Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[PandaDarling]

Ok, I really, REALLY dislike your reasoning for doing this. You literally just admitted that you had inconsistency to tunneling a doctor claim, so you attempt to cover it up, and hope that someone can point it out so you can try to call them town. It sounds hypocritical for me to say this, but why would you automatically call me town right away when scum can do situations like this as well, when you were obviously suspecting me for "lurking", and had me as one of you main prioritys to lynch today?

@Ness i don't think Sarasakat even had you as one of her "main priorities to lynch today" but if you thought that to be true then you coming back as OMGUS (im hoping im using the tern correctly) and getting all on her because you thought she suspects you then thats pretty scummy and very common for your usual emotions scum meta imo.

-also congrats for now wasting hours arguing with Sarasakat and NOT responding to all of us about our suspicions on you. thank you.

 

[N e s s]

@Ness i don't think Sarasakat even had you as one of her "main priorities to lynch today" but if you thought that to be true then you coming back as OMGUS (im hoping im using the tern correctly) and getting all on her because you thought she suspects you then thats pretty scummy and very common for your usual emotions scum meta imo.

-also congrats for now wasting hours arguing with Sarasakat and NOT responding to all of us about our suspicions on you. thank you.

These are my current strong reads. The scale goes from
Very town
Slight town
Neutral/Null
Slight suspicions
Heavy scum read

Difference between Neutral and Null is that Neutral is split between Town and Mafia. Null is lack of evidence for either.

9. Toadsworthy - When I was coaching him, I told him when he was suspicious of someone, to make a case. And well, he did. And he showed he was willing to put in the effort to take initiative into a dying thread and start something new, which is generating discussion and protown. My only gripes with him is that he's tunneling and he hasn't really made any reads apparent besides his scumread of me iirc. Before I get asked, tunneling is ducking your head in and charging at someone full speed ahead going out of your way to find anything that points them towards being mafia, regardless of the evidence being sound or not. And while that concerns me, I think him being on the initiative is something that marks a town player, and he has been inactive so it's harder for him to give other reads.

---

10. ClamEatsCurry - As one of two people in here who have meta experience on Curry (Cad, Curry, and I have played Town of Salem before), this fits his town play. He doesn't seem like he's afraid to throw up whatever thoughts he has, where iirc he would try to be a little more guarded of his opinions as scum. I would appreciate you posting more, though.

---

11. Ness - Gonna look back in a sec. You've been very unremarkable. Which in your case, is concerning. I get IRL can be in the way sometimes, but you're the kind who has a very hands-in-deep meta regardless, picking fights wherever you can.

Considering he's known to be active as both town and mafia though, I don't think you can call him mafia for being AFK. It is interesting to note, however, so we should look back at a lot of his earlier posts.

---

12. Cadbberry - She seems tunneled on Tardis because of OMGUS ("you're suspicious of me, so Imma be suspicious of you"). Her replies also came off as... oddly defensive for not being a major topic at all. I'd like to hear your opinion on other issues, Cad. What do you think about the suspicion against me? What about the whole Doc fiasco?

---

13. M3ow_ - From what little you've posted, something's bothered me about your tone. I'll look back on evidence and specify what I mean in a little.

---

16. Cory - Someone said earlier that town!Cory is usually less reserved and willing to pick fights. I can see it as a general trend, but he was adamant about the sacrificial blade and whoever didn't out that they had the daggar was scum. And he has scumhunted a little, which is promising, but I generally have a "Lynch all Hypocrits" policy, and Cory pretty clearly broke that when talking about Curry and Toads being the only two scumhunters when he wasn't scumhunting himself. And he hasn't really scumhunted much, to be fair.

Also for future reference, but maybe his townread of me came about to pocket me. Iirc he said people needed to be more townie to go into his town circle, I townread him for saying that, and then he put me in the circle immediately after for meta reasons. One post can't be enough to change someone's mind from null regarding their meta to town, right?

---

18. Aronthaer - Claimed Doc, and he seems like ever since the drama blew over, he's been trying to some extent to scumhunt. I don't think a new scum player would think to do that.

Imma start reading up on the others, but Meow, Ness, and Tardis are my priorities.

Here you go panda

 

[Chrystina]

Looking at the votes for me atm: Tardis, Aron, SarasaKat, and Cadbberry.

So I'm not sure really where to start with defending myself, considering most of these votes are all from m3ow's read on me. I see a lotttt of people saying I'm being wishy washy flippy floppy idek whatever you wanna call it. This day 1 has been so exhausting for me it's incredible. Usually I'm not a strong town player, but I feel like in Tarot I gained some confidence in my reads, so I was hyped for this game to start cause I'm just gonna get better. then I put up my rqs and sarasakat quickly reaction tests me. thats fine, scumhunting I get it.

