Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[piichinu]

maybe im not trying to put a big red ex on my back the way aron did.

the bid red ex on aron is from his roleclaim not from his reads

- - - Post Merge - - -

x*

- - - Post Merge - - -

and about that thing i thought i had figured out, nvm. smth happened here that made me change my mind.

 

[tae]

maybe im not trying to put a big red ex on my back the way aron did.

i guess maybe you have something to hide then. since voicing your opinions = a big red x on your back.

your argument makes no sense. we're not asking you to roleclaim wtf. we want your opinion not your role. please read.

 

[Kirbystarship]

I'm reading Alexi scum but I'm not sure because she keeps flip flopping around.

yeah I can just see it as giving a first time player some general advice really.

@aron you were pretty sus to me in the beginning but like I said earlier thats pretty much gone so I'm as well not voting for you. think it's been established that voting our doctor is well.. stupid.
care you explain a little more on the sus of ness though? do you just agree with whats been said or maybe something new?

She is no longer sus of Aron so she is defending him because she believes him after he claimed to be doctor and is trying to help him.

the more i look into it, the more aron screams scum.

aron if you really want to make some good guesses and lynch some scum, maybe a read on someone who hasn't been already mentioned? or even someone who has been but for different reasons you find sus?

Do you still think that Aron is still the doctor? And you are no longer defending him. I'm asking this because you are no longer believing him. Or you are no longer showing it.

 

[xine]

maybe im not trying to put a big red ex on my back the way aron did.

You don't even post besides to defend yourself lol

 

[PandaDarling]

I would REALLY prefer to lynch inkling today, because while I see me0ws points I also believe that Alexi contributes a lot while inkling has done basically nothing. Alexi has contributed and given opinions, although wishy washy, at least they are somewhat valid.

@Xine are you not in favor of a Ness lynch given how he's acted in the last few hours with what little time we have left ? I want you opinion cause i get accused of tunneling (especially him) a lot (so I've been told recently) and i just want a fresh opinion.

Still in favor of a Ness or Inkling lynch. (neither of you please don't blow up on me)

 

[piichinu]

how about we all stop trying to pin people as scum based on what they think of aron?
you cant deny that aron gave off the impression of messing around with town, especially since he said that. so being sus of him doesnt make anyone else sus imo.

and thats why im not willing to lynch alexi yet since i had the same thoughts about aron.

 

[Cadbberry]

maybe im not trying to put a big red ex on my back the way aron did.

Aron did place an X on his back but he will die soon if he is really the doctor. You on the other hand have given some odd responses and have made little help on these topics, I understand work/school issues but even the evening contributions have not helped much.

 

[xine]

maybe im not trying to put a big red ex on my back the way aron did.

Not giving reads = not putting target on your back

Considering you're my main priority and you haven't give developed reads, this is highly contradictory

 

[inkling]

i guess maybe you have something to hide then. since voicing your opinions = a big red x on your back.

your argument makes no sense. we're not asking you to roleclaim wtf. we want your opinion not your role. please read.

i gave my opinion last night. i posted my reads. how can i have an opinion right now when i just got home and said ill catch up.

im not scared of voicing my opinions, but i think its pretty dangerous to vote so randomly.

 

[mother of all llamas]

Tardis you're just repeating what everyone else said....
@Inkling, I don't really believe for what you have to say, could change depending but you still look scummy to me unless you can come up with a better defense.. Me being inactive doesn't mean you can't be suspicous

 

[piichinu]

i gave my opinion last night. i posted my reads. how can i have an opinion right now when i just got home and said ill catch up.

im not scared of voicing my opinions, but i think its pretty dangerous to vote so randomly.

then dont vote, give reads !!

 

[inkling]

Not giving reads = not putting target on your back

Considering you're my main priority and you haven't give developed reads, this is highly contradictory

so you obviously have not read my posts enough to give a deep enough read or else you would have seen this:

at this point there isn't much to go off of but here are my current thoughts in a nutshell:

i think tae is being unusually quiet. i think this important to make note of and I'd like to hear an explanation.

heyden is following his typical meta so is probs town.

n e s s, its hard to say. i think he did get frustrated and quit. maybe he's giving himself breathing room? in the last game he was scum and acted defensive but was a bit more calm and collected. this game he kinda just exploded so i think he might really be town.

cad, seems like she's trying to be helpful to town and didnt post previously bc she was unsure or whatever.

xine is trying to be helpful to town but i don't feel she asks enough questions.

panda is being less aggressive this game

there's definitely something off about aron. i know m3ow and xine are defending him. but maybe he read the last game and saw the doctor was killed d1 and wanted to start a guilt trip? i don't want to lynch him of course but something's not right here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh and tardis is very confused as usual

ya, you're helpful to town. nah, you're just trying to find an easy target. thats what sum does

- - - Post Merge - - -

*scum

- - - Post Merge - - -

then dont vote, give reads !!

what are your reads. could you link me please?

