@alexi no I'm not avoiding the thread I have just been reading this thread catching up. I'm done catching up. As for toad you almost sound like you are 100% sure that I'm scum. So you don't believe my sean claim?
any claim can be a safe claim until it's proven (like sarasakat's with xine). what was weird is that you randomly claimed when you werent even asked to (like you did in Tarot) and I'm still convinced you were scum in that game.
I really wanted to save my case against tardis for day 3, but I guess I'll start on it now.
I didn't vote for Inkling day 1 because I was out of town.... I kept posting saying I was gonna be back in town enough to catch up and vote, but it had already reached majority by the time I got home
this just sounds terrible... so where have you been forever? and then you're just gonna come in, same some broad general statement and try to affect the votes?
Putting my vote on Qwerty based on what m3ow_ has said as I don't feel comfortable pushing Alexi right now, even though I do feel she's acting differently than she was as town in Tarot mafia. I think Heyden deserves more chance to explain himself.
It's after midnight and I'm in a call with my bf and want to go to sleep after (day ends 4am my time), so I'm not going to go back right now and try to analyse/come up with something more solid. But I'm assuming a non-vote = modkill so y'know.
You won't hear from me again before the end of day. Sorry.
because D1 he softed blue, it was kinda ez to miss but I noticed
because I think he would be trying a lot harder in defending himself and also throughout the game, I mean he knows how to play and he's aware of what he's saying so I genuinely believe that the things he was mostly purposeful, and I know that if hes town he's not afraid of saying anything so he just freely blurts out whatever
he would be a lot more wary if he was actually scum. like when he was SK a couple games ago(I think it was papers please?) nobody thought he was sus all game until things about his claims stopped adding up when he got replaced by Crys
You do realize that you've said way more scummy things than he has, right? the only reason I've defended you throughout the game is because you claimed blue and you're un cc'd doctor lmao
I think we can make sure if two doctors are really doctors by having them say who they protected after the deadline (for actions to be sent in) and before day post is posted. There's a one hour gap which should be enough for them to get on and confirm, right?
Saying this now so the doctors remember and don't use the "I forgot to send in an action omg!!" excuse and as someone who pretended to be a doctor before, I can imagine what they'll say if they're not a doctor and can't prove it. Will remind again once night is up.
As you've probably noticed, I've been repeatedly saying that there can't be 2 Doctors in this game, and it was mostly because of how weird Aron is acting when he claimed. In particular in this post:
or you could protect me since there's a 100% chance maf's gonna kill me
- - - Post Merge - - -
on the bright side, I doubt the Mafia's gonna kill anybody this round. We all know they'll kill me and whoever the doctor is will protect me (or should because who else is the Maf gonna gun down?)
This post was made before Kat claimed as Doc, and it implied that he knows there's probably another doc. Why would he think there'd be another doc if he IS the doc? I was waiting for him to step up and play seriously, but he barely contributed seriously and posted this:
Honestly guys, I have no idea what's going on. The reason I haven't posted reads is because I've fallen way behind on reading the posts and at this point there's practically no way I'm going to be able to make any in-depth analysis.
Here's all I ask: Leave me alive for 2 more days. by day 4 if I'm not dead than consider me confirmed scum and lynch my @ss. All I ask is that you let me try to play doc right until then.
I know how hard it is to catch up, but I'm a replacement who wasn't in the game before D2, and you're a player who participated from the start. Catching up should be easier for you, yet you're not even trying?
As a doctor, you should be helping town scunhunting, because ultimately, it'll be your job to decide who is saved and who aren't.
And that paragraph is really weird. Ypu specifically want us to keep you alive until day 4? And your wording, "let you try to play doc"?
I hate people who aren't scum who fakeclaim and I hate town who don't even try.
any claim can be a safe claim until it's proven (like sarasakat's with xine). what was weird is that you randomly claimed when you werent even asked to (like you did in Tarot) and I'm still convinced you were scum in that game.
