PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
same
haha remember call the ships to port where was Time Bomb/Veteran
remember when i got lifted away by a crane
Mafia Jailbreak Mafia Game Thread - Game Over, Town Wins!
- Thread starter Geoni
- Start date
same
haha remember call the ships to port where was Time Bomb/Veteran
remember when i got lifted away by a crane
Reread cell A. She definitely feels unsure and tbh at the beginning I felt like she wanted to coast by. Wasn't very committed.
Kept making up excuses because there was no content and imo town should be proactive. However I can chalk that up to being noob.
She also seens not confident in herself. Reminds me of Toad lol. Actually a lot reminds me. How he also came up with an excuse for his lack of commitment.
Gonna rethink it over and wonder if shes scum or not. She definitely seems new regardless but I dont know her enough as a person to determine if she was pretending to be scared town or is actually mafia trying to skate by.
Gonna reread cell B because id rather leave cell A to think a bit more
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
haven't had a chance to read much yet.... when does this phase end ?
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Tomorrow at 9am EST. So we've got just over 16 hours until hammer
- - - Post Merge - - -
tbh I'm gonna ahead and ##VOTE: Toadsworthy because I don't see that changing
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
I read Cell C, and I see what everyone is saying about unravel for sure. She wanted to **** post, but went so serious so quick and thats a sure sign for her when she feels panicked. The only time she was ever cool under pressure, was that one game where she was like town cleared for no reason (I was scum with her and scum read for some reason, it was a kingmaker?). I think her last vote was out of self-preservation, which isn't necessarily scummy but combined with everything doesn't help.
- - - Post Merge - - -
shall I explain myself for the next 12 hours again, only for you to not listen to me
- - - Post Merge - - -
I don't get the logistics of radical asking a question being so pivotal? that whole conversation just sounds like trying to clear someone for the wrong reasons... antonio saying he cant read people over the internet and so he goes by people being "suspicious" was something weird to say, like trying to justify bad reads? he wrapped it up with like being autistic, which just was like a weird thing to say... in that place (I'm not making fun of people with autism, but i gotta say what i feel)
- - - Post Merge - - -
I honestly think you are trying to town lead so hard with this hahaha, because you know I'm the only one who could really challenge you. I think you are trying to play a game of chess by doing all this so quickly, by coming out swinging and now voting me you are essentially trying to make it so I can't vote for you because otherwise I just look like OMGUS...
- - - Post Merge - - -
shall I explain myself for the next 12 hours again, only for you to not listen to me
- - - Post Merge - - -
I don't get the logistics of radical asking a question being so pivotal? that whole conversation just sounds like trying to clear someone for the wrong reasons... antonio saying he cant read people over the internet and so he goes by people being "suspicious" was something weird to say, like trying to justify bad reads? he wrapped it up with like being autistic, which just was like a weird thing to say... in that place (I'm not making fun of people with autism, but i gotta say what i feel)
- - - Post Merge - - -
I honestly think you are trying to town lead so hard with this hahaha, because you know I'm the only one who could really challenge you. I think you are trying to play a game of chess by doing all this so quickly, by coming out swinging and now voting me you are essentially trying to make it so I can't vote for you because otherwise I just look like OMGUS...
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
You don't need to vote to be guilty of OMGUS
Also very bold statement @bolded. Weren't you just saying you're the one who is going to be emotional and wild and an easy target or some ****? Also, literally anyone could challenge me? If you're speaking in terms of skill, I think Ness and radical has you beat in that category. Why are you the only person who "can challenge me"?
Also, what do you think of Ilumnie/Maddie, Toads? You never answered that.
@Radical's question and receipts that whole **** wasn't AI imo
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
also your argument on me is so tangled in on itself... no matter what I say its not gonna make you listen
You keep saying I'm responsible for "thread death" but like, what could I have done. I tried my damnedest, but panda barely would answer my question and would then log off and Rosie wanted to push me based on my post "hunch on punchy" which was more of a reaction test than anything else. And like, my "hunch" was a baseless guess, but Rosie was expecting me to come up with some backing for it when she should damn well know its faceless because it was my second post (not like I was gonna vote based on it). She then moved to a convenient "placeholder vote" on punchy.... like come on, thats suspicious af. You wanna say I was defensive during then, she was also defensive and I at least I questioned her where I could.
