Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

[glow]

Who’s your top 3 for lynching today Ms Elf

i skimmed the last like 4 pages because i just want to say that out of this entire table, @PunchyTheCat is the one who's posts i dislike the most and i am placing my vote on him in seconds.

even his early game (which i try to more be lenient on reading because the ~it's d1 what do~ mentality) were awful, he started off the game with comments about "c'mon i wanna hunt" while not progressing the game at all. his return to the game more recently was filled with poorly executed apathy like "zzz boring game i'm disinterested" it's like he wants to feign cheeky aloofness but it seems more just like lazy mafia lol

when he outs a read, he immediately walks it back or discounts it. or he'll just say words with no substance like "oh this post is bleeding sOmeThinG", maybeeeee town?" complain about wallposts......... if a single user here can quote ONE good read or post from punchy, i would love to see it

tl;dr punchy punchy punchy

 

[PunchyTheCat]

mayor town
bianca town
daniel town?

shawo off the table
ace off the table
would rather not heyden

not opposed to sensai tbh

toads wolf

ness doesn't deserve the amount of townreads he's getting

i'm voting toads, nitpicky and getting mad over small things

probably someone i'm forgetting

i'm choosing to ignore glow's post except for that i'm lazy town not lazy mafia

i'll probably solve more once i wake up

going sleepytime zzz

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

my gut also tells me that epona and aerious are scum

also toads if you respond with a wall to my scumread please trim it down to what is essential

i'll hold off on reading glow and the newbies until later

although the splatoon one was giving me scummy vibes

also someone's probably going to jump on me for shawo read

i don't want him executed over some mechanical nonsense that toads blew out of proportion

i may reread his wolfgame later

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

not only is your scumread on me best summarized by "weeeelllll i voted randomly, but regardless i committed myself to it, so here we are"
but you contradict yourself in an incredible fashion by "warning people to be wary of meta" while simultaneously placing a townread on someone that you consider to be skilled at blending in with ~meta from last game~

at least be specific for what meta you think qualifies to be an exception. at least explain what exactly makes you read me as mafia from your gut feeling. until then i'm not taking your reads on me seriously regardless of length.

urgh this post has wolfy soul

 

[Pinkshade]

I have no idea if anyone is awake but I’m just popping in to once again apologize for inactivity and I will try to be more active tomorrow if possible because real life sucks lol
I don’t really have any evidence to back this up but I’m feeling strong mafia vibes from Toad and Bianca still (nothing against you I’m sure you’re both lovely people I’m just trying to contribute ^^) although I will admit the glow wagon seems pretty suspicious although I can’t tell if that has died or not...

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Last thing before I attempt to sleep so I don’t completely fall apart, I also personally think that epona and Daniel are town with, again, nothing concrete to back this up... sorry I have always been awful at collecting evidence. One last apology for inactivity, and I’m going now okay byeee

 

[SensaiGallade]

Pick me! Kill me first!

​

Working on a read list and I'm hoping to have it done and finished by EoD also does anyone know if its possible to have more posts per page show up?

Also I just wanna clarify that I was never on the glow bandwagon to begin with, so idk how that conclusion was came to.

 

[toadsworthy]

I’m gonna be incredibly busy today with work and getting ready for my trip tomorrow. I still think shawo’s hyper focus on the set up is not town helpful as much as he forces that it isn’t. His false guided crusades on me, then ness, and almost daniel last night didn’t get him anywhere. The one on ness pointed out that ness “scum lean, scum locked, scum leaned him” which you could argue he kinda did the same thing. The way he bulldogs through an argument also just feels super defensive.

I would be open to an Aerious elim due to their constant sitting back and watching while continuing to be very null. Their reaction to my case on them was also very explosive which also seemed scummy.

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

+ shawo has really only focused on those three things. Judging alignment based on how people react to his stubbornness about gameplay honestly does not make sense as it’s a pretty NAI topic to me. I can’t think of one mafia game where talking about game mechanic helped anything.

