Mafia [GAME THREAD] Karen Mafia (Endgame - Mafia Wins)
- Thread starter Geoni
- Start date
strong disagree on arstotzkan -- they had a scumlean. it was me. they didn't vote for me. if you understand my points, why dodge this one? she flat out admitted to leaning me
but this is the exact same thing that you mention, despite me repeating exactly why i tried to avert the game away from everyone claiming they aren't sure and others suggesting rng votes
not understanding how ace is weak scumread and mog isn't, with arguably less content than tensu/evan. i also don't grasp the townlean on ronishy and guava when really they haven't contributed much either.
epona shifted onto dedenne to save antonio, but believed both were town
glow i can't say for certain, but i genuinely do not believe glow is maf this game. settling for the option of two people is straight up false dichotomy, glow pointed what epona did (see above) out. there's been weak participation, but i find it incredibly hard to believe that maf would lead an elim on dedenne d1 to draw attention to themselves when everyone was running around like chickens w/ their head cut off. it's easy to be opportunistic during that and join in
FYI quick musings from yesterday and quick read this morning. Detailed one will come later.
Epona--In the last game I Sr epona but she turned out town. Im finding her difficult to read.
Ace-Where are you? We need you to Karen on giving your insight.
Tensu- my thoughts from last night were you need to come out of endless's shadow as I got picked for the same thing. I need to iso you soon.
Aerious vs kat is heating up.
Antonio- after day 1, I gave you the benefit of doubt but from now on I will be more critical on you.
Evan- your first post started with a joke? It's not a good way to make an entry. Not sure how believable is that you forgot as this is a serious game with time commitments. I would say beware of reading reports as you might be influenced by their view of events.
Epona--In the last game I Sr epona but she turned out town. Im finding her difficult to read.
Ace-Where are you? We need you to Karen on giving your insight.
Tensu- my thoughts from last night were you need to come out of endless's shadow as I got picked for the same thing. I need to iso you soon.
Aerious vs kat is heating up.
Antonio- after day 1, I gave you the benefit of doubt but from now on I will be more critical on you.
Evan- your first post started with a joke? It's not a good way to make an entry. Not sure how believable is that you forgot as this is a serious game with time commitments. I would say beware of reading reports as you might be influenced by their view of events.
i've explained this a thousand times and it's kind of annoying that you've missed it but you've kept going on about it multiple times while i was asleep so allow me to direct you to my response to glow:
girl where was the back and forth? i replied to one post about that saying i disagreed with the 'kill strong players' angle. there were no further posts about it from me
Post automatically merged:
also i just woke up but from reading through i'm definitely more convinced by the kat case than the glow case. i just don't really see why scum!glow would bring up a weak, easily-shot down case on dedenne as the very first substantial case of the game when she could have just rode it out and waited for someone else to bring something to the table. that said, she did make a caveat post:
day is too short tbh
i think i know mafia but like if i case them it'll be a total of two sentences long ^_^
and these kind of posts always really grate me because i'm like just say it with your chest
but i guess it also comes across as just thinking out loud which usually comes from a town perspective
Last edited:
did endless just say he's voting me cos i voted town and "haven't been responding to questions exactly"
lol ngl i expected like... more... if he's trying to mislynch me... make it fun ^_^
anywho
endless is definitely playing this sr of me weirdly and i'm not sure what that means
i would like to hear more from kat, i kinda took her out of my townreads bc i dunno how compatible they all are with each other so yep
i'm gonna b voting Evan because his thread entrance was clunky and it doesn't seem reasonable to me that he has three scumreads when uhhhh ive been here the whole game and i find it incredibly difficult to narrow teams as this point
also he should have been mod killed??? or did i miss something.
at*
ugh it just bothers me that he hasn't read like, you signed up for the time commitment to the game which has been INCREDIBLY slow compared to others (where d1 can be 80-100 pages) and you missed an entire phase so the least you could do is catch up i don't even care as much about what you contribute but i don't think town benefits anything from having someone who's reliant upon a summary of d1 to formulate reads
i never fill these out lmao..
