Mafia Jailbreak Mafia Game Thread - Game Over, Town Wins!

[radical6]

I'm not trying to echo, i just noticed while i was reading back that punchy didnt make any posts during his cell phase but then made posts now that all cells are combined i thought that was a bit TOO convenient but at the time i didnt notice where they mentioned a power cut??

Geoni said it first.

Anyway now that you know does that change your opinion of him? What do you think now?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also theres light hearted banter and then flaming each other. Just cut it out. Youre both clogging up the thread with insults anyway.

 

[Arstotzkan]

A little yeah, especially when you were questioning him about his cell.

Mind explaining to me why Rosie is confidently maf for being defensive, but Toads presumably isn’t?

 

[radical6]

I take it Toads is so far the only one up for lynch

 

[toadsworthy]

Yeah just wreck me so I can go work on RHOM2

Hopefully Rosie was scum or punchy gets lynched. I’m pretty strong in panda being town, because she is obvi scum most the time. She hasn’t spoken yet, but thats kinda par for the course with her too... people have sussed her back and forth for “inactivity” but like she just doesn’t stalk the thread like the bulk of us lol

 

[Arstotzkan]

Toads is my preferred lynch atm, yeah. And no one else has really been brought up. Tea I guess but honestly I'd want to see a toads flip before looking into her as a potential lynch.

Did you have anyone else in mind?

 

[toadsworthy]

Still haven’t read cell C, because I’m trying to catch up at work. But will do tonight... whether or not anybody will give a rip is debatable, but just in case you all come to realize you’re wrong and want some extra help

 

[Arstotzkan]

Who do you want as the lynch, Toads?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Given what you know

 

[toadsworthy]

Toads is my preferred lynch atm, yeah. And no one else has really been brought up. Tea I guess but honestly I'd want to see a toads flip before looking into her as a potential lynch.

Did you have anyone else in mind?

There isn’t any flip either is there? I thought everything was all neutral even after a lynch

 

[Arstotzkan]

There isn’t any flip either is there? I thought everything was all neutral even after a lynch

I think that was during cell phase exclusively? I believe flips are revealed during this phase.

Geoni, confirmation on this?

 

[toadsworthy]

Who do you want as the lynch, Toads?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Given what you know

In cell A, I was between ilunie and Kat, but I don’t think I would get anywhere with that... tea’s recent posts are weird, but I don’t know why a scum tea would be trying to stick up for someone as sunk as I appear to be. So not anyone from cell A

My cell is between Rosie and punchy in my eyes. Punchy is still not posting enough, but his first endeavors didn’t seem too promising, especially f he has gotten more experience with being a confident mafia.

Probably someone in cell C. I feel like unravel can be a very easy Lynch given her demeanor? So I want to see their reasoning for it before jumping to anything... but it very well could be in that cell.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Gimme one person Toads

 

[toadsworthy]

Fine you, I think you overwrought the whole mediator perspective during your phase. Being very careful to appear like you are going to each person and looking/organizing their input, when that is very much your scum meta. Hard to nail that down though because it is very town-oriented of a move, but you’re obviously good enough to pull that off.

You’re also a good enough player to confidently come flying into this phase and lead a quick lynch on me. However you also very much know that I’m a mess on my best and worst days of mafia, so I feel like you are leaving all that all out, and focusing in on me to get a quick lynch. My cell was messy, but like given the circumstances I don’t think I was out of line in my pressure and thought process. Also you’re reasoning for all this was “you were excited at the start and I expected you to pressure the people in your cell. You did that, but not enough” is a dumb reason to scumlean me.... I did what you say I should do, but it’s like not enough? Idk how much else one can get from someone who just does one liners, someone giving scum vibes, and someone not even there. So I think it’s funny that you went from mediator in phase 1 to pointing a major finger at me right away, not really focusing on anything else. If you were actually concerned about mediating I feel like you would have continued to get more input from all people (especially cell c) right now, but instead you have directed almost all of your attention at me

 

[Aquari]

Geoni said it first.
Anyway now that you know does that change your opinion of him? What do you think now?

I'm neutral on punchy for now, I still need to read back in the thread a bit

Mind explaining to me why Rosie is confidently maf for being defensive, but Toads presumably isn?t?

Because in my opinion rosei reacted more defensively than toad, besides i never said toad was town anyways.