I was not fully convinced she was scum, because Punchy was literally nonexistent, but I wasn't gonna vote an inactive... and between Rosie who was feeding me all this bs and Panda who came out talking pretty confident, it was no brainer to vote rosie. I do want Panda to keep talking to help me convince myself that wasn't a bad choice. But I feel like I'm getting targeted for my cell because I actually played the game vs everyone else was avoidant. So you can all stand on the outside and say I'm scummy and Rosie looked town. But it sure af didn't feel like that and I don't think anyone would've reacted differently.
Now Kat wants to sit here and say "I expected more from you, you sound so excited at the start," well uh, I did what I could with that, but none of y'all had literally a corpse in your cell like us. But also she says "you did what I expect, but I wanted more." what am I supposed to say to that? I feel like you all are saying I harped on Rosie, but like between Rosie and Panda... I did keep pushing to get more info and i didn't like what I was getting. With nothing with Punchy like wtf do you expect me to do? I think its a piss poor argument for me and she is throwing out the context of my ****ty cell in order to fuel an easy lynch candidate
- - - Post Merge - - -
Because I've already voiced that I thought you were suspicious, you told me to act more experienced. so here I am.
I've posted what I thought about maddie and you from that cell. I thought Maddie sounded like an awkward panicked mafia most the time, and then she kinda tails pinned at the end to get kinda emotional which also reads new scum. The way she talked it was very forward, but then she tried to come across like a new player at times.... it was really strange
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also rude.... calling out people as better than others. Not what I meant but you've kind of had a habit of twisting my words or casually leaving out what you want to make your point
- - - Post Merge - - -
and if I'm already accused of OMGUS anyway then may as well make it official
## Vote Arstotzkhan
You keep saying I'm responsible for "thread death" but like, what could I have done. I tried my damnedest, but panda barely would answer my question and would then log off and Rosie wanted to push me based on my post "hunch on punchy" which was more of a reaction test than anything else. And like, my "hunch" was a baseless guess, but Rosie was expecting me to come up with some backing for it when she should damn well know its faceless because it was my second post (not like I was gonna vote based on it). She then moved to a convenient "placeholder vote" on punchy.... like come on, thats suspicious af. You wanna say I was defensive during then, she was also defensive and I at least I questioned her where I could.
I was not fully convinced she was scum, because Punchy was literally nonexistent, but I wasn't gonna vote an inactive... and between Rosie who was feeding me all this bs and Panda who came out talking pretty confident, it was no brainer to vote rosie. I do want Panda to keep talking to help me convince myself that wasn't a bad choice. But I feel like I'm getting targeted for my cell because I actually played the game vs everyone else was avoidant. So you can all stand on the outside and say I'm scummy and Rosie looked town. But it sure af didn't feel like that and I don't think anyone would've reacted differently.
Now Kat wants to sit here and say "I expected more from you, you sound so excited at the start," well uh, I did what I could with that, but none of y'all had literally a corpse in your cell like us. But also she says "you did what I expect, but I wanted more." what am I supposed to say to that? I feel like you all are saying I harped on Rosie, but like between Rosie and Panda... I did keep pushing to get more info and i didn't like what I was getting. With nothing with Punchy like wtf do you expect me to do? I think its a piss poor argument for me and she is throwing out the context of my ****ty cell in order to fuel an easy lynch candidate
- - - Post Merge - - -
You don't need to vote to be guilty of OMGUS
Also very bold statement @bolded. Weren't you just saying you're the one who is going to be emotional and wild and an easy target or some ****? Also, literally anyone could challenge me? If you're speaking in terms of skill, I think Ness and radical has you beat in that category. Why are you the only person who "can challenge me"?
Also, what do you think of Ilumnie/Maddie, Toads? You never answered that.
@Radical's question and receipts that whole **** wasn't AI imo
Because I've already voiced that I thought you were suspicious, you told me to act more experienced. so here I am.