lol ngl i expected like... more... if he's trying to mislynch me... make it fun ^_^
Post automatically merged:
anywho
endless is definitely playing this sr of me weirdly and i'm not sure what that means
i would like to hear more from kat, i kinda took her out of my townreads bc i dunno how compatible they all are with each other so yep
i'm gonna b voting Evan because his thread entrance was clunky and it doesn't seem reasonable to me that he has three scumreads when uhhhh ive been here the whole game and i find it incredibly difficult to narrow teams as this point
also he should have been mod killed??? or did i miss something.
Post automatically merged:
at*
Post automatically merged:
ugh it just bothers me that he hasn't read like, you signed up for the time commitment to the game which has been INCREDIBLY slow compared to others (where d1 can be 80-100 pages) and you missed an entire phase so the least you could do is catch up i don't even care as much about what you contribute but i don't think town benefits anything from having someone who's reliant upon a summary of d1 to formulate reads
Post automatically merged:
i never fill these out lmao..
Last edited:
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
Sorry I got caught up with the fair event, but I'm here.
Endless you are super close of becoming the next target of SPAAM, yes we have nothing going on in the sense that we are repairing ourselves, but your arguments against me are the same over and over, no matter what I do, but is okay, I always encourage people to try.
About glow, for me it made sense at the time, and like I said I don't regret my vote, the only thing that is strange is that I set the first vote, but glow explained napping. So no biggie there. For once in my life I'm not reading glow as scum, so I really don't want to go there.
Endless you are super close of becoming the next target of SPAAM, yes we have nothing going on in the sense that we are repairing ourselves, but your arguments against me are the same over and over, no matter what I do, but is okay, I always encourage people to try.
About glow, for me it made sense at the time, and like I said I don't regret my vote, the only thing that is strange is that I set the first vote, but glow explained napping. So no biggie there. For once in my life I'm not reading glow as scum, so I really don't want to go there.
i feel like endless centering his scumread off me around me mislynching dedenne and townreading epona for defending dedenne is so weak
which... i just.... huh
**on
i didn't even read this before my posts on evan but i vibe so hard w it
which... i just.... huh
Post automatically merged:
**on
Post automatically merged:
i didn't even read this before my posts on evan but i vibe so hard w it
Last edited:
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
Seriously please don't take this the wrong way Endless, but everyone is saying why Volt and not Endless as N1 kill, well, I feel your reads atm are a little weak, specially in glow that you are voting for, so maybe there is a reason you are still alive, and I'm mentioning this because this game is a mix of new and old players, so yeah meta is good, but not everyone have it, because of that I will be trying to not used meta as my strongest argument, because it won't take us anywhere.
Also brings up my next topic, I don't do walls and super insightful reads, that is Epona's work, this is your first game with me, so is understandable that you don't know my playstyle, but the only reason I'm saying al of this is because I still can scum lean you, and I want to see if you can brought up a stronger argument, because right now, I'm not even close of wanting to vote glow off, Antonio is saying there is a lack of solving on glow's part, but for me this is the same glow I have played with before, so that meta is non existent.
And again I apologize if this comes up as rude, never my intention.
Also brings up my next topic, I don't do walls and super insightful reads, that is Epona's work, this is your first game with me, so is understandable that you don't know my playstyle, but the only reason I'm saying al of this is because I still can scum lean you, and I want to see if you can brought up a stronger argument, because right now, I'm not even close of wanting to vote glow off, Antonio is saying there is a lack of solving on glow's part, but for me this is the same glow I have played with before, so that meta is non existent.
And again I apologize if this comes up as rude, never my intention.
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
I have quoted glow's post from another game in the the thread so please tell me how the meta is not existent.
Post automatically merged:
I mean, the difference is hugely noticeable.
To Antonio "This started to feel like a rosh read explanation and then led into an cover up to a situation no one was thinking. Like, no one was implying that mafia would do that so why did you imply they wouldn't? I don't see how that's relevant to the first sentence in the quote?"
