Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

[N e s s]

does a shawo/ace team make sense?

It doesn't.

I'm trying to process my thoughts right now, I'm just mildly impressed (?) by what just happened because nobodies ever blasted me for something I feel like I normally do lol. He's going to have something to say about this but I am genuinely kind of thinking he's town now.

 

[Heyden]

i honestly think it's very possible that ness/shawo is town/town

if i had to choose a wolf out of the two of them it's ness, but i think that might just be because i find his playstyle a bit offputting in general

I’m still reading up and formulating my thoughts, but yeah this is where I stand too. Ness vs Shawo is honestly town vs town to me zzz.

Is heyden the one whos asking to be replaced? I havent heard from them

No. But I’m busy making my scumread on you

 

[N e s s]

It's like... never in a 1000 years would I have expected Shawo jump the gun so hard there. It feels like raw, genuine emotion to me.

 

[Biancasbotique]

they posted a while ago, i think they're probably catching up on the thread atm

bianca, who would you eliminate today if you had to choose now, and why

The most inactive player ...heyden is a candidate

 

[toadsworthy]

I definitely agree with the ppl saying that Shawo and Ace seem kinda sus

I definitely am thinking they are scum,,

To be honest,, I really dunno what to say but, yeah,, haha

can you give a quick reads list on like all the players? copy the first list and write null scum or town lean whatever?

 

[g u a v a]

It's like... never in a 1000 years would I have expected Shawo jump the gun so hard there. It feels like raw, genuine emotion to me.

are you saying mafia wouldn't have raw genuine emotional responses?

Post automatically merged: Jun 16, 2020

The most inactive player ...heyden is a candidate

sussing bianca on this because it bit me in the ass when i didnt last game.

voting an inactive wouldn't give us anything when we have a decent amount of sus on other more active players.

 

[Aerious]

I definitely agree with the ppl saying that Shawo and Ace seem kinda sus

I definitely am thinking they are scum,,

To be honest,, I really dunno what to say but, yeah,, haha

you're parroting. what do you think of all players right now?

comments like that don't help town, if you actually want to improve on this game then acting like this is going to confuse us rather than present anything worth following towards a credible lynch... I don't think anyone should follow your wagon tbh, I think glow's posts read very genuine and while she can be a tough cookie to read I think it bodes well for now.

meanwhile, you slip more down my reads list. I know this will be greeted by a "i'm being scum read by everyone YAY" and again that isn't gonna make any good content. If you are going to be 90% un-inspired posts and not willing to interact then rethink your strategy because its chaotic and if you wanna continue to be chaotic you will lose it for us.

thanks, this is summarizing my thoughts completely. this is what i meant by scot-free vs. literal interpretation. ace just feels like he's derailing and throwing for us. the glow wagon completely derailed what could've been productive convo, and then trying to derail again just now

 

[shawo]

they want you to get lynched because you're mafia, therefore they're actively looking for mafia. you're acting scummy fmpov.

I think you're misunderstanding the point I'm trying to make.

When you claimed I was mafia and wanted to get me lynched, you backed up your points with why you think that was the case to try and convince other people.

When ness did the same he instead tried to get on other people for [whatever the expression is].

The motivation behind these two actions are different.

I would also like to point out the fact that ness has also back-tracked on their read on me, and demoted me back to a scum-lean, so wouldn't they have preferred to dig out more from me so that they'd be confident in their read?

I'm just saying that "them trying to get me lynched" isn't really a town thing, because at the point in the game it was at they were acting more confident than they should have been, given their posts.

 

[epona]

is it too late for an RQS

if yes, this isn't an RQS it's just an friendly unsystematic interrogation quiz

1. what players do you know best on this table
2. what are your reads on them so far
3. do you think shawo and ness are both town? if not which is mafia?

1. personally, probably aerious, daniel and mayor leaf. in terms of mafia meta, probably daniel and mayor leaf

2.
aerious = slight townlean
daniel = townlean
mayor leaf = honestly null, her vastly different playstyle in this game compared to the last is throwing me

3. i answered this already

 

[Damniel]

The most inactive player ...heyden is a candidate

i think technically frogslime is the most inactive now. do you think they’re a candidate?

 

[g u a v a]

I think you're misunderstanding the point I'm trying to make.