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Anyone voting for me, my only defense is hopefully you can go back through my posts and see that I was actually trying to scumhunt

 

[epona]

good morning (it's 2pm)

i've just caught up with the 10 or so pages that came into existence while europe was asleep and i'm fairly solid on bianca being town atm. i know i keep flip-flopping on this but i honestly think her contributions are hard to read bc they're erratic and all over the place at times, but i know for a fact she told me herself her scum strategy was to lay low and be her 'usual towny self' and i don't think i'm seeing enough parallels between this game and last to place her as scum rn. she's posting a LOT and her activity level is so so much higher than the last game, and she seems less afraid to say the wrong thing and actually put thoughts forward. not ruling out that this is just increased confidence in scumplay bc we had a mafia win in the last game, but regardlesso i'm not willing to get rid of bianca today.

i apologise for this read bc i'm painfully aware that my entire read on bianca is based on meta (and i've always maintained an overeliance on meta is a dull and lazy way to play the game) but bianca's posts are so chaotic that i actually don't know if there's any way to read her except with the hindsight of meta

also retrospective apology for my post quality yesterday, last night before i went to sleep i was so conscious of my posting being all over the place and not as concise or measured as i usually like to be, i had a weird brain-bleed day yesterday where i just could not think straight or order my thoughts efficiently at all. will try to gather myself and post with more clarity today

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

to add to my bianca read: she hates being scum, it stresses her out SO MUCH lol, it looks to me like she's having more fun in this game so i'm inclined to believe that she's not as anxious about the way people view her because she has nothing to hide

 

[toadsworthy]

@epona who are you considering for elimination then

 

[SensaiGallade]

@epona who are you considering for elimination then

I know you're not asking me but I think Shawo judging from what I read up so far

 

[toadsworthy]

I know you're not asking me but I think Shawo judging from what I read up so far

I feel like you could be a possible elimination candidate given people’s ideas toward the end of yesterday. What’s your defense to that

I for one haven’t seen anything scummy outside you’re normal play style. Which as I mentioned often gets read that way and you eliminated early

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Of all the newbies I think pink shade gives me the most new scum vibes.... although I’ll be honest I haven’t paid much attention to frogslimes posts
Fefer and loth to me seem town so far

 

[SensaiGallade]

I feel like you could be a possible elimination candidate given people’s ideas toward the end of yesterday. What’s your defense to that

I for one haven’t seen anything scummy outside you’re normal play style. Which as I mentioned often gets read that way and you eliminated early

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Of all the newbies I think pink shade gives me the most new scum vibes.... although I’ll be honest I haven’t paid much attention to frogslimes posts
Fefer and loth to me seem town so far

It would be a waste killing me. What exactly would you get from it? I was accused of hopping onto a glow bandwagon then jumping back off when I never considered a glow elim anyway, not to mention I was asking Ace why they weren't considering glow a elim candidate after trying to start a bandwagon. Whenever I have been consistent D1 it usually results in me being eliminated that day or soon after. The only time I was ever Maf, it was with Ness, something to do with Alola (forgot the name of the game), and I was a hot ****ing mess.

I'll admit I have been fairly unmotivated, but that's my own issue to tackle, and I am working on a read list of sorts and re-reading the thread now.

 

[Heyden]

I’m probably gonna sleep in tomorrow unless I set my alarm, so I’m sorry I haven’t really contributed much besides my Bianca tunnel which I’m already doubting. I’ll just move onto Toads idk.

If you guys end up lynching Shawo I’ll be so upset.

 

[SensaiGallade]

If you guys end up lynching Shawo I’ll be so upset.

