Yeah, I wish Sherb talked like that too, though its cute how he has so many bug friends
This is how I feel about Keaton vs O’Hare and Henry. All 3 are smug. Keaton was the camper they force you to keep. I couldn’t stand him: constant flirting, telling me that he dreams about me, Hazel was my enemy and when I found her in his house he said he set up a meeting for me with her. I was like ummm no. This was in the beginning of the game so it has been awhile, but I used to have a long list of things he did that freaked me out. Finally I got a cute camper (Mint) and she booted him out.I do find that just due to the way the rng plays out especially initially, I can feel really differently about two villagers of the same type (and subtype). And it really can build a different picture of the villager in your head of that particular villager, even when/ if you experience the same dialogue. To me it is a mix of luck on what the first few more elaborate bits of dialogue you get, the way the villager reactions come across, and other little ransoms accidents of coincidence. Although I didn’t find him terrible, I had that experience with Lionel and then Graham. They are both smugs of the same type. I didn’t hate Lionel, but a lot of his dialogue for whatever reason came across and weirdly flirty and I did not like that, it made him seem kind of gross at times. But Graham always just seemed so sweet and innocent and loveably dorky to me. I know they had the same dialogue and same reactions to things, but the parts that stuck out to me and how they came across was totally different.
On your Paulo experience, I admit I find the lazy dialogue most charming when they are talking about the weirdest stuff, but I can understand it is not for everyone!
I also enjoy when Genji tells me how he likes to sleep in his own sweat soaked clothing because he finds the smell comforting (or something like that)
I love this sentence lmao.
I do find that just due to the way the rng plays out especially initially, I can feel really differently about two villagers of the same type (and subtype). And it really can build a different picture of the villager in your head of that particular villager, even when/ if you experience the same dialogue. To me it is a mix of luck on what the first few more elaborate bits of dialogue you get, the way the villager reactions come across, and other little ransoms accidents of coincidence. Although I didn’t find him terrible, I had that experience with Lionel and then Graham. They are both smugs of the same type. I didn’t hate Lionel, but a lot of his dialogue for whatever reason came across and weirdly flirty and I did not like that, it made him seem kind of gross at times. But Graham always just seemed so sweet and innocent and loveably dorky to me. I know they had the same dialogue and same reactions to things, but the parts that stuck out to me and how they came across was totally different.
On your Paulo experience, I admit I find the lazy dialogue most charming when they are talking about the weirdest stuff, but I can understand it is not for everyone!
I also enjoy when Genji tells me how he likes to sleep in his own sweat soaked clothing because he finds the smell comforting (or something like that)
. I admit back in NL I didn’t like smugs for awhile because of Keaton or some of the other personalities because of that one (along with the fact I may have wanted them to move ). My perception has changed of the smug villagers overall (as well as the other personalities I didn’t like) thanks to the community and now realizing that some have different vibes. You gave me something to think about now. The dialogue doesn’t bother me (except the bugs) since I usually don’t pay much attention anymore to the dialogue sadly. But that is definitely understandably gross to hear/see. ><He's gonna be in boxes tomoooorooooowwww.....you know you waaaaant hiiiiimmmm....In NL, I thought Keaton’s comments seemed kinda flirty and so he creeped me out. I thought maybe I misinterpreted it. And I have always wondered why I liked some villagers of certain personalities, but didn’t like others (beyond the design)? Thanks for sharing your thoughts. That actually helped clear up my thoughts a bit
I have been up in the air about Paolo; for the longest time I didn’t like any of the elephants and now I’m liking some and I was thinking I maybe liked Paolo. Now I think I will reserve my judgment when and if I cycle him.
Just want to throw in, that as tempting as that may be, I would not as if you play with anyone else, they could end up in that person's move in queue and then be ruined for them.
It made them one of my favourite personalities.