When you claimed I was mafia and wanted to get me lynched, you backed up your points with why you think that was the case to try and convince other people.

When ness did the same he instead tried to get on other people for [whatever the expression is].

The motivation behind these two actions are different.

I would also like to point out the fact that ness has also back-tracked on their read on me, and demoted me back to a scum-lean, so wouldn't they have preferred to dig out more from me so that they'd be confident in their read?

I'm just saying that "them trying to get me lynched" isn't really a town thing, because at the point in the game it was at they were acting more confident than they should have been, given their posts.

so you're saying that i used receipts while ness was trying to guilt other townies into feeling bad for not immediately sussing you as scum? and that's what puts you off to ness?

 

[toadsworthy]

are you saying mafia wouldn't have raw genuine emotional responses?

Post automatically merged: Jun 16, 2020

sussing bianca on this because it bit me in the ass when i didnt last game.

voting an inactive wouldn't give us anything when we have a decent amount of sus on other more active players.

if you are mafia I'm going to be really impressed

 

[Biancasbotique]

i think technically frogslime is the most inactive now. do you think they’re a candidate?

yeah frogslime i missed it. I think heyden is making a scum case against me now

 

[shawo]

Well now I really am confused.

I'll mull it over.

I think my argument still makes sense in it's self contained logic, so Ness. Can you make the post as to the reason why you thought I was so mafia at that point in time?

 

[N e s s]

are you saying mafia wouldn't have raw genuine emotional responses?

They can, but this is a little different from something I would have expected a scum player to have done. It's too bombastic, and it looks to me like he was pissed off because I didn't make a case on him yet lol.

There are some posts that are not easily engineered as mafia, I lean more on him having an "a-ha!" moment on me there, even if it came across to me as "I'm going to break your kneecaps"

Post automatically merged: Jun 16, 2020

Well now I really am confused.

I'll mull it over.

I think my argument still makes sense in it's self contained logic, so Ness. Can you make the post as to the reason why you thought I was so mafia at that point in time?

I will get it out soon, but I'm not in a position to do it at the moment; my parents want to watch a movie with me and my sister tonight. Have patience.

 

[Lothitine]

Lothitine - town
Ness - null
Ace - scum
Feferily - null
Toads - town leaning
Shawo - scum
glow - town
Sensai - scum leaning
Heyden - null
Aerious - town
Daniel - null
Pinkshade - null
Mayor Leaf - scum leaning
Frogslime - town leaning
Bianca - town leaning
Punchy - scum
Epona - town leaning
@toadsworthy
Again, mostly gut feeling

 

[shawo]

so you're saying that i used receipts while ness was trying to guilt other townies into feeling bad for not immediately sussing you as scum? and that's what puts you off to ness?

Pretty much, but that in itself isn't so much scum as much as it was the fact that the rest of Ness's posts didn't support how hard they pushed me.

It wasn't just that they didn't SUPPORT their own argument as much as it didn't make sense for Ness to have done that given what they had said at that point in the game.

Post automatically merged: Jun 16, 2020

Yo lothi, can you talk about your experience in mafia?

 

[g u a v a]

@N e s s why should we wait for the info "coming soon"? in a previous post you said something to that effect but i want to know why we should trust you re: shawo.

 

[Aerious]

Lothitine - town
Ness - null
Ace - scum
Feferily - null
Toads - town leaning
Shawo - scum
glow - town
Sensai - scum leaning
Heyden - null
Aerious - town
Daniel - null
Pinkshade - null
Mayor Leaf - scum leaning
Frogslime - town leaning
Bianca - town leaning
Punchy - scum
Epona - town leaning
@toadsworthy
Again, mostly gut feeling

why am i definitive town to you? why is frogslime town leaning with one post? why toads town and shawo scum?

 

[toadsworthy]

Lothitine - town
Ness - null
Ace - scum
Feferily - null
Toads - town leaning
Shawo - scum
glow - town
Sensai - scum leaning
Heyden - null
Aerious - town
Daniel - null
Pinkshade - null
Mayor Leaf - scum leaning
Frogslime - town leaning
Bianca - town leaning
Punchy - scum
Epona - town leaning
@toadsworthy
Again, mostly gut feeling

thank you, I think I'm gonna give you some town credit for this