Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[N e s s]

Probably shouldn't speak up, but I play tons of Mafia, it's my go-to game at parties, gatherings and such. So no, this isn't my "first game," just my first game on TBT.

You're not understanding the point i'm trying to make. To me, it looks like you have slipped townie. i know that you have played werewolf before, but the point is that forum mafia is way different then werewolf and town of salem combined.

tldr: You look like you accidentally townslipped.

 

[Aronthaer]

You're not understanding the point i'm trying to make. To me, it looks like you have slipped townie. i know that you have played werewolf before, but the point is that forum mafia is way different then werewolf and town of salem combined.

tldr: You look like you accidentally townslipped.

Welp. RIP me when night 1 rolls around haha

 

[Damniel]

Ah, and I'm a she

Alexi's reply the the third question read odd to me - " So far I'm always town ): so I can't say which one I'd prefer."

It reads insincere.

How come you didn't say the same thing about Panda when she basically said the same thing?

 

[N e s s]

I'm not saying don't question the answers from the RQS lmao. I'm just saying more than half the people have yet to post so it seems quick to be sus of anyone really.

In your eyes, I look like I said "oh you're saying not to answer my RQS questions?"
The real point: We're all trying to get information out of Day 1, so why shouldn't we question someone for standing out on something?

I don't know what you're trying to say. I say that you look suspicious, and you post this reply that doesn't even correlate to what I said. Why should it matter if majority of players have yet to post when someone is looking suspicious, kind of like you?

 

[Aronthaer]

This thread reeks of scum...

 

[Damniel]

Welp. RIP me when night 1 rolls around haha

Why? Mafia would know you're town, so town slipping doesn't do anything. It's not like you blue slipped, so why would you be a target?

 

[glow]

hi all

1. What is your timezone? PST
2. How do you react under pressure? fairly well unless it's irl things :^)
3. Do you prefer to play as town or mafia? mafia i think. although i've only been mafia once, it was fun
4. What are you going to be known to do this game? bringing honor to my lord and savior trump
Pronouns: She

 

[N e s s]

Welp. RIP me when night 1 rolls around haha

This post essentially confirmed that I think Aron is noob town right now.

 

[Damniel]

This post essentially confirmed that I think Aron is noob town right now.

I wouldn't say it essentially confirms he's town, I could see any newbie player say that regaurdless of alignment

 

[toadsworthy]

1. I'm in CDT timezone.
2.. I will reply to it.
3. I like being on the town side because I don't feel like I'm trying to lynch my scum partners.
4. I will try and not roleclaim so early and try to be more active I think both of them almost got me lynched in the last game but it was canceled.

does no one else find this wording suspicious too?

 

[Shondell]

Hey all, just checking in to let you all know I'm here, woke up pretty early due to a headache but I think I'll be fine.
1. GMT+2
2. Not too sure, I haven't played forum mafia before but I guess fairly well?
3. Mafia seems really fun, too bad I'm only town
4. I don't know
5. Female

 

[f11]

This post essentially confirmed that I think Aron is noob town right now.

anyone can fake a noobslip so idk why ur clearing him so easily.

 

[N e s s]

I wouldn't say it essentially confirms he's town, I could see any newbie player say that regaurdless of alignment

Its not him saying it confirms him in general, i'm just using what we have right now. In my eyes, his motivation behind that post are the adjectives of~

-Not thinking it through/proofreading
-Being new to forum mafia (Lucanosa was only familiar with werewolf in his first game, and look at his meta)

To me, he just seems like noob town who didn't proof read his post. I'm not confirming him, i'm just using my current thoughts.

 

[Shondell]

does no one else find this wording suspicious too?

Yeah, it does look pretty off, but I think he might have just worded it wrong? I don't think he is mafia based on one sentence, but it could a huge unintentional leak.

 

[Kirbystarship]

My scum partners? is this just like a major slip? or is this just worded extremely weird?

That post I made it was talking about the last time I played scum and why I didn't want to be scum.

 

[Damniel]

Its not him saying it confirms him in general, i'm just using what we have right now. In my eyes, his motivation behind that post are the adjectives of~

-Not thinking it through/proofreading
-Being new to forum mafia (Lucanosa was only familiar with werewolf in his first game, and look at his meta)

To me, he just seems like noob town who didn't proof read his post. I'm not confirming him, i'm just using my current thoughts.

But you didn't say you think he's town, you said he's "essentially confirmed town". As Crys put it, any noob can fake a slip like that. The way you worded you're clearing of him is odd.

 

[toadsworthy]

That post I made it was talking about the last time I played scum and why I didn't want to be scum.

so you are referring to Tarot then? so I guess we know where you stand if that game were to come back

 

[N e s s]

You're not understanding the point i'm trying to make. To me, it looks like you have slipped townie. i know that you have played werewolf before, but the point is that forum mafia is way different then werewolf and town of salem combined.

tldr: You look like you accidentally townslipped.

Daniel i just said in this post that I thought he looked like slipped townie, are you referring to me not explicitly calling him town?

- - - Post Merge - - -

This post essentially confirmed that I think Aron is noob town right now.

^^

 

[inkling]

hai guys

 

[Arstotzkan]

I don't really know how tone can be read through text. i always answer that question the same though.
very quick to be sus of someone, don't you think? not even an hour into the game.

Alexi, tell me the difference between these two statements:

"I am so mad right now. I could kick a wall."

"I am ****ing livid. I'm going to shatter that wall over there to smithereens so help me God."

Tone can be read through text (surprisingly easily, actually). You've actually addressed this yourself iirc in mentioning Ness's emotional game.

Also tell me: what about pointing out something shady, scumhunting is wolfy? What else would we be doing besides be answering RVS if I didn't point out my suspicion of you?

@Toads Nah - it read like a hypothetical situation.