Mafia Greek Cultists Mafia: Cult Surrenders! Town Wins!

[Geoni]

Dad you ever gonna come back and speak? I already did and I don't feel like putting in the effort to do it again when clearly it's impossible to get anything across to him.

Been busy yesterday and in a cleaning frenzy today, y'all are posting a lot of stuff that's draining to read (I'm looking at you Ness). Until I actually get the energy and motivation to make a decent post, uh...what justice has said this past day or so.

 

[N e s s]

Been busy yesterday and in a cleaning frenzy today, y'all are posting a lot of stuff that's draining to read (I'm looking at you Ness). Until I actually get the energy and motivation to make a decent post, uh...what justice has said this past day or so.

yes i know and i'm sorry for that abomination i created.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Been busy yesterday and in a cleaning frenzy today, y'all are posting a lot of stuff that's draining to read (I'm looking at you Ness). Until I actually get the energy and motivation to make a decent post, uh...what justice has said this past day or so.

I'm guessing you haven't read the whole me being suspicious of justice thing then?

 

[radical6]

Explain how this idea is bad then, yeah?

i literally said so why last night

i remember why i hate playing mafia

 

[Geoni]

I have read into where both of you are coming from, Sarasa. I'm debating on whether or not to make clear my reads in thread, what with this being a PM game. I haven't played a PM game in some time.

 

[radical6]

How much mafia experience do you have?3 forums worth, rip.
Now that we're further into the day, Who would you like to be lynched the most?As of now, justice, though it isn't a strong scum read at all. The whole thing with it being a low percentage of electing a president, therefore, we shouldn't worry too much about it still rubs me the wrong way, and when they were like "what the hell no", it made me go "eh" b/c they said they said that we shouldn't worry about it after the fact, which is?? Also, the fact that they voted Ender for seemingly little reason isn't giving me a good vibe at all.

PB I feel like had reason to be like how they were just now, so my suspicion of them isn't really that high. I'd like to see their reply to my cop reply, though.

Whats your favorite mystery book?I don't read mystery that often, but 39 clues was a pretty good series iirc. Just read a German mystery book called Haifishe in der Spree that was kinda hilarious, so there's that too.

@Ness First off, I don't really think the arguments against me there were really established already.
Second off, do you think PB is the most likely to be cult, or...?

lol
your reasons for wanting to lynch me are so incredibly weak and i expected better

you are not gullible. youre looking for an easy lynch that you believed i would actually tell dylan im cult 5 mins into the game. do you realize how stupid that sounds?

you ignore everything i posted and expect me to explain everything AGAIN.

i want you lynched because to be honest youre getting on my nerves. first you propose a stupid goddamn idea

you yell at me for saying we HAVE A GREATER CHANCR OF ELECTING TOWN AS PREZ

YET you want to tell the prez our ****ing roles???

your plan is stupid as ****. people will be converted. it will do nothing to narrow down roles. prez WILL leak roles regardless. its risky and useless and will do nothing to help us. and if pres is cult? lol

i have no idea why ness thinks youre a good prez when you are so ****ing gullible and came up with the most useless stupid plan ive ever seen. get off your high horse.

 

[Arstotzkan]

i think it is silly to write the prez off of as 100% town, but i also find it unlikely we will elect cult. if we do, we can always monitor them.

Just gonna note that I found this, so one of my earlier points are kinda invalid b/c of this

 

[radical6]

my wifi sucks be patient



i haven't concluded anything but i think she's acting extremely suspicious
i don't care who president is as long as it isn't kat

umm we all know that kat is 100000% town and if you dont answer to her or ness youre a ****ing scumlord obviously

- - - Post Merge - - -

jeez maybe if YOU READ WHAT I ****ING POST you would realize that everything you said about me is ****ing stupid, useless, and irrelevant.

you are looking for an easy scapegoat. im still amazed you believed anything dylan posted. that was obvious bait. you yell at me for being too "careless" about who prez is yet you WANT US TO TELL THEM OUR ROLES

do you not see how contradictory that is?