I really wanted to save my case against tardis for day 3, but I guess I'll start on it now.
@Alexi okay you can lynch me I'll flip as town. I don't believe that you are Scott Walker he doesn't sound like someone who would support Trump more like trying to stop him.
@Alexi okay you can lynch me I'll flip as town. I don't believe that you are Scott Walker he doesn't sound like someone who would support Trump more like trying to stop him.
@Alexi okay you can lynch me I'll flip as town. I don't believe that you are Scott Walker he doesn't sound like someone who would support Trump more like trying to stop him.
I haven't even voted for you yet. I figured I'd bring up the two times you said you were going to respond to a case on you, but never did. Avoiding it is just making you seem scummier really.
I haven't even voted for you yet. I figured I'd bring up the two times you said you were going to respond to a case on you, but never did. Avoiding it is just making you seem scummier really.
he's done more than enough to be scummy.... and Cory put down a random vote and peaced.
Heyden could've soft claimed (as a ploy to not get lynched) and then left. Kinda different
and did I switch my vote absolutely not.... I'm just saying, Meow is pushing Heyden as town as town can be, and you have to admit he has been acting scummy whether or not you believe it.
yeah but some can argue that Aron's scummy too but we didn't lynch him did we?
if you really wanna lunch blues so bad that's pretty scummy too. just saying ~
i agreee Heyden could have just soft claimed and left so that we wouldn't lynch him also so no one can really cc (if they wanted too.) but i don't want to lynch a PR if he is telling the truth so that leaves me with either Alexi, Tardis, or Qwerty- whom just came in jumped on the Alexi bandwagon and voted to save themselves from being mod-killed with no real explanation. which makes me feel like Alexi might be a bad choice now, sense she is becoming a bandwagon. as of right now i think the best bet might be Qwerty but still hoping Xine comes back in time with some reads she was gonna make, to get another perspective.
yeah but some can argue that Aron's scummy too but we didn't lynch him did we?
if you really wanna lunch blues so bad that's pretty scummy too. just saying ~
but the way both are doing it is scummy af, can you not see that? so if anyone claims a blue role your just gonna believe them? Aron I think only has a limited number of trackable moves tonight, so I think we will know what to do with him on Day 3. and at least he said he is the doctor. Heyden is soft claiming a blue role and alluding to maybe being the cop, but he just said it and left.... DO YOU NOT SEE WHY THAT IS A SKETCHY?
- - - Post Merge - - -
god I'm literally done trying to explain things, you guys are all set in the way you are going to think so just go about the rest of your day... you aren't going to try understand anything I bring up then I'm not gonna be so conversational, but clearly I'm not acting on all these things I bring up, I just think its funny that he's doing something scummy and you all believe him for all he's worth despite everything else he's done
1. What is your timezone? EDT. 11PM here atm. 2. How do you react under pressure? Pretty well I guess? I'm not really under pressure a lot. 3. Do you prefer to play as town or mafia? So far I'm always town ): so I can't say which one I'd prefer. 4. What are you going to be known to do this game? Get better at my reads hopefully. Be active, as usual.
Alexi, when I say insincere, I mean your tone doesn't sound genuine. I don't doubt what you say is fact - but the tone in which you say it is extremely awkward.
I don't really know how tone can be read through text. i always answer that question the same though.
very quick to be sus of someone, don't you think? not even an hour into the game.
HEre alexi is defensive about how quick sarasa was sus of someone. Extremely defensive. Also claims that she didn't know tone could be read through text.
I'm not saying don't question the answers from the RQS lmao. I'm just saying more than half the people have yet to post so it seems quick to be sus of anyone really.
okay.. so @aron, flip flopping with being pro and being noob at this.
said you're playing as "50% mafia" like what?
APPEAL TO EMOTION LIKE CRAZY. i think this tops ness actually.
idk. i really don't know what to think. crazy 3rd party most likely.
As per lately, Xine delivers with good reads and has similiar sus with who I'm thinking - which is Ness. Really just been waiting for him to come on and post then go from there.