I've posted what I thought about maddie and you from that cell. I thought Maddie sounded like an awkward panicked mafia most the time, and then she kinda tails pinned at the end to get kinda emotional which also reads new scum. The way she talked it was very forward, but then she tried to come across like a new player at times.... it was really strange
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also rude.... calling out people as better than others. Not what I meant but you've kind of had a habit of twisting my words or casually leaving out what you want to make your point
- - - Post Merge - - -
and if I'm already accused of OMGUS anyway then may as well make it official
## Vote Arstotzkhan
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Wait toads lmfao
I'm gonna eat real quick so I will try to explain it in a proper wall or something, but you're really not representing my FOS of you correctly.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Toads, I mean no offense by saying that. I'm not as good as you in plenty of things. It's okay to be better or worse in various topics than others, and it's inevitable.
Are you okay? Like you've seemed really sensitive this whole game. If you need to replace for your own mental health, I think you should.
- - - Post Merge - - -
This game be damned - Toads, please do something to relax, at least for a little bit. Your mental health matters more than some silly argument simulator.
Soooo doesn't that prove that your conviction in your ability doesn't really come from within yourself, but rather an attempt to align with what others think you are? That's highkey scummy my man
I'm gonna eat real quick so I will try to explain it in a proper wall or something, but you're really not representing my FOS of you correctly.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Toads, I mean no offense by saying that. I'm not as good as you in plenty of things. It's okay to be better or worse in various topics than others, and it's inevitable.
Are you okay? Like you've seemed really sensitive this whole game. If you need to replace for your own mental health, I think you should.
- - - Post Merge - - -
This game be damned - Toads, please do something to relax, at least for a little bit. Your mental health matters more than some silly argument simulator.
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
I just ate a lot of pizza, so if you could stop shoving words in my mouth that would be great because I might puke without disgusting this convo is
I am an easy target in this game because I was outspoken in a very silent cell where one person literally did nothing (but I stand by all my actions, reread everything I've ever said), that I have explained multiple times. I am berated a lot of the time due to being emotional in a lot of games... whether that is to scum-affect or town-affect, i think at this point you should just expect it from me and people look down on me for that.
Maybe challenge wasn't the right word, but what I meant was that based on my already-voiced opinion of you are shady based on trying to appear as a mediator throughout your cell that I was going to be the most competent person with the most drive to say something about that... I never implied that I was better than anyone else, but I'm literally the most outspoken so far to call you out.
But now I'm kinda over this whole stupid game, because now its me spiraling and having to back talk my explanation again while people just take my words and misconstrue them to just make me look worse and worse
Also I don't align with others or any of this psych absolute bs, but I always stand for what I think and my observations even while I don't have a very high opinion of myself in a lot of situations. And hell I'm wrong a lot in trying to catch scum, but I'm also just trying to have a good time and play with what I can
Jesus this is like Dolby all over again
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Toads, please take a break. You aren't having a good time right now. If you are town, you need to take some time to collect your thoughts and not have hurt feelings influence your mind.
I'm really, really sorry. I didn't mean to hurt you. I may think you're sus but that can go to hell in light of your well-being. And I realize a true apology won't be taken for real at this point because you think I could just be scum trying to get you over to my side or something, but after this game, I'm apologizing in full.
I'm really, really sorry. I didn't mean to hurt you. I may think you're sus but that can go to hell in light of your well-being. And I realize a true apology won't be taken for real at this point because you think I could just be scum trying to get you over to my side or something, but after this game, I'm apologizing in full.
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
literally typing up a reads post on each person but then I'm gonna go shove villagers into pitfalls and feng shui my ACNL house
- - - Post Merge - - -
I know you *probably* didn't mean it, and it came out wrong... it happens and I know you wouldn't purposefully try to say anything hurtful.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I know you *probably* didn't mean it, and it came out wrong... it happens and I know you wouldn't purposefully try to say anything hurtful.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
I need a break from thread myself tbh. I really can't play right now without feeling guilty
I'll be back before lynch for sure, either late tonight or tomorrow morning
I'll be back before lynch for sure, either late tonight or tomorrow morning
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
I think everyone should try to due a quick reads post of each person as a way to try to normalize all this, because I feel like a lot of isolated events are going on/ just by the nature of this set up and it might help to try to put everyone on similar ground now that were all together.
Arstotzkhan - played referee or mediator imo for the whole first cell phase. But now came at me hardcore for this phase. I see it as trying to lynch maybe an easy target and get rid of someone who has been vocal about her and the way she is twisting my words is deplorable. I don't know if its scum based tunneling, but I think she is also harping on everything I've done without trying to understand my context which typically she does a very good job of.