Then a doctor claim, then all of the posts following after that, one word: ridiculous. It set this day 1 as we're off to SUCH a bad start, and it just did a complete turn of events as to what I'm usually used to. so, there's my defense as to why I've been tunneling aron, being wishy washy etc.

if anyone has any other reasoning for voting for me, I'd love to hear why

 

[N e s s]

@Ness i don't think Sarasakat even had you as one of her "main priorities to lynch today" but if you thought that to be true then you coming back as OMGUS (im hoping im using the tern correctly) and getting all on her because you thought she suspects you then thats pretty scummy and very common for your usual emotions scum meta imo.

-also congrats for now wasting hours arguing with Sarasakat and NOT responding to all of us about our suspicions on you. thank you.

Actually wait. You're going to cherry pick me saying that I had suspicion for her saying i was one of her priorities to lynch today, yet your not going to look or read any of my other points?

 

[Aronthaer]

wow, two votes for Inkling. What happened while I was gone?

 

[Arstotzkan]

@Ness I wanted to read your posts, didn't necessarily scum read you

 

[PandaDarling]

Here you go panda

@Ness i think you are misreading her post, she put you as null... and i think she meant you were a priority to start reading up on, im not sure, kinda looks weird but either way you coming back and getting all OMG you sus me so im going to sus you is scummy Ness. just please stop wasting our time and get to what you promised before deadline or you will be my vote, im sorry i don't want to keep lynching you D1 but you're honestly not giving us much of an option when you are refusing to deliver what you are promising and not helping us at all.

 

[N e s s]

@Ness i think you are misreading her post, she put you as null... and i think she meant you were a priority to start reading up on, im not sure, kinda looks weird but either way you coming back and getting all OMG you sus me so im going to sus you is scummy Ness. just please stop wasting our time and get to what you promised before deadline or you will be my vote, im sorry i don't want to keep lynching you D1 but you're honestly not giving us much of an option when you are refusing to deliver what you are promising and not helping us at all.

But you're just choosing to cherry pick that i was suspicious of her for saying i was priority to lynch (now that you point it out, she didn't mean that) but you're going to disregard my other points on her?

 

[piichinu]

wow, two votes for Inkling. What happened while I was gone?

nothing, for me personally i was suspicious of inkling in my initial read and im not comfortable voting alexi just yet so i switched to inkling. xine posted her reads about inkling as well.

 

[inkling]

home from work. fyi i cant be on my phone at work i work at a salon and its bust on saturdays so im gonna catch up now.

 

[PandaDarling]

But you're just choosing to cherry pick that i was suspicious of her for saying i was priority to lynch (now that you point it out, she didn't mean that) but you're going to disregard my other points on her?

@Ness im not disregarding your other points, im just saying you either misunderstood her or you are twisting what she said to fit your suspicion of her (which is scummy) and again you are wasting so much damn time. Maybe i just see it differently the stupid claiming doctor thing has really thrown us off and i don't even know what to completely make of it still myself. it could have been a really lame mistake on Aron's part of it might be part of a master plan by mafia/third party... but i was just hoping the after D1, cause we aren't obviously gonna lynch our (might be) doctor, that more info would help us determine what to do with him and his role claim.

- - - Post Merge - - -

home from work. fyi i cant be on my phone at work i work at a salon and its bust on saturdays so im gonna catch up now.

:: waiting for the emotional outburst:: ha

 

[mother of all llamas]

I'm going to vote for inkling mainly because her activity in the game has been really off. Her tone is also less aggresive and I can sebse that her posts seem pretty forced. At first I thought they were changing to not start up any arguements again, but right now I'm definitely getting a feeling thats she could possibly be scum. As for Alexi, I'm not too sure what to think of her yet but I don't feel right voting her after the turnover of events for hee and emotions are probably just getting to her. I'm more confident with an Inkling vote anyhow.
And to address the people, yes, I know my inactivity irritates you all so I'm probably going to only sign up for replacements from now on... Sorry for inconveniencing you all...

Note: my vote is not firm, depending on Inklings defense of course

 

[f11]

Spoiler

Heyden
Heyden so far has gone with what a majority of people have said and posted a small chatter. However I think that this corresponds with there usual town play. He said that he'll be back so I'm waiting for his thoughts before I say anything definitive. A couple of his posts have thrown me off due to its lack of seriousness. I am bookmarking his push on Aron in day 1.
Call me Daniel
Daniels inactivity of day has thrown me off. One of his posts

I have to go out for a few hours, but when I get back I'll make a nice long post of my reads y'all seem to like from me, with all them juicy quotes and stuff. Should be back in the afternoon. Seems like everyone is posting their reads, yet don't really say who they want to lynch today.

this one, makes me feel he may be scum. In another game, reindeer mafia, a game where he was mafia he posted reads on day 1 matches the desciption of what he will be posting later. Like heyden, I will be waiting for their next posts.
Alexi
I feel like alexi's playstyle has changed a little from the last games I have played with her. In this game she feels a bit more flip floppy, ridng on the backs of others. Meow, read of her was execllent, I especially agreed with the point that her opinion of ATE changed so easily, perhaps it changed when you realized you are scum and were going to use it (jk)? I am kind of in the fence of Alexi though, I have some questions for them before I label her as scum or town.
Sarasakat
Slight scum read. I think she's diverging from her town play, where she usually questions things. She has not been mafia in awhile here on tbt so I'm going to check mafiauniverse to see if the meta of her last scum game matches up. Like most on this lynch im not 100% sure as of now.
Toadsworthy
I noticed toadworthy was posting at a lower frequency than usual so I think some irl stuff could have come up. His off and on of aron gives me a slight scum read.
Cory
I pushed thought cory was scum, but going back to BoI mafia changed my mind so I'll leave him alone for now.