Your quote to glow. I see nothing wrong with it, she is explaining it more clearly.
Me, Tensu and glow lol. I wouldn't say they were coming to my defense, they are giving their reason for tr me.
The scum team links are weak at the moment Antonio. Im looking into who is trying to get into my good books. Me and glow might be on a similar wavelength, but I will go after if she slips up.
Tensu- I was SL by you at the beginning to a firm Tl, wow I have improved in your eyes.
Aerious--good point on glow, but she had a good point on Evan.
Endless-- if endless gets hit, then we have to analyse the hell out of his reads, but if he is super maf he might be the pied Piper.
Your quote to glow. I see nothing wrong with it, she is explaining it more clearly.
Me, Tensu and glow lol. I wouldn't say they were coming to my defense, they are giving their reason for tr me.
The scum team links are weak at the moment Antonio. Im looking into who is trying to get into my good books. Me and glow might be on a similar wavelength, but I will go after if she slips up.
Tensu- I was SL by you at the beginning to a firm Tl, wow I have improved in your eyes.
Aerious--good point on glow, but she had a good point on Evan.
Endless-- if endless gets hit, then we have to analyse the hell out of his reads, but if he is super maf he might be the pied Piper.
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
Because if you go to the last games we have played, Glow was town, and it's similar to this.
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Her explanation is irrelevant to the first statement. I don't see how that fits, it's implying something that wasn't implied before.
Post automatically merged:
I'll look at their posts and see for myselfm
Post automatically merged:
Last game, Glow was scum and their meta fits their meta here. @Ace Marvel
Yall keep implying that glow meta was the same like the previous game, which I agree with. What I don't agree with is that Glow was Town in that game, he was roleblocker mafia aligned.
Well tbf my post sussing you D1 was more of a reaction test than an actual firm scum lean and I feel like it served it’s purpose. And also your posts have been way better lately imo so that too
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
No, I wasn’t clear in my subjects there, sorry. The sheeping comment was in reference to ronishy.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
I may have only been here since D2 started but that doesn’t mean I can’t give opinions at all. Rn those three are pinging me the most. Guav@ too now that I think of it. Just due to how much they piggyback you/@like your posts for little reason
tbh im kind of put off by this.
i want to believe endless is town but it rlly just doesn't make sense. he's had some of the most detailed posts re: game reads/game in general and he's town reading me and epona (who i sus on gut reasons more than anything else) and scumread antonio who legit doesn't appear scummy to me, just a bit erratic if anything.
if i were maf i would've immediately taken this dude out so i'm like.. hunny why r u still here??? r u scum??
i just like posts baby.
i've always said don't read into my likes bcos they literally are me liking the post detached from gameplay. they're meaningless and if u wanna sr me for that go ahead but look @ any of my mafia games and i'm liking **** up and down. i've actually had to tone it down bcos everyone loves reading way too deep into it.
Post automatically merged:
hi do u have any ideas for why scum would want to keep him around if he rlly is town?
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
I like some of the points Endless made here but I have a real big issue with their glow read. Even though we share the opinion that glow is likely scum, Endless’s reasons read almost like she should be put in nulls. Like cover up the red glow part and read the paragraph he wrote - would you have assumed that was a scum read? I wouldn’t have and that’s a problem. It feels like this read is hedging a lot
This doesn’t mean I think endless is scum now too but I am reevaluating because some of these reads very much rub me the wrong way
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
You are right, that game is too chaotic to count, I was thinking of the Shawo game (miller) and the other one before that.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
Don't like to ***** about irl but here goes.
Dad invited me here over discord and I’ve generally eschewed mafia games for a long time now for a variety of reasons, not the least of which is that I work full time now + OT so I don’t generally have much time to actually *be* here. With my weekend stacked (including celebrating my IRL dad’s birthday) I simply forgot I signed up. But now I’m attempting to make an effort here best I can. Be gentle with me
Also I like to meme post a decent bit as anyone who’s played with me can attest to
Similar threads
