Mafia Greek Cultists Mafia: Cult Surrenders! Town Wins!

[N e s s]

Hmmmm thats interesting. Im gonna have to go with benefit of the doubt and trust Sarasa. But Pillow Bunny is really sus now. I think Pillow is probably the biggest suspect.

@Ender Why do you think Ness is 90% goon. Not saying I don't or do find him sus, but 90% is quite a lot.

Exactly, thats what i'm curious about.

I'm not exactly going to fight back with you ender or start a pointless argument like i did early game, because i do find you to be town. I don't see any which way of you finding a way to bus Oath, so i think you're basically comfirmed now.

I can't exactly prove anything either way, but i will say that you can't press a button and see my perspective of things. I'm going to leave you with this, i am a Townie.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, i'd like to take a second to point out that Oath also called Me, SarasaKat and LaBelle. That should say a little bit about my alignment. If not, lets talk.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Nah Oath, you were definitely sus. Acting like you're doing something and not doing something is definitely reason to suspect.
Nice job, though ^-^

@PB I know it isn't in the role list, but good god if I didn't know any better, I'd think you were Exe with me as your target. I'll reply to your other stuff soon - gotta read up.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Aaand I gotta to eat. NEVER MIND.

 

[Kit]

Had to do like 2 hours of math homework and now a 4+ hour assignment for English. Due tomorrow for like 75% of our grade.
oath is dead okay wait what did I miss.
also gj

- - - Post Merge - - -

welp i want my money now
remember like that joke "oh oath is mafia thing" i threw around day one
i'm a physic apparently

nothing else to say really.. anybody got anything on pb? I'd like to see a quote post from someone.
i'd do it but hw so

 

[Arstotzkan]

What's happening is that I was boss and for some reason Oath survived Day 1 where we should have just won easily.

Also if there were 2 cult to start then Ness is 90% the goon.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Note:

THE CURRENT SPEAKER OF THE SENATE SHOULD ALWAYS CLAIM TO SARASA

Because the instant they get converted, a new Speaker is assigned and therefore we can autolynch the previous one.

Also Granny also claim to Sarasa.

Because Granny is the other safe.

Guys, this is basically what my plan would have done, and I don't get why you guys were so against it?

@Ender Ness is fine. I think we need to look at the people who're on the down-low.

And, if we're going to be completely clear with the record. Ness wasn't the first to know my role. LaBelle was.

@PB Were you in Kissing to Be Clever? I'm not entirely sure if you were, but basically that game, Dad did exactly what you're saying I'm doing right now. Get all of the other cultists lynched to "make myself appear town". If by chance there's another cop, they're free to check me. Long story short: it didn't work. I'm not an idiot lol? In a game where the whole thing depends on conversions, why would I take down my numbers?

But you literally have no actual in game evidence as to why I'm scum. The only reason you've come up with is that you don't like the plan I came up with. And I'm aware I quoted that, but I'm saying why the hell would I say that in thread if I were scum? I would have checked with Dolby in scum chat first. (yeah, yeah, we know the answer is WIFOM, so take everything with a grain of salt I guess). But seriously, you don't have any actual evidence.

I'll get the quote for ya. Brb.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Why would you have everyone tell roles to someone and then check them on the same night? If you thought that's what I meant, I never thought that oml. That'd be really bad.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm not really dancing around it? I'm answering your questions.

From my POV, it feels like you've been the one dancing around, actually. You say it's sus, I ask how, you said it's b/c I didn't consider cop check, I say I did, but then you go back to "but then they were right for the wrong reasons" and still kept believing I was scum without offering anything else up. I can see where you could have been confused though with the details of the cop check.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Not to mention the part where you said I should have defended with a point that hadn't even been attacked.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Aand you leave before you admit I have a point. Of course.

There ya go PB.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Just to make it clearer:

Speaker of the House/Charon, I'd appreciate it if you could share your role with me via PM. This goes to if you ever receive the Speaker role in the future as well.

 

[Kit]

Guys, this is basically what my plan would have done, and I don't get why you guys were so against it?

@Ender Ness is fine. I think we need to look at the people who're on the down-low.

And, if we're going to be completely clear with the record. Ness wasn't the first to know my role. LaBelle was.

@PB Were you in Kissing to Be Clever? I'm not entirely sure if you were, but basically that game, Dad did exactly what you're saying I'm doing right now. Get all of the other cultists lynched to "make myself appear town". If by chance there's another cop, they're free to check me. Long story short: it didn't work. I'm not an idiot lol? In a game where the whole thing depends on conversions, why would I take down my numbers?

But you literally have no actual in game evidence as to why I'm scum. The only reason you've come up with is that you don't like the plan I came up with. And I'm aware I quoted that, but I'm saying why the hell would I say that in thread if I were scum? I would have checked with Dolby in scum chat first. (yeah, yeah, we know the answer is WIFOM, so take everything with a grain of salt I guess). But seriously, you don't have any actual evidence.

I'll get the quote for ya. Brb.

- - - Post Merge - - -



There ya go PB.

guys if Sars was scum they would have lynched me n1 after my RC and would have said something like "i don't believe you"
what even is this argument imo.