Teabagel - So I mean your tone throughout the cell A phase was pretty much town you to a tea (lol that pun), but you seem really defensive all of sudden which I don't get because I don't think you've had too much pressure put on you. I also don't get why you are sticking up for me if you are scum, but whenever I'm scum I do that "Pocket-the-person-who-is-gonna-get-lynched-so-I-look-better-when-they-die" thing all the effing time.
Dinosaurz - This is basically old-school punchy, and I had good reads on that. I feel like you would know to be more serious if mafia, yada yada we all pretty much put you as bleeding town.
Panda - Panda usually is not confident as town, she literally avoids everything and pops in to make an excuse once in a while. Her first few posts showed an excitement and confidence that I didn't expect in panda. Hence why when faced with rosie vs panda, rosie was a much scummier choice
Punchydahufflepuff - claims more experience, but that could just be a more focused gameplay which would come with experience. I think your argument about me at the start of this phase sounded more like trying to differentiate from Kat's argument. But you both lunged at me at the start of this. Highly doubt Kat and Punchy are together, but I bet one is scum based on how this has gone.
Antonio - low-key made excuses to be defensive throughout cell c which def rubbed me the wrong way. There was an attempt at scum reading radical over a question, which never really sits well when people want to try to get lynches off logistics like that.
Radical - I don't know what you were doing in your cell, I feel like you all talked about your subbing into the game for far too long and idk why. That was an easy way to feign any attention, but you could also have just been chilling. I felt like there was a lot of attention on you though and I think you handled it really calm and cooled, so it leans townie, but I know you could fake that affect as a veteran
Ness - I thought you played a balance of emotion with being at school and having exams with actual content and analysis across the board that made sense. You came across probably the most town besides dino, and if you are scum then ripperoni
Most scummy right now - Kat, antonio, tea bagel, then punchy
Middle of the road - Radical and panda
Town leans - Ness and Dino
I'm leaving good bye
Arstotzkhan - played referee or mediator imo for the whole first cell phase. But now came at me hardcore for this phase. I see it as trying to lynch maybe an easy target and get rid of someone who has been vocal about her and the way she is twisting my words is deplorable. I don't know if its scum based tunneling, but I think she is also harping on everything I've done without trying to understand my context which typically she does a very good job of.
Teabagel - So I mean your tone throughout the cell A phase was pretty much town you to a tea (lol that pun), but you seem really defensive all of sudden which I don't get because I don't think you've had too much pressure put on you. I also don't get why you are sticking up for me if you are scum, but whenever I'm scum I do that "Pocket-the-person-who-is-gonna-get-lynched-so-I-look-better-when-they-die" thing all the effing time.
Dinosaurz - This is basically old-school punchy, and I had good reads on that. I feel like you would know to be more serious if mafia, yada yada we all pretty much put you as bleeding town.
Panda - Panda usually is not confident as town, she literally avoids everything and pops in to make an excuse once in a while. Her first few posts showed an excitement and confidence that I didn't expect in panda. Hence why when faced with rosie vs panda, rosie was a much scummier choice
Punchydahufflepuff - claims more experience, but that could just be a more focused gameplay which would come with experience. I think your argument about me at the start of this phase sounded more like trying to differentiate from Kat's argument. But you both lunged at me at the start of this. Highly doubt Kat and Punchy are together, but I bet one is scum based on how this has gone.
Antonio - low-key made excuses to be defensive throughout cell c which def rubbed me the wrong way. There was an attempt at scum reading radical over a question, which never really sits well when people want to try to get lynches off logistics like that.
Radical - I don't know what you were doing in your cell, I feel like you all talked about your subbing into the game for far too long and idk why. That was an easy way to feign any attention, but you could also have just been chilling. I felt like there was a lot of attention on you though and I think you handled it really calm and cooled, so it leans townie, but I know you could fake that affect as a veteran
Ness - I thought you played a balance of emotion with being at school and having exams with actual content and analysis across the board that made sense. You came across probably the most town besides dino, and if you are scum then ripperoni
Most scummy right now - Kat, antonio, tea bagel, then punchy
Middle of the road - Radical and panda
Town leans - Ness and Dino
I'm leaving good bye
I'm going to go ahead and extend it to 9pm tomorrow because end of day change will inevitably result in a lot of missing votes on tbt and it gives people time to catch up during what is finals week for some.
