-
Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.
Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins
- Thread starter DinoTown
- Start date
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
akkdkektkrkkg wow this makes it much clearer now
im actually dying rn
lmao wow ok i've caught up on all this live-action posting and um..
i didnt realize how many brains i was living in rent free!!!!!! <3333 housing crisis?? couldn't be me!!☝
on the real tho i genuinely just dont have much to say about everything going on!! d1 is always the worst for me and my one (1) ☝ brain cell srry </3
i didnt realize how many brains i was living in rent free!!!!!! <3333 housing crisis?? couldn't be me!!☝
on the real tho i genuinely just dont have much to say about everything going on!! d1 is always the worst for me and my one (1) ☝ brain cell srry </3
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
what about your previous readslmao wow ok i've caught up on all this live-action posting and um..
i didnt realize how many brains i was living in rent free!!!!!! <3333 housing crisis?? couldn't be me!!☝
on the real tho i genuinely just dont have much to say about everything going on!! d1 is always the worst for me and my one (1) ☝ brain cell srry </3
i was shocked ppl took me seriously??
mostly just tl you bc you're acting fairly on brand so like "eh sure why not"
other than that the geoni comment was obvi a joke too lol i said i would do it for ~*~the drama~*~ which... clearly is a joke
Geoni
You're doing great!
Pages 1-3
Can't really determine much from the entry posts on the first page or two since joking about Tom Nook or villagers or whatever is pretty nai.
First point of actual substance was really Dan digging into Dino as well as going after me.
The only thing that stands out to me in the first 50 or so posts is the probability stuff about me randing town from Ace comes out of left field, it's just something I'm mildly pinged by. I just closely read a scumgame of his and will be watching the way he joins wagons.
The vote on me by Dan doesn't ping me as town or scum yet on its own, just something that he's using as a springboard for reactions that either alignment can do. That being said, it does feel like Dan trying something new however because he didn't just begin with RQS and went the RVS route instead which feels more inventive and less like someone replicating themselves, so I didn't feel his entry was outright scummy.
Dino I think was just trying to break the ice with his comment about Poncho and Dobie and I don't think it's a buddy attempt.
Antonio/Alek (I'll call you Alek now?) had a reaction that felt like he was asking a question to process the idea brought up by Dan that felt off the cuff and genuine.
Hikari had a mixed reaction: "I think it's sus" but I'm understanding it is just how it is worded and she doesn't actually find it sus and is considerate about it being something that wasn't done out if evil intent on Dino's part.
Volt epona and guava just felt...around in these first three pages.
Doing catch up this way will probably take too long. :/
Page 4
Volt what was that 'chaotice ace go brrr' all about? It felt like a weird comment to make in the moment.
Hikari reaction to Dan going in on someone who hasn't posted yet feels okayish to me although I do feel like scum would wanna go in on Dan for doing this, out of the people criticizing him this feels genuine enough.
Alek's approach and way of reacting to things feels consistent on this page too. Starting to feel good about him.
Epona saying the probability thing is not a hill to die on...I like this comment for how it gives the impression she has made a comment like that as towny and doesn't want someone going down the wrong path about it.
Low level build since it's just four pages but I feel alrightish so far in my catch up with Alek and Hikari, alrightish but always wary with Dan and Epona.
This feels like a waste of time at best but I like vibing out first impressions of that makes any sense, will probably just have to touch on things that long me as towny or questionable for the sake of time tho, we have like half an irl day left?
Noon EST?
Can't really determine much from the entry posts on the first page or two since joking about Tom Nook or villagers or whatever is pretty nai.
First point of actual substance was really Dan digging into Dino as well as going after me.
The only thing that stands out to me in the first 50 or so posts is the probability stuff about me randing town from Ace comes out of left field, it's just something I'm mildly pinged by. I just closely read a scumgame of his and will be watching the way he joins wagons.
The vote on me by Dan doesn't ping me as town or scum yet on its own, just something that he's using as a springboard for reactions that either alignment can do. That being said, it does feel like Dan trying something new however because he didn't just begin with RQS and went the RVS route instead which feels more inventive and less like someone replicating themselves, so I didn't feel his entry was outright scummy.
Dino I think was just trying to break the ice with his comment about Poncho and Dobie and I don't think it's a buddy attempt.
Antonio/Alek (I'll call you Alek now?) had a reaction that felt like he was asking a question to process the idea brought up by Dan that felt off the cuff and genuine.
Hikari had a mixed reaction: "I think it's sus" but I'm understanding it is just how it is worded and she doesn't actually find it sus and is considerate about it being something that wasn't done out if evil intent on Dino's part.
Volt epona and guava just felt...around in these first three pages.
Doing catch up this way will probably take too long. :/
Page 4
Volt what was that 'chaotice ace go brrr' all about? It felt like a weird comment to make in the moment.
Hikari reaction to Dan going in on someone who hasn't posted yet feels okayish to me although I do feel like scum would wanna go in on Dan for doing this, out of the people criticizing him this feels genuine enough.
Alek's approach and way of reacting to things feels consistent on this page too. Starting to feel good about him.
Epona saying the probability thing is not a hill to die on...I like this comment for how it gives the impression she has made a comment like that as towny and doesn't want someone going down the wrong path about it.
Low level build since it's just four pages but I feel alrightish so far in my catch up with Alek and Hikari, alrightish but always wary with Dan and Epona.
This feels like a waste of time at best but I like vibing out first impressions of that makes any sense, will probably just have to touch on things that long me as towny or questionable for the sake of time tho, we have like half an irl day left?
Post automatically merged:
Noon EST?
