Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Damniel]

shucks lol my point was going to be that just because you did doesnt mean it's a wolf thing - i mean i know that but i cant convice you lol. i am sure i said in a convo that you were around that I always assume that everyone is mafia, but whatever at this point im just being like "dude trust me"

well given i did that as wolf i can't really go like "Hmmm yeah this is town" when i know that wolves can do it

 

[Ace Marvel]

Glow put a gun to my head I'd vote guava for being around in those first four pages and not saying much at all to what was going on, if I have to shoot in the dark I'll aim at the person who felt like they were hiding in it amongst the stuff Dan was making happen. I'll know how to actually feel about her once I read this thing but that's the kinda shot that hits when I don't have much to go off. This can serve as an additional note about guava I guess.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

I understand it's a joke post. It was just...pinging me idk. If I have to explain it I would say it felt like you have this idea of who Ace is and why he does things rather than outright prescribing the behavior as towny or scummy. You made some notes on his meta around the time of that post, maybe that's why.

+1 to him very clearly avoiding interaction with his partners but he's been made aware of his meta in saying that so there probably will be interaction if he's woofin.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Anyways gonna resume my catch up but as an aside I looked back on the sign up thread and mafia has four members potentially which is insanely maf-sided considering godfather unless host nixxed one for balance, so it's very very important to not screw this first elimination up.

Am I the potential D1 kill? GOALS! you are killing town, but goals!

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Kill me! Kill me! Is the only way to prove that Damniel is mafia, so I'm on board!

 

[voltairenism]

Doubly pinged tbh, this gives me undertones that you read him as town and that's what I was wondering from that first joke I pointed out as pinging me - why do you feel like you townread Ace in this moment given what was on the table so far and what you said earlier in on this page (page 5)? Unless I'm misinterpreting 'mafia low hanging fruit' here. LHF is solely a term to describe someone you suspect is towny so that's what I assume despite mafia being tacked on.

yes geo i do townread him

well given i did that as wolf i can't really go like "Hmmm yeah this is town" when i know that wolves can do it

this is fair but if you are town think with care

 

[Geoni]

Just noticed I am misgendering you Alek, apologies for that.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

i mean it’s just a lot of back and forth so far really... that is my thoughts on everything up until now. it just feels like a lot of standard d1 chatter, and were still missing a few so...

not really much else to go on fmpov, just your very early vote that could be a bold maf move to try and hide behind a joke but i think you really were mostly joking lol

What would have been so bold about it if he is a wolf here?

View attachment 321235
my d1 meta : )

Motion denied. You will do things. You will show yourself as townie to the people you play with because that's what good townies do.

 

[Ace Marvel]

I need to work on this but is the first time I made a costume brush!

 

[Geoni]

Random note as I bread but Daniel vs Hikari doesn't feel like w/w theater so I don't think they are teamed based on the way Hikari reacted. Whether or not I think Dan had a point I'll see, but as of where I am making this comment on page 7 he doesn't entirely -feel- committed to the way he's grilling Hikari so far but I sorta share the same read a lot of others seem to in not finding her reaction that sus. Idk if it was his way of trying to figure someone out better because he doesn't know them.

Epona is laying her mindset out on this page and I felt good about it although I don't entirely agree nothing was happening.

Shawo has felt a bit meh so far and I laughed at him thinking 5 mafia in 14 player setup is balanced. Another person I hope to see more from as I catch up

 

[shawo]

guava is so odd to play with, because sometimes as town they'll have super town games where they're obvtown and find 3 mafia...

and then the other 90% of the time they play like this as town or mafia.

I think last time they did this they were town, and the time before they were mafia, so it's such an odd point to go after. There's a couple of people in this game that are hard to read, and I don't think we need to be too focused on it. A big problem I have with TBT mafia is that both town/mafia lead a lynch on someone for lack of effort rather than anything else.

I already talked about dino who I think is high-effort filler. But I would say that I still sus a couple of people who have been high effort - but I'll need to go through specific posts to put it into words. I need to do homework but I'll be back after midnight my time.

 

[Geoni]

It's hard to not do this when catching up on mobile because tab switching to note take is a pain in my backside

 

[shawo]

Random note as I bread but Daniel vs Hikari doesn't feel like w/w theater so I don't think they are teamed based on the way Hikari reacted. Whether or not I think Dan had a point I'll see, but as of where I am making this comment on page 7 he doesn't entirely -feel- committed to the way he's grilling Hikari so far but I sorta share the same read a lot of others seem to in not finding her reaction that sus. Idk if it was his way of trying to figure someone out better because he doesn't know them.