Day will end at 9pm EST on Tuesday the 10th.
Day will end at 9pm EST on Tuesday the 10th.
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
uh
this is exactly how she posted the whole time
we might have gotten a wolf?
will dive deeper into toads and panda
- - - Post Merge - - -
ok
i've flipped my reasoning on toads
i've read my cell like 5 times
rosetti was really wolfy after rexamination and toads points make sense on her
as said in my last post, her play really represented her wolf tell she told us about in the RQS
rosetti took the vote on me wayy too seriously tbh
i skimmed the first time and was thinking too anylitically instead of using an occam's razor thinking. If I were active, I probably would have wolfread rosetti because of her response to questioning.
I also think toads reactions to incessant questioning come from a town pov, I dont think toads would AtE in this situation
Now i believe that Toads is actually kind of towny
Panda coasted a lot tbh and I would like to hear more from her, I think she's a little wolfy. I havent read the other two cells yet.
Let's lynch someone from a different cell today
ftr this is a towny post
as a wolf i'd keep pushing
I'll read the other cells now.
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
i think radical is the wolf in cell c
she didnt really do anything until pushed
I still dont understand antonios logic
i think radical would lead more as town
instead she left that to ness
and didnt do much except vote unravel
she didnt really do anything until pushed
I still dont understand antonios logic
i think radical would lead more as town
instead she left that to ness
and didnt do much except vote unravel
Im so confused what just happened but ok
- - - Post Merge - - -
Im tired buf will try to iso but dont count me for it
Also to everyone your mental health > mafia
- - - Post Merge - - -
I don't like to lead lol. This is all meta and doesnt rly matter but I've always just been leaving it to someone else anyway. Past games I would default to Geoni until he died. I feel uncomfortable dominating until I have to. But anyway that doesnt mean much
Will respond to toad in a bit
- - - Post Merge - - -
Im tired buf will try to iso but dont count me for it
Also to everyone your mental health > mafia
- - - Post Merge - - -
I don't like to lead lol. This is all meta and doesnt rly matter but I've always just been leaving it to someone else anyway. Past games I would default to Geoni until he died. I feel uncomfortable dominating until I have to. But anyway that doesnt mean much
Will respond to toad in a bit
Flips are not revealed for the entire game because it would create too many clears due to the one per cell aspect, highly townsiding the game. Sorry I missed this one.
- - - Post Merge - - -
It will be announced at EoD.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Current Votecount
toadsworthy (1): Astrotzkan
Astrotzkan (1): Toadsworthy
With plurality in effect, toadsworthy is set to be lynched. You have 24 hours and 43 minutes to vote before day 4 ends at 9pm EST on Tuesday the 10th.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
well **** @ flips
Naps are nice, would def recommend.
Toads, when do you think I twisted your words? I know you think I did with the whole experience thing, but where else?
- - - Post Merge - - -
A mountainous flipless game feels scum-sided af though. Not having any form of host information is ****ing difficult
- - - Post Merge - - -
Absolute worst case (all 3 maf are alive), we can only mislynch once. 2 maf would give us 2 mislynches, 1 maf gives us 3. So if we get to a third cell-merged day, then we got at least one maf. Getting to a fourth cell-merged day means we got 2 and it's LYLO.
Naps are nice, would def recommend.
Toads, when do you think I twisted your words? I know you think I did with the whole experience thing, but where else?
- - - Post Merge - - -
A mountainous flipless game feels scum-sided af though. Not having any form of host information is ****ing difficult
- - - Post Merge - - -
Absolute worst case (all 3 maf are alive), we can only mislynch once. 2 maf would give us 2 mislynches, 1 maf gives us 3. So if we get to a third cell-merged day, then we got at least one maf. Getting to a fourth cell-merged day means we got 2 and it's LYLO.
So you're saying she typically can see context and isn't doing that right now?
What was the last game she played?
And I don't know her as a person but typically a lot of the times I see ppl more confident as scum than town usually because they know who the scum is. They know whats going on (especially in a setup with no blues).
However, if she's usually not confident as town, then how does being confident make her town now? I'm not following your logic here.
Antonio was harping on me about it and I didn't wanna die lol. Ness later asked me to be as specific as possible on how I subbed so I obliged. Not sure if that did anything though since Antonio hasn't said a word since then.
Similar threads