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
wow geo you said the S word like 12 times despite advocating against it smh
EoD is at 4pm EST
i think these reads are a bit too early now so im more interested in general thoughts/instances that stand out, unless you plan on catching up at this pace tonight
EoD is at 4pm EST
i think these reads are a bit too early now so im more interested in general thoughts/instances that stand out, unless you plan on catching up at this pace tonight
Geoni
You're doing great!
This is sarcasm I assume?
Post automatically merged:
Ajjshdbens you're right
glow
not ur aesthetic
lol honestly i think the removal of that word should be reconsidered if we're keeping other objectively offensive terms... ik i should voice my opinions elsewhere but
anyway i need to read the response u made to me but i'm just kinda lazy cos i really don't consider you a good vote
shawo was actually posting rly good analysis but he seems so everywhere. i was thrown off by how scattered his reads were and don't actually know where he sits rn
Post automatically merged:
i agree with this post the most so far actually
glow
not ur aesthetic
weird post, assumes that alek wasn't sorting ace when he was?
Post automatically merged:
pretend day ends rn who do u vote
Post automatically merged:
BY THE WAY i am pretty sure i have an exam during when day ends.
so. i'll be placing my vote tonight (next five hours or so)? but i'll be watching the thread as much as i can
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
this was on alek trying to figure out guava
Post automatically merged:
guava is pretty open about not being interested and having nothing to say. i dont think she's trying to appear contributing she's very much clear she isn't
Post automatically merged:
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
why? it was just a joke because ace was being chaotic and i find his playstyle entertaining
Geoni
You're doing great!
Glow put a gun to my head I'd vote guava for being around in those first four pages and not saying much at all to what was going on, if I have to shoot in the dark I'll aim at the person who felt like they were hiding in it amongst the stuff Dan was making happen. I'll know how to actually feel about her once I read this thing but that's the kinda shot that hits when I don't have much to go off. This can serve as an additional note about guava I guess.
I understand it's a joke post. It was just...pinging me idk. If I have to explain it I would say it felt like you have this idea of who Ace is and why he does things rather than outright prescribing the behavior as towny or scummy. You made some notes on his meta around the time of that post, maybe that's why.
+1 to him very clearly avoiding interaction with his partners but he's been made aware of his meta in saying that so there probably will be interaction if he's woofin.
Anyways gonna resume my catch up but as an aside I looked back on the sign up thread and mafia has four members potentially which is insanely maf-sided considering godfather unless host nixxed one for balance, so it's very very important to not screw this first elimination up.
Post automatically merged:
I understand it's a joke post. It was just...pinging me idk. If I have to explain it I would say it felt like you have this idea of who Ace is and why he does things rather than outright prescribing the behavior as towny or scummy. You made some notes on his meta around the time of that post, maybe that's why.
+1 to him very clearly avoiding interaction with his partners but he's been made aware of his meta in saying that so there probably will be interaction if he's woofin.
Post automatically merged:
Anyways gonna resume my catch up but as an aside I looked back on the sign up thread and mafia has four members potentially which is insanely maf-sided considering godfather unless host nixxed one for balance, so it's very very important to not screw this first elimination up.
Last edited:
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
i’ve been thinking about it and honestly i’m struggling with who to vote for here
dedenne guava and cake feel like very lazy votes to default too so i won’t be going there
epona geoni and glow are the players i’m the most focused on solving since it would give me great peace of mind if they’re town
hikari im not familiar with and while i do find their reactions odd part of me also wants to give them an extra day
volt and ace are next most strange players to me rn. volt i’ve already explained gives me a lot of discomfort with the 6 GTH reads since i’ve done that as a wolf, and ace is just being bizzare but so bizarre i’m not seeing the wolf motive yet so idk
i mean i would probably go for one of these 3 in the end but i’m not very confident on it tbh
dedenne guava and cake feel like very lazy votes to default too so i won’t be going there
epona geoni and glow are the players i’m the most focused on solving since it would give me great peace of mind if they’re town
hikari im not familiar with and while i do find their reactions odd part of me also wants to give them an extra day
volt and ace are next most strange players to me rn. volt i’ve already explained gives me a lot of discomfort with the 6 GTH reads since i’ve done that as a wolf, and ace is just being bizzare but so bizarre i’m not seeing the wolf motive yet so idk
i mean i would probably go for one of these 3 in the end but i’m not very confident on it tbh
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
i did say i think he is town later. i think his behaviour in karen mafia was way more collect and without as much confidence as this behaviour that I both recognize as town and enjoy.
daniel question did ur teammates act the same way as you in that MU GTH and if no were they familiar with GTH
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
i actually just read back and none of my teammates were actually present for that game lol. my parents just general maintained an iffy read on me so i misremembered there
so i was the only wolf that answered and I called out 5 wolf reads
Post automatically merged:
my partners* my parents do have an iffy read on me tho tbh
Last edited:
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
shucks lol my point was going to be that just because you did doesnt mean it's a wolf thing - i mean i know that but i cant convice you lol. i am sure i said in a convo that you were around that I always assume that everyone is mafia, but whatever at this point im just being like "dude trust me"
Geoni
You're doing great!
ugh king why u are always mafia low hanging fruit
Doubly pinged tbh, this gives me undertones that you read him as town and that's what I was wondering from that first joke I pointed out as pinging me - why do you feel like you townread Ace in this moment given what was on the table so far and what you said earlier in on this page (page 5)? Unless I'm misinterpreting 'mafia low hanging fruit' here. LHF is solely a term to describe someone you suspect is towny so that's what I assume despite mafia being tacked on.
Similar threads