- - - Post Merge - - -

how the **** is PB suspicious? theyve barely posted. theyre a quiet person.

you have a big nerve calling PB a town idiot when you yourself ness have been nothing but attacking people for no reason lmao

also stop using she/her for me

also the thing dylan posted? thats a joke. i **** with him. hes my friend. i **** with him every single game. i said that nearly a hour into the game.

if you actually think that was real then oh my god

he even told me it was bait for you idiots, and asked me not to post. so i didnt. i didnt expect anyone to actually believe it when i literally said i wanted dylan lynched before he posted anything.

you should be able to tell its an obvious joke, jesus christ.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Justice, first, please calm down. You resorting to insults is doing nothing.

Second off, I legitimately can't find your reason why my vote would be a bad idea. I didn't say that without looking for a post. I'm sorry I'm unobservant apparently, but..

I never even listed your **** with Dad as a reason to lynch you there. I'm not sure why you're bringing that up.

I didn't yell at you for saying Town has a greater chance of electing president. I yelled at you for two reasons:
A. I thought you were saying that we shouldn't look into Pres at all once elected b/c they had a high chance of being town. As I just quoted, I was mistaken in you believing that.
B. You were saying that we shouldn't worry before the election at first, then after that you said we shouldn't worry about it afterwards. Perhaps you're bad at wording, but I can quote you to things, if you'd like.

The President cannot be converted b/c they are immune to conversion. No **** people will be converted, but that way, the President could be able to narrow things down because there's only going to be so many cop, doc, vig, speaker, ect claims. Say if someone gets given the Speaker role, we'd know the old Speaker was converted, and lynch them because of that. In addition, we can organize our actions that way. How would Pres leak roles? A smart one wouldn't.

And if President is cult, this is why cop would check them N1, before any roles were told.

Also, your paragraphing is hard to read. Can you group some of your ideas together?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I'm not super sus of you anymore, my main gripe was the one that went away with that quote I found, but I still don't like your vote for Ender.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Gonna be completely honest here, but Kit, justice, and Ness, your posts hurt my brain. They're not formatted in such a way that's easy to read at all.

 

[EnderWiggin]

She voted for me because I'm awesome.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ftr I'm going to be here for the next hour so feel free to throw whatever at me.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Disclaimer: Responses will not be fast as I'm trying to reread at the same time.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dolby:

If I were to send in who I'd lynch prior to the end of president voting, in case I win, would that count?

Asking because I'll probably have just finished having my wisdom teeth removed at day end and therefore will probably be not coherent in any way to actually send a lynch in in the hour after day end.

 

[radical6]

no, i have every right to be pissed, because you and the rest of you idiots who believed that **** proved my point. you have no excuse to have believed that. it only shows youre either

1) really ****ing gullible
2) looking for an easy lynch

and no. it doesnt matter if we elect a "good" prez. they will leak. this is a PM game. unless they swear to not talk to anyone, they will always leak. no matter how good they are, that info will end in bad hands.

 

[LaBelleFleur]

My brain seriously hurts from reading all of that salty illogical messy meta-filled junk, holy.

Okay. So. Presidency. I'm voting for Kat. Why? Because she's the only one besides justice (and Oath, to a degree) who's actually making any sense. She's questioning people and bringing up new points and answering the questions asked of her. The rest of you lot (looking, N e s s, Kit & StarryWolf) are just bickering and I can't even begin to wrap my head around it right now.

Another point about the presidency: I'm questioning anyone who votes for or suggests Dad or Ender as president. Yes, they're both strong players, and would make good presidents, if they were town. But neither of them have really posted anything, and if you're supporting either of them, you're just going off of meta and I'm judging you. (I'm really sorry about your cat, Ender. )

Need to read back through to get a better idea of a lynch candidate... the thought of reading through all of that BS again makes me want to throw my computer out the window. But definitely town-reading Kat & justice, and questioning JellofishXD for this post alone:

- - - Post Merge - - -

Why would you be a good president? I would listen to the others, my vote would be on others opinions.So even if I was scum, it would go on the chat/what other people think
Who would you lynch day 1? No one yet, but once again it would be on what the majority want.
If you had a nuke, would you detonate it? honestly I'm not sure, too much of a rushed choice
Read through SO much but only this post stood out to me like why would you say that about if you WERE scum, still too early but seems suspicious to me

You couldn't scream evasive any louder if you'd tried.