 

[Chrystina]

@tardis: i explained why i've been literally everywhere about aron, did you read it? as of right now I STILL don't know wth he is, but i've said multiple times i'm not voting for him.


my vote right now is leaning towards ness but i have to look further at inklings posts. a LOT of people have yet still to post and it's crazy considering theres 2 hours left.


also @crys i was so hyped for that?! lmao. actually i don't think i've ever seen any reads from you so it was a nice build up at least.

 

[xine]

@Xine are you not in favor of a Ness lynch given how he's acted in the last few hours with what little time we have left ? I want you opinion cause i get accused of tunneling (especially him) a lot (so I've been told recently) and i just want a fresh opinion.

Still in favor of a Ness or Inkling lynch. (neither of you please don't blow up on me)

I am not in favor of a Ness lynch anymore considering that he is tunneling someone that I consider to be town, if he was scum he would've just sheeped a bandwagon instead of causing a scene.

I'm not completely townreading him but again, like Alexi, he is making contributional posts

 

[piichinu]

okay, first of all, ive only played like 1/12th of a mafia game, so this could all be wrong or really bad but thats ok i guess.

heyden
he seems like town to me so far. i was reading through all his posts and his reactions all seem genuine, dont have anything to use against him as of now

call me daniel
ive got nothing on daniel. could be anything.

alexi
i think her reactions to the aron incident were genuine, so ill base what i think of her off of that (for now). town, maybe an important role

tardis2016
tardis seems kinda innocent, it always feels like theyre getting jumped on (and for good reasons of course) but i dont really wanna say anything here yet. i read their posts and i have no idea what to make of anything. seems like a sloppy playstyle

panda1376
town id say, posts seem genuinely helpful

sarasakat
i don't know

xine
ive only read their big post. i dont have enough to say anything about xine.

crys
unsure, maybe scum cuz shes quieter in this game than the other but then again idk if irl stuff is going on or

toadsworthy
as others have said, he just really wants to help so hes posting anything he can.

clameatscurry
unsure!!

ness
unsure, and i dont wanna hop on the ness bandwagon just yet, so i wont say anything here yet. i will say this though, i saw someone say one of ness' posts was awkward, but from what ive seen is he tends to be an awkward poster outside of mafia. not defending him though, just something to keep in mind.

cadbberry
not definite town, but hasnt done anything to come off as scummy yet

m3ow_
i actually think m3ow is kinda scummy. the thing about "anyone lynching aron will be in my crosshairs" was like..trying too hard to be passionate about helping town.

inkling
scum, even if theyre not, its kinda annoying how all of their posts are based off of personal dislike of people, especially from that last mafia game.

kevinnn
hasnt done anything that shouts town, but also hasnt done anything scummy

cory
tbh i was doctor in the last mafia game, and i was gonna save cory from the lynching train, but i couldnt bc i was banned. however in this game im not rly believing in him so much. i think hes possibly scum. then again i dont have much evidence. so this is hard.

taesaek
don't know

aronthaer
as i said before, seemed like a bad coverup to a silly mistake, i only called him mafia to so hed be more inclined to respond to me. im not sure how party mafia works exactly so i wanted to find out the rules to see if ppl rly did claim that early. so town for now.

qwerty111
kinda innocent. not sure

mother of all llamas
idk but i think panda said they were being kinda quiet and thats true.

since i wrote this ive changed my mind about alexi somewhat, and see sarasa as more scummy than i thought.

 

[Heyden]

//30 pages to read thx guys

 

[f11]

@tardis: i explained why i've been literally everywhere about aron, did you read it? as of right now I STILL don't know wth he is, but i've said multiple times i'm not voting for him.


my vote right now is leaning towards ness but i have to look further at inklings posts. a LOT of people have yet still to post and it's crazy considering theres 2 hours left.


also @crys i was so hyped for that?! lmao. actually i don't think i've ever seen any reads from you so it was a nice build up at least.

good were in brackets for a reason lol. I suck at reads and never usual give them so this is new.

 

[N e s s]

My reply to all who suspect me.

I started all of this on Page 50 up til this point.

@Ness you seem to want to agree with Sarasakat straight away when she barely gave any reason to her read or even letting Alexi respond, i don't know if you two may be on the same mafia team or if you are just trying to agree with her to seem pro-town as you know that Sarasakat is a good player and you don't want to be under her radar.

