking around doesn't mean he's town. Like I said, he was lynched D1 in the reindeer game as mafia so I think it's safe to assume he would play differently if he was mafia again

Plus nearly everyone has been joking around/shtposting, that's not the best evidence to use for someone being town

I'm confused by that 2nd part, my reaction to what? my response to you voting me, or to your reply about Daniel? I figured you just voted me 'cause of my accusation of Daniel, but I don't understand how that could be scummy. I was trying to see how him/everyone would respond, that's why I phrased it as a joke

 

[Damniel]

@Kitler
There's still an hour until lynch, there's still time for votes to change.

 

[N e s s]

Vote count

StarryWolf-5
-Call me Daniel
-White Claw
-reyy
-Kit
-Minties

Call me Daniel-4
-Trojan
-M3ow_
-Panda
-Oath2order

M3ow_-1
-Trundle
-Oath2order

Players not voting
Dolby, Lucanosa, Mother of all llamas, JelloFishXD, StarryWolf, Haydenn(Being replaced) Aelia

Currently, StarryWolf is set to be lynched. You have aproximately 1 hour left to lynch.​

 

[PandaDarling]

I have been saying she's scum? But if she isn't it's will help us anyways.

More town may be beneficial, but inactivity is just harmful to town in every game.

Also possible results in Starry's lynch:
She's scum, good.
She's a townie/unlynchable, she becomes a stump and her inactivity won't confuse us.
She's a blue role, but she wouldn't be active to actually send in the action so it's not to harmful.

you did say she's scum ? how has she been scum so far ?

 

[Damniel]

Since not all the players have posted(maybe they didn't know the game started or haven't bothered), I'd say starry is actually a good lynch. Reason being she only posted once saying she was going to be away. Why would she bother to post if she's not going to be here? Maybe it's to avoid detection when people wondered why she's not active(she does have boarding school but it seems like she's just giving an excuse). Either she shows little interest in this game to actually play all the way, or she's just scum trying to go under the radar. Even if she is town, she'd be a good lynch. Since her constant inactivity usually just confusing town on what she's doing.

Kinda going off on the little we have besides the sht posting, but my point on her confusing town regardless of alignment is from post games.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Do only townies get stumped and blue tiles just die? Or do all town get stumped?

- - - Post Merge - - -



It's only the 2nd half of day one though

You quoted this even panda?