Epona is laying her mindset out on this page and I felt good about it although I don't entirely agree nothing was happening.

Shawo has felt a bit meh so far and I laughed at him thinking 5 mafia in 14 player setup is balanced. Another person I hope to see more from as I catch up

did you ignore the rest of the context?

this is an expiremental game where you can solve mafia with riddles. Depending on how easy to solve these riddles are, having 5 mafia actually makes a lot of sense. Not to mention this is an open setup with prs.

I mean it's welcoming to see you here, but your first post already told me that you didn't read what I said :/

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Ok maybe it wasn't your first post, but it was the first I read. Let me go back.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Alright I feel bad, I didn't associate your new image with you and just assumed you didn't post. Oops.

 

[Antonio]

Am I the potential D1 kill? GOALS! you are killing town, but goals!

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Kill me! Kill me! Is the only way to prove that Damniel is mafia, so I'm on board!

Why do you want to die so bad?

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

This is sarcasm I assume?

It was not, it was a poor choice of words due to distractions Look on the next page.

Also, I don't mind being misgendering but if you could, use they/them.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

No, I'm so busy streaming that my mind isn't clearly paying attention. I don't think he was "misleading" either. However, what i do find weird is him having these red flags this early.

I'm going to go back streaming

^^^

 

[voltairenism]

Why do you want to die so bad?

dont we all

 

[Antonio]

dont we all

yes but in the game sense he is obviously trying to die, I don't understand.

If you don't want to play ace, ask for a replacement.

 

[Ace Marvel]

Why do you want to die so bad?

Because if I'm a D/N1 kill means that all the other players felt threaten by my presence, which means I'm getting better, it would be a huge honor.

 

[Antonio]

Because if I'm a D/N1 kill means that all the other players felt threaten by my presence, which means I'm getting better, it would be a huge honor.

Dude, I can't stop laughing. From the Hilary Duff post to whatever the hell this is, it is hilarious.

However, it's also irrating that you ain't taking the game seriously.

 

[Ace Marvel]

If you don't want to play ace, ask for a replacement.

I do want to play, that is why I'm here, I have always said it since my first game, if me dying helps town solve the game I'm up for it. Hopefully my clue frames Damniel.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

However, it's also irrating that you ain't taking the game seriously.

Quite the contrary, I'm taking this game seriously, that is not up your standard is different, but I don't do things randomly, everything is calculated and with a motive.

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Not taking the game seriously would mean hardclaming, leave a random vote and don't come back.

 

[Antonio]

I hope your behavior pays off to what you believe it will pay off. Can you possibly provide some opinions on others?

 

[Ace Marvel]

yes but in the game sense he is obviously trying to die, I don't understand.

This is to prove a point that everybody is just wasting your time looking into a puddle, expecting it to be a lake, I'm shallow.

 

[Antonio]

This is to prove a point that everybody is just wasting your time looking into a puddle, expecting it to be a lake, I'm shallow.

I'm terrible with metaphors, can you elaborate?

 

[Damniel]

given im not pushing ace, there’s no real reason that ace’s chop would point to me i don’t get it

 

[Ace Marvel]

I hope your behavior pays off to what you believe it will pay off. Can you possibly provide some opinions on others?

Epona, won't be readable until D2, I did learn even though one game, some key elements of her mafia play style,
(from now on everything I interact with Epona, I'll use TS lyrics)
Damniel is wolf
Not getting WEP (wolf energy player) from glow this game.
Volt is Null
You are Null don't worry, my main target is Damniel
Dino is cool
Geoni IDK
Cake is everything and must be protected until proven otherwise
Guava is a queen but that is NAI
FA and Hikari no opinion yet

I'm terrible with metaphors, can you elaborate?

I said it like it is, last time I was mafia because I was absent, this time I'm mafia too, so I will always be mafia, until I flip, the thing is it happens almost always at night, because no one dares to vote me off. So I'm okay with it. I know you won't kill me so I'm free to do my crazy stuff, because when I try to be serious it will just get ignore, so in the end, I'm best to keep alive till the end, because that's when all my crazy stuff comes together and actually is helpful.
I might not give you reads, but the reactions I have on people are big clues, something I would never do as mafia.

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2020

given im not pushing ace, there’s no real reason that ace’s chop would point to me i don’t get it

Experimental game that gives clues to be solved.