Just to say, I only agreed to Kat's points. I do post later a suspicion on Alexi before Kat said anything about it, but if you think about it in all the games i've been scum, i've never bussed a strong teammate. If I were scum, me pushing Kat this hard wouldn't mean the 2 of us would be scum together.

Ness's logic for clearing me is a bit flawed, but then again, I've seen a lot of flawed logic flying around today. To be honest, this whole thing looks a bit suspicious, but for the life of me I don't know who's who.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I JUST GOT A FILLING DONE I CANT FEEL MY FACE ARGHHH HELP

But in the end, I was correct. You claiming doctor confimed that I think you're town.

Also just a side note, Honey.dew slot has me conflicted as town/scum now.

No one really seems scummy to me to be honest, Kat seems aggressive but knowing Kat outsidd mafia I know she can be kind of aggressive. Ness seems to be always lynched d1 at TBT but he was trying to get information too I think.

Don't understand this too well, but yes. I was trying to get alignment tells.

From here on after a while people are just arguing about Aron's claim until the next suspicion about me on post 859.

Still pretty iffy about Ness, considering he was posting a decent amount up to when I sussed him, then he backed off and slinked into the shadows

Because I had to go do community service for my future resume c:

@M3ow oh ya i forgot to add that in my post, Ness is still leaning towards scum for me, but i want to wait for him to come back and reply to my last post. i know everyone has irc stuff but that is a characteristic of Ness's to hide away when he starts to get accused cause he knows he will tend to be too emotional. and plus he was posting in the critique thread and all that without coming here to help us understand his motives.

That was mostly because it was late at night, and I was getting frustrated since i'm getting tired of being the D1 lynch all the time. I just want to live until the end of a game for once, since for some reason i'm always scumread when i'm trying to do something as either alignment on these forums. This isn't an issue for me on several other websites i play mafia on, so it gets frustrating when people always scum read you for the same usual thought process. That is all.

oh I missed this.
Ness as usual has shown frustration/emotion when even 1 person is sus of him, so yeah I see him scummy as of now.
Cory.. idk, I think he just reacted bad towards the doctor claim. most of us did, but he took it kinda far (sorry cory, I understand why Im JS)

Its starting to upset me how people are taking my emotional brain from null to always scum. I get emotional as either alignment, so I don't understand this shift its taken when I hardly even was emotional besides being frustrated a bit.

Both of these are a bit awkwardly phrased which leads me to believe they are forced. Not so much about Honey, but more about "yes let's get back on topic" when the discussion seemed to be mostly about him, I found it weird for him to say this. Maybe it's just me, but it seems like he is trying to restrain himself here.

I can see your thought process here. The reason I said "Lets get back on topic" was because of the banter going about on Honey/Shondell, not that there was only topics about me going on.

maybe Ness gave up? im kinda confused right now he post a picture after Toms reply to him in the Critique thread and then i quoted it and replied but now all 2-3 of those post are gone, how did they get deleted.

Please don't think that I give up whenever I go offline in these games. I'm a hardworking honors student, and I have homework to do all the time now.

Ness: His inactivity is interesting to say the least, and does smell kinda scummy. However, he could have legitimate reasons, so I'm waiting for him to show up again. If he doesn't post by the time night closes in and no one else is practically confirmed scum he gets my vote.

I said that I was busy, and you say I was genuine. I'm moving on from this.

and up til that last post that was the only main post that questioned me.

---

I'm going to do some reads after this post, but i hope this post summed up everything. I put this off for a while since i was reading back, but its here.

 

[PandaDarling]

maybe im not trying to put a big red ex on my back the way aron did.

@Inkling what? oh man i don't know if this is a mafia slip or a PR slip, what do you when put a big red x on your back? we don't want to harm you we just want you to contribute more to be helpful towards us lynching scum.

I am not in favor of a Ness lynch anymore considering that he is tunneling someone that I consider to be town, if he was scum he would've just sheeped a bandwagon instead of causing a scene.

I'm not completely townreading him but again, like Alexi, he is making contributional posts

@Xine thank you for your input and i will take it into consideration but this seriously made me laugh cause you obviously don't know our little pineapple head (Ness) very well, tunneling and making a scene is what he's best at, im pretty sure others that know him would agree to this, am i right?

 

[inkling]

since i wrote this ive changed my mind about alexi somewhat, and see sarasa as more scummy than i thought.

u read me wrong, and the statement in itself is a bit ironic. in last game, i i scumread cory and dolby mostly so not sure where those ideas came from.

i agree with you on sarsa and m3ow. i didn't like m3ow's comment either.

i havent really seen qwerty contribute much, and im wondering why. are they trying not to be noticed>