Welll. Slept in and looks like I'll be here today instead. Feel like a piece of **** for not making it to my uncle's funeral and istg if any of you come at me for AtE or any personal attacks I will go right back at you. Apparently AtE = scum but apparently NOT after the way Aron reacted to claiming doctor SO I'm just throwing that out there, I'm not in a good place right now.
all I wana say right now is, shiida, you have a really good point with m3ow. I'm not saying m3ow is scum but I didn't like how she basically told us all to get off Aron and that he made a mistake bla bla. I already had said my opinions towards him weere 60% town, 20% scum, 20% doctor, but then she said that it was like I had to be 100% believed he was town or i was scum.
I hope that makes sense. It's just something real quick I thought I'd say. I'll get everyones reads together later when I have a better, more clear mindset.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Actually nah I'll do it now.
heyden
reactions towards aron's claim seemed genuine. town to me.
call me daniel
also was there to react to aron's claim.. seemed kinda off with the "whats your role." instead of reacting to the fact our doctor just outted themselves. but, seems pretty town to me regardless.
tardis2016
as always, tardis just seems confused and i dont really think thats a good reason to be lynching him to be honest. idk what he is reallly.
panda1376
town. panda's been really helpful so far. i didnt really agree with her x cory back and forth but i guess both made sense.
sarasakat
also was there to react to aron's claim... actually kinda seems waay off and kinda scummy especially with asking about anyone's roles if they had one similar to Ronald Reagan... Idk if you meant to make it sound like that, but it did. thats been the one thing that seems off to me for her.
xine
xine always has good reasons but y'know, I didn't agree with the inkling case because theres lots of others who have yet to post a lot too, so that didn't make sense to me but the rest did.
crys
i'm awaiting this "[good]" post from crys. should be interesting.
toadsworthy
your read on sarasakat, while some points weren't as strong as they could've been, made sense. pretty town to me i think.
clameatscurry
not really enough posts to say, but the one they made about aron bringing attention to himself was smart and obv made sense. idk im null for them.
ness
unsure, but i think i'll be more sure when he posts more today.
cadbberry
her RQS seemed really off but it's her first game so, i'm really just thinking town. null, if anything.
m3ow_
said my opinion before.
inkling
as always a little defensive, but i think this time it was pretty justified.
kevinnn
null. hasnt posted enough.
cory
town. if anyone reads town in this entire list to me, it's cory.
taesaek
reactions to the DR claim seemed genuine and i agreed to them. pretty town to me.
aronthaer
i really dont know.
qwerty111
null. not enough posts.
mother of all llamas
null. not enough posts. but im glad they pposted their reads on everyone just recently.
In her quick reads she states that she thats she think Daniel is town, after doing scummy [kind of off] things she says that inkling is justifiably defensive and reads her as town I think that weird as later shes completely agreeing with xine on inkling being scum. She also talks about ATE retracting her statement from earlier about it.
yesss tae is back. im loving this right now - esp your read on aron. everyone wants to townread him but i can pull real quick 5+ quotes from him that sound scummy as hell.
I think you want him to be lynched because he's the doc, a pr. If anyone claims doc, the smartest thing to do would leave them to Day 2, where you're able to figure out what happened at night. Bad logic coming from Alexi.
She believes M3ow is scum for defending the doctor. Alexi then says that he is going to coast, but if anyone was doc, coasting be need to be done to stay alive and get out of the mafia.
She says no lynch, saying it could be a good idea, then probably not, why mention it then say its a bad idea. It seems like she was trying to build trust by saying painfully obvious things.
This is the last thing I quoted, but I find this weird in this as how earlier before Alexi suspected ness earlier, It seems like she dropped it here, but continues to suspect him after he said "the town" again. Make up your mind would ya?
and as someone who pretended to be a doctor before, I can imagine what they'll say if they're not a doctor and can't prove it. Will remind again once night is up.