Also, Trojan, Rune: You've both been pretty quiet. Who's your prime lynch candidate right now? Rune, who would you want for president?

 

[Arstotzkan]

no, i have every right to be pissed, because you and the rest of you idiots who believed that **** proved my point. you have no excuse to have believed that. it only shows youre either

1) really ****ing gullible
2) looking for an easy lynch

and no. it doesnt matter if we elect a "good" prez. they will leak. this is a PM game. unless they swear to not talk to anyone, they will always leak. no matter how good they are, that info will end in bad hands.

You don't because this is a game. There's no reason to actually go offending people because this has no actual bearing on anything outside this game.

Like I said, I didn't read the second part at first. And once I did, it cleared things up for me and I saw it as a joke.

Pres will leak? What do you think about Endless practically being the President of Sins mafia, then? Why did that work, but this won't?

- - - Post Merge - - -

There wasn't a "President" role, but he practically was one.

 

[EnderWiggin]

Another point about the presidency: I'm questioning anyone who votes for or suggests Dad or Ender as president. Yes, they're both strong players, and would make good presidents, if they were town. But neither of them have really posted anything, and if you're supporting either of them, you're just going off of meta and I'm judging you. (I'm really sorry about your cat, Ender. )

I'll have you know that I'd be a good president even if I was cult! It's in my genes! Authority befits me!

A vote for Ender is a vote for the end of day!

That makes sense right?

(Thank you. ><)

- - - Post Merge - - -

and no. it doesnt matter if we elect a "good" prez. they will leak. this is a PM game. unless they swear to not talk to anyone, they will always leak. no matter how good they are, that info will end in bad hands.

I agree with a lot of your points, Justice, but gonna point out that this isn't necessarily true.

I've pulled off "Leader" rolls where I had all kinds of information and didn't leak any of it. It's a matter of how you talk to people.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also you can "Leak" things and then laugh.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I mean, tricking mafia into thinking you've given them key information is literally my special move.

See my first game here where I lead everyone on a merry chase for my actual role.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Tbh 90% of my pres campaign is a joke.

 

[Arstotzkan]

I mean, tricking mafia into thinking you've given them key information is literally my special move.

See my first game here where I lead everyone on a merry chase for my actual role.

God damn you and your Vet/Doc shenanigans

It won us the game at least.

 

[radical6]

you guys realize this is tbt were talking about

i have no problem believing you or abe have pulled off leader roles before without harmimg town

but our canidates?

oath - will trust wrong person probably, or trust a town player who will then go tell maf

dylan- he always end sup telling me **** he shouldnt be telling

especially when im maf

lol

sarasa - easily gullible, will probably tell domeone they 10000% think is town who turns out to be cult


therefore, i only see ender as a viable choice, and even then i see no point in telling him our roles. whats he gonna do with the knowledge that there are 6 townies? how will that help him determine any countrr claims? we know nothing. no one is dead yet. people will be converted

 

[EnderWiggin]

God damn you and your Vet/Doc shenanigans

It won us the game at least.

That was so fun.

don't forget, I was "Doc Saved Blue" in there too

 

[N e s s]

Lololol this game is going bananas over me right now

I gotta say i love how i'm going to be lynched if anything because everybody wants me dead

- - - Post Merge - - -

But i already look crazy enough, so i'll do a defense later about justice <3

 

[EnderWiggin]

therefore, i only see ender as a viable choice, and even then i see no point in telling him our roles. whats he gonna do with the knowledge that there are 6 townies? how will that help him determine any countrr claims? we know nothing. no one is dead yet. people will be converted

Cop scrying cult is good tho.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Kinda back now, anything big happen?