Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

[Ace Marvel]

glow was here by the last half hour but i doubt she wouldve moved off punchy either alignment

In my mind then glow is with Aerious, I will trust punchy read on glow.

Post automatically merged: Jun 19, 2020

you say this when you directly soft claimed detective to scum last game

Exactly because of that, nobody told me, so I'm passing advise on what not to do. sorry for trying to help a new player.

Post automatically merged: Jun 19, 2020

I find it funny, that you keep mentioning I should use meta, yet you keep bringing my last game quite often. Should I start with the cryptic clues?

 

[Feferily]

I was trying to type up a post on my phone before I realized I had switched keyboards and everything was unintelligible... but speaking of, I do wonder how the roles were handled over the night and if anybody else is going to give info on it today. I haven’t seen it handled before on forums. I also want to get some opinions on the people who didn’t vote Punchy or Sensai. I know ... two voted no elim?

 

[shawo]

I think we're going to need a lot more from
Slime
Lothi
Glow
bianca.

I have a read on everyone else in the game and having to decide on lynching the scummiest person who's here or lynching the scummiest person who's not here is the worst.

 

[Feferily]

Also going to finish reading up some of the older posts from Epona, Mayor, and Punchy since we know for sure they come from a town perspective.

 

[shawo]

I was trying to type up a post on my phone before I realized I had switched keyboards and everything was unintelligible... but speaking of, I do wonder how the roles were handled over the night and if anybody else is going to give info on it today. I haven’t seen it handled before on forums. I also want to get some opinions on the people who didn’t vote Punchy or Sensai. I know ... two voted no elim?

I can explain how every role works through the night. I planned on doing it during the night phase but didn't realize it was going to be locked.
I'll just do it now

 

[voltairenism]

Ive been banging my head on the wall bc EoD since I feel there was an unsaid consensus that both of them were town yet the bw was too strong to vote on anyone else. seems like most couldn't make up their minds on what would do the less damage hence the flips so I'm putting that on NAI for now

 

[Ace Marvel]

I was trying to type up a post on my phone before I realized I had switched keyboards and everything was unintelligible... but speaking of, I do wonder how the roles were handled over the night and if anybody else is going to give info on it today. I haven’t seen it handled before on forums. I also want to get some opinions on the people who didn’t vote Punchy or Sensai. I know ... two voted no elim?

Bianca is being Bianca
Everyone else in the end voted
except for Frogslimes who didn't vote and someone else since the total tally is 15.

 

[Damniel]

I was trying to type up a post on my phone before I realized I had switched keyboards and everything was unintelligible... but speaking of, I do wonder how the roles were handled over the night and if anybody else is going to give info on it today. I haven’t seen it handled before on forums. I also want to get some opinions on the people who didn’t vote Punchy or Sensai. I know ... two voted no elim?

the exacts of the roles are in the OP now. But no one should hard claim as a power role unless they got a definitive investigation on a scum (which could only be the tracker if there is one). other PRs should keep quiet

the only two to not vote punchy or sensai is bianca (no lim) and frogslime (no vote). frogslime would theoretically be either alignment since they haven't provided any thoughts yet and ive said my thoughts on Bianca

 

[voltairenism]

I dont mean everyone that flipped is town but that looking into that is not giving any answers

 

[Ace Marvel]

Ive been banging my head on the wall bc EoD since I feel there was an unsaid consensus that both of them were town yet the bw was too strong to vote on anyone else. seems like most couldn't make up their minds on what would do the less damage hence the flips so I'm putting that on NAI for now

Based on Toads actions would you consider a Toad wagon as possible?

 

[shawo]

Tracker/Watcher visit their target and receives a visit. We have a dead watcher but watcher was probably one of the more useful roles. Generally if you have a visit it means one of two things. I'll just skip over that.

Same with tracker, except you're able to actually sort out kills.

If you're roleblocked a visit doesn't go through, so if you track someone and they have a visit, they can't have been roleblocked. (If someone claims they were doc/roleblocked on kill for example.)

So if anyone visits a kill they MUST be mafia.

Secondly, visits always go through if ninja is jailed. That means jailer should be going after the ninja every day, because it means that the visits actually mean something.

obviously doc is there.

also, if there's one mafia left I'm pretty sure the jailkeeper can roleblock them. So if we're in a situation where we know who last mafia is, jailkeeper can set up a code with the person they jail to confirm the fact that they were jailed.
This is especially useful as it can set up autowin in an end game position.

That's all the ones important to right now.

 

[Damniel]

I can explain how every role works through the night. I planned on doing it during the night phase but didn't realize it was going to be locked.
I'll just do it now

role details are in the OP

 

[SensaiGallade]

Well this is awkward

 

[Lothitine]

Hi I’m so sorry I’m being so quiet hh I was workin in important stuff on another site and my phone died hhh


So is Ace still going after Aerious? Honestly I’m still not rlly sure why they’re doing that but you do you bro

 

[SensaiGallade]

Maf was obviously be content with me or Punchy going, for what it's worth the activity of people on each wagon from EoD1 should be looked into

 

[Ace Marvel]

Tracker/Watcher visit their target and receives a visit. We have a dead watcher but watcher was probably one of the more useful roles. Generally if you have a visit it means one of two things. I'll just skip over that.

Same with tracker, except you're able to actually sort out kills.

If you're roleblocked a visit doesn't go through, so if you track someone and they have a visit, they can't have been roleblocked. (If someone claims they were doc/roleblocked on kill for example.)

So if anyone visits a kill they MUST be mafia.

Secondly, visits always go through if ninja is jailed. That means jailer should be going after the ninja every day, because it means that the visits actually mean something.

obviously doc is there.

also, if there's one mafia left I'm pretty sure the jailkeeper can roleblock them. So if we're in a situation where we know who last mafia is, jailkeeper can set up a code with the person they jail to confirm the fact that they were jailed.
This is especially useful as it can set up autowin in an end game position.

That's all the ones important to right now.

So a Jailkeeper is a really important role we should protect at all costs?

 

[Damniel]

Maf was obviously be content with me or Punchy going, for what it's worth the activity of people on each wagon from EoD1 should be looked into

what's your analysis of EoD

 

[Ace Marvel]

Maf was obviously be content with me or Punchy going, for what it's worth the activity of people on each wagon from EoD1 should be looked into

That's all but Bianca and Frogslime.

 

[Aerious]

So a Jailkeeper is a really important role we should protect at all costs?

yes. jk is arguably the most important in this game (if we have one)

 

[Feferily]

the exacts of the roles are in the OP now. But no one should hard claim as a power role unless they got a definitive investigation on a scum (which could only be the tracker if there is one). other PRs should keep quiet

the only two to not vote punchy or sensai is bianca (no lim) and frogslime (no vote). frogslime would theoretically be either alignment since they haven't provided any thoughts yet and ive said my thoughts on Bianca

I’m assuming this also goes to anyone who could have been affected by a role during the night? That’s the thing I was wondering about.