 

[N e s s]

guys if Sars was scum they would have lynched me n1 after my RC and would have said something like "i don't believe you"
what even is this argument imo.

What

 

[Arstotzkan]

Are you confused by something I'm saying, or something PB's saying?

 

[N e s s]

No i don't know what kit just said in that?

I'm on there with the PB thing, he's acting weird.

I have someone who's interested in joining as a replacement, is it still too late?

 

[Arstotzkan]

I was asking Kit that riip

- - - Post Merge - - -

Just realized my name isn't in the list of players playing RIP.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, pretty sure your D1/N1/D2/N2 links are broken. Keeps bringing me to the last page posted on

 

[Dolby]

Also, pretty sure your D1/N1/D2/N2 links are broken. Keeps bringing me to the last page posted on

They work fine for me. They bring me to the page that the posts are on. Is anyone else experiencing this problem?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I have someone who's interested in joining as a replacement, is it still too late?

They can join as a replacement if somebody drops out

- - - Post Merge - - -

post glitch

 

[Kit]

What

sry ness im half awake fml
Trying to say that Kat can't be scum because they didnt lynch me when they had the chance
He could have done it and easily passed it off as "oh well she was actin sus anyway oopies" while getting rid of someone you cannot convert.

 

[N e s s]

@Dolby hold on, i'll test it

- - - Post Merge - - -

Works fine for me

 

[Trojan]

I think I might just vote for pillow tomorrow. Just YOLO it.

 

[N e s s]

I think I might just vote for pillow tomorrow. Just YOLO it.

Are you certain of pillow bunny being mafia?

 

[Trojan]

Are you certain of pillow bunny being mafia?

almost.

 

[Trojan]

Are you certain of pillow bunny being mafia?

almost.

- - - Post Merge - - -

damn that double post

 

[Geoni]

Either pb is cult or they're really dumb town, but I remember earlier this game that when I was about to make my reads on pb but neglected to because my reads were on other people, one of the things that got pb caught back when we were mafia together was that they made what was to seem like a helpful, objective post early in the game to make themselves seem town and that's exactly what they got suspected and eventually lynched over (reactions too). Also am I the only one getting a glitch where if they advance search a specific player's post they get sent back to the forum home page? Trying to look through some of pb's posts and find the post I was thinking about earlier.

Also, Dolby, if the wealthy landowner dies does that mean cult can't convert people anymore or use influence points or whatever?

- - - Post Merge - - -

the cop check is basically meaningless
- if the president is cult leader they find out who cop is day 1 and convert them night 1. cop is now on the cult's side, pres covers for them, we die
- if president is town the cop can't announce that anyways
- cult member who is converted night 1 (or cult leader) can pretend they're cop and check the president to lynch them, which is indistinguishable from the above case

Found it.

 

[Trojan]

mhmhmmhmhmhm Pillow bby. You in some deep trouble

 

[Geoni]

Okay here's pillow's kissing to be clever post that I was talking about earlier:

Okay, so here?s four scenarios about what?s going on with Endless and Forek:

1. Endless is town, Forek is mafia.

• This is what seems to be happening based on their interactions, but there?s no way to confirm it.

2. Endless and Forek are both mafia.

• I?m assuming their argument at the beginning was fake, but it escalated too much, so if Endless didn?t vote for Forek it would seem suspicous
• How did Endless get all that from ?kill some KP?? Kill some KP could just mean kill some people with KP (mafia), which Forek mentioning thinking was a good idea
• If Forek flips red, Endless is essentially confirmed to be town (plus Forek being dead will probably help him regardless), but does that outweigh the loss of KP?
• They MIGHT still be fakevoting for each other, and are going to kill the next person who slips up. Endless is trying to become really influential, so if he does a couple people might follow him, plus there?s the other two(?) mafia members. Between them, they could get someone lynched
• Even though the tables have turned, I still think Endless? ?this is a good response and he?s definitely town so I?ll retract my vote? comment was really weird

4. Endless and Forek are both town.

• imo Forek seems more like a clueless noob than mafia. The only ?proof? we have is the kill some KP comment
• I think this could very well be what?s happening, but Forek probably don?t have a blue role anyways so it?s no real loss if he dies

3. Endless is mafia, Forek is town.

• Basically indistinguishable from the previous scenario
• Even if Forek does flip green, Endless would be pretty justified in voting for him, so he won?t get indicted.

This is the post I used to 'softbus'* pillow back in that game because I was stupid. My having already known pb was mafia aside, it was my plan to bus her and I needed to find some sort of post that she wasn't doing well with, and chose this one, because it read as forced (and I of course knew it was). That got Endless started off and it only went downhill from there for pb. They did these sort of theoretical posts twice in the game.

And here I am wanting to forget that game and now I gotta bring it up. : |

*softbus: what I mean by that is I didn't want to straight up lead a lynch on her, but suspect her with evidence should she get killed or lynched, making me look good. Or that was the plan.

- - - Post Merge - - -

She did*

pb you're female right?