 

[toadsworthy]

Scum mommy slipping up, because her appetite for town blood was so strong she wanted to just lynch this little mushroom

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm neutral on punchy for now, I still need to read back in the thread a bit


Because in my opinion rosei reacted more defensively than toad, besides i never said toad was town anyways.

I’m glad someone else sees what I see. I at least explained myself, I feel like Rosie kept just asking me dumb questions, like to expand on my hunch on punchy. Like there was nothing to go over because homie never showed up... it was a flat out guess and that was pretty obvious because it was my second post. Idk it was a pretty noob/ roundabout way I feel like to try to “question” me or try to throw shade at me

 

[Arstotzkan]

Fine you, I think you overwrought the whole mediator perspective during your phase. Being very careful to appear like you are going to each person and looking/organizing their input, when that is very much your scum meta. Hard to nail that down though because it is very town-oriented of a move, but you?re obviously good enough to pull that off.

We're getting into WIFOM territory, but I feel like my scum meta is much less decisive than my town meta.

You?re also a good enough player to confidently come flying into this phase and lead a quick lynch on me. However you also very much know that I?m a mess on my best and worst days of mafia, so I feel like you are leaving all that all out, and focusing in on me to get a quick lynch.

You're really underplaying your own ability here, Toads. You've been underplaying yourself a lot in general. It's one of the secondary reasons why I'm FOSing you. You aren't a noob. Didn't you play as the IE in one of the noob games? Like. C'mon man. You've been around this community for a while. You aren't top tier, but you aren't by any means bottom tier either.

My cell was messy, but like given the circumstances I don?t think I was out of line in my pressure and thought process. Also you?re reasoning for all this was ?you were excited at the start and I expected you to pressure the people in your cell. You did that, but not enough? is a dumb reason to scumlean me.... I did what you say I should do, but it?s like not enough? Idk how much else one can get from someone who just does one liners, someone giving scum vibes, and someone not even there.

Please see post #466. I felt you let that thread death happen instead of fight against it. Additional note here but I feel like you're pretty damn confident in Rosie being scum considering how little material she really gave. Noobs aren't going to do the pro-town thing, most of the time, and you're taking "not pro-town" to equate to scum. And your "reaction test" felt off. And I had to basically pry an FOS out of you, which I don't feel like town would need to have happen.

So I think it?s funny that you went from mediator in phase 1 to pointing a major finger at me right away, not really focusing on anything else. If you were actually concerned about mediating I feel like you would have continued to get more input from all people (especially cell c) right now, but instead you have directed almost all of your attention at me

I'm not concerned about mediating. I'm not trying to play a particular role. I'm concerned with finding scum. And I feel you are it.
Also, I feel cell C's lynch was right. Of course I'm going to be much more concerned about the cell that I feel had the wrong lynch than the right one. If you have any comments on Cell C, I'd love to hear it, but I mean you're the one who'd rather post than read back on that cell so dunno if you're much to talk here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Actually q toads: What's your thoughts on Maddie?

 

[PandaDarling]

I’m off work today... I’ll catch up on the thread and contributed asap

 

[Dinosaurz]

Ah just woke up

Sup guys

- - - Post Merge - - -

Do we get to know the 3rd place prize now that’s it post cell? Or is that secret forever

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sorry don’t know how to use colour question thing

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I’m not sure how aggressive town toad is but he’s been trying to guilt trip and seems very off. I just think that’s very scummy since that’s something mafia me did in the past.

 

[radical6]

Probably someone in cell C. I feel like unravel can be a very easy Lynch given her demeanor? So I want to see their reasoning for it before jumping to anything... but it very well could be in that cell.

poe

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok since im exhausted and busy tmrw my thoughts:

Toad is very defensive, but understandable since hes on the lynching block.

Id like to hear more from panda tbh

Teabagel seems like noob town

Kat I'm a bit wary of

- - - Post Merge - - -

I dont think cell A or B lynched scum tbh.. inb4 they did and cell C got it wrong lmao

Also i dont really think toads is guilt tripping. Thats not what that means anyway.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anyway im not going to be around for much but will try to vote tonight before my flight but for cell A I feel like scum is Liam by POE. (Process of Elimination) though if something changes Kat is my 2nd.

Cell B I'm hesitant between Toads or Panda so I'm not sure and would have to read it over.

Cell C I think we did it even though I doubted myself at the end but im glad i didnt change my mind ultimately.

 

[Arstotzkan]

No way Liam’s scum

What do you think about Ilumnie/Maddie?

 

[Dinosaurz]

Why do you think tea is NOT scum she seems so scummy