Why

 

[Damniel]

also retrospective apology for my post quality yesterday, last night before i went to sleep i was so conscious of my posting being all over the place and not as concise or measured as i usually like to be, i had a weird brain-bleed day yesterday where i just could not think straight or order my thoughts efficiently at all. will try to gather myself and post with more clarity today

hm i don’t really like the wording of this. feels unnecessary and too conscious of self image

Of all the newbies I think pink shade gives me the most new scum vibes.... although I’ll be honest I haven’t paid much attention to frogslimes posts
Fefer and loth to me seem town so far

yea i’m not giving any new player passes so i don’t find it impossible they’re scum. is it worth voting D1 though not sure

I was accused of hopping onto a glow bandwagon then jumping back off when I never considered a glow elim anyway, not to mention I was asking Ace why they weren't considering glow a elim candidate after trying to start a bandwagon. Whenever I have been consistent D1 it usually results in me being eliminated that day or soon after. The only time I was ever Maf, it was with Ness, something to do with Alola (forgot the name of the game), and I was a hot ****ing mess.

who accused you of going with glow

that game was like years ago and was canceled so i don’t find that valuable meta. lack of will to scumhunt will warrant scrutiny!



im not for voting shawo today. not that i townread him really but i just don’t think he’s worth voting D1 since he’s contributing a lot and will trip up soon enough if scum. better of reevaluating for the next stage and feels like too easy of a vote right now along with ace. i honestly just think the numbers thing yesterday was a culture clash so that’s NAI for me



glow brings up a good point on punchy on lack of motivation. but he continues to play multiple games at the same time so i’m like not surprised by it since he’s being active at least. not enough to take out of my PoE pool but yea

 

[toadsworthy]

I’m probably gonna sleep in tomorrow unless I set my alarm, so I’m sorry I haven’t really contributed much besides my Bianca tunnel which I’m already doubting. I’ll just move onto Toads idk.

If you guys end up lynching Shawo I’ll be so upset.

your read post on me is mostly talking about how you didn’t like my like first few posts, didn’t like my joke first posts, and my read on shawo which I think you shamefully missed the point of.

do you still feel the same about my posts with aerious? And everything afterward? Because otherwise your vote is one of the weaker ones

 

[Damniel]

but i’m also not convinced of glow as town yet since her posts have been mostly underwhelming. her recent pop in really only was to defend herself against ace’s sus (which has been repeatedly called out as weak several times) and calling out punchy. i would’ve expected like an update on more people who were here last night so i’m like meh on her still

 

[toadsworthy]

@Daniel I’m it giving a pass to any of those, but for the sake of today’s lynch, if we wanna talk inactives or new players I look more at pink shade first, then possibly frogslime... however I feel better about a shawo elim or aerious

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

I’m not*

 

[Damniel]

can i just say, this post slayed

what did you like about it? like do you think toads is scum from it too or

 

[Ace Marvel]

not only is your scumread on me best summarized by "weeeelllll i voted randomly, but regardless i committed myself to it, so here we are"
but you contradict yourself in an incredible fashion by "warning people to be wary of meta" while simultaneously placing a townread on someone that you consider to be skilled at blending in with ~meta from last game~

at least be specific for what meta you think qualifies to be an exception. at least explain what exactly makes you read me as mafia from your gut feeling. until then i'm not taking your reads on me seriously regardless of length.

When I see your true colors shinning true, this is a perfect example of what scum Epona would do, this is giving me wolf vibes galore extravaganza, way to defensive for being the only one that evens considers you mafia.

i apologise for this read bc i'm painfully aware that my entire read on bianca is based on meta (and i've always maintained an overeliance on meta is a dull and lazy way to play the game) but bianca's posts are so chaotic that i actually don't know if there's any way to read her except with the hindsight of meta

Scum Epona would never post something like this, but I might be wrong.

hm i don’t really like the wording of this. feels unnecessary and too conscious of self image

Which makes me feel she is town.

 

[Damniel]

Scum Epona would never post something like this, but I might be wrong.

i mean you’ve only seen one game from her I don’t think meta is that reliable to say she’d never do that

When I see your true colors shinning true, this is a perfect example of what scum Epona would do, this is giving me wolf vibes galore extravaganza, way to defensive for being the only one that evens considers you mafia.

it really just feels like you’re forcing your glow read when it just isn’t there. also glow and epona are different people so i don’t know why you bring up epona

 

[toadsworthy]

Holy crap a new Pokémon snap was announced