This is so bad lmao. I was on my phone so thats why there was a delay.

 

[piichinu]

for the next vote ill probably be voting alexi (if i live until then) if nothing changes/no new info is revealed.

 

[PandaDarling]

I'm going to vote for inkling mainly because her activity in the game has been really off. Her tone is also less aggresive and I can sebse that her posts seem pretty forced. At first I thought they were changing to not start up any arguements again, but right now I'm definitely getting a feeling thats she could possibly be scum. As for Alexi, I'm not too sure what to think of her yet but I don't feel right voting her after the turnover of events for hee and emotions are probably just getting to her. I'm more confident with an Inkling vote anyhow.
And to address the people, yes, I know my inactivity irritates you all so I'm probably going to only sign up for replacements from now on... Sorry for inconveniencing you all...

Note: my vote is not firm, depending on Inklings defense of course

@Mother im sorry but i just don't see the point, you sign up for these games and i understand you want to play, but its not helpful and hard for us to get a read on you, especially when theres a chance you could get a PR and really help us out sometimes you know what i mean ?

 

[Chrystina]

@ness, why are you focusing so much on sarasakat? she's been townread by every single one of us. she even townread YOU adn you still think she's scum?
idk.. like I said, getting weird vibes from ness - i think he's just trying to take the attention off of the fact some of us were sus that he just left.

 

[xine]

I would REALLY prefer to lynch inkling today, because while I see me0ws points I also believe that Alexi contributes a lot while inkling has done basically nothing. Alexi has contributed and given opinions, although wishy washy, at least they are somewhat valid.

 

[inkling]

I'm going to vote for inkling mainly because her activity in the game has been really off. Her tone is also less aggresive and I can sebse that her posts seem pretty forced. At first I thought they were changing to not start up any arguements again, but right now I'm definitely getting a feeling thats she could possibly be scum. As for Alexi, I'm not too sure what to think of her yet but I don't feel right voting her after the turnover of events for hee and emotions are probably just getting to her. I'm more confident with an Inkling vote anyhow.
And to address the people, yes, I know my inactivity irritates you all so I'm probably going to only sign up for replacements from now on... Sorry for inconveniencing you all...

Note: my vote is not firm, depending on Inklings defense of course

this is crazy. you're literally the most inactive member here.

also, im not sure what im suppose to defend myself against? i already responded to xine's reads. im not as impressed by them as others seem to be, though her posts are a breath of fresh air compared to most of what's been going on.

But like I said, whenever I've been on, everybody was inactive. I had a long day at work. ive beeen checking in in the evenings if you haven't noticed.

I still need to focus on who im going to vote for anyways so i can't defend myself much. But if you'd like, you can go back and read my original defense.

 

[PandaDarling]

Spoiler

Heyden
Heyden so far has gone with what a majority of people have said and posted a small chatter. However I think that this corresponds with there usual town play. He said that he'll be back so I'm waiting for his thoughts before I say anything definitive. A couple of his posts have thrown me off due to its lack of seriousness. I am bookmarking his push on Aron in day 1.
Call me Daniel
Daniels inactivity of day has thrown me off. One of his posts this one, makes me feel he may be scum. In another game, reindeer mafia, a game where he was mafia he posted reads on day 1 matches the desciption of what he will be posting later. Like heyden, I will be waiting for their next posts.
Alexi
I feel like alexi's playstyle has changed a little from the last games I have played with her. In this game she feels a bit more flip floppy, ridng on the backs of others. Meow, read of her was execllent, I especially agreed with the point that her opinion of ATE changed so easily, perhaps it changed when you realized you are scum and were going to use it (jk)? I am kind of in the fence of Alexi though, I have some questions for them before I label her as scum or town.
Sarasakat
Slight scum read. I think she's diverging from her town play, where she usually questions things. She has not been mafia in awhile here on tbt so I'm going to check mafiauniverse to see if the meta of her last scum game matches up. Like most on this lynch im not 100% sure as of now.
Toadsworthy
I noticed toadworthy was posting at a lower frequency than usual so I think some irl stuff could have come up. His off and on of aron gives me a slight scum read.
Cory
I pushed thought cory was scum, but going back to BoI mafia changed my mind so I'll leave him alone for now.

This is so bad lmao. I was on my phone so thats why there was a delay.

@Crys this is what we waited 13+ hours for? ...... well that was anticlimactic, but never the less thank you for contributing. so who are you most likely placing your vote on then ?

-also guys we have 2 hours left. please just vote for your main suspicions, i don't want mafia to come in close to deadline and to get us all to sheep and bandwagon on someone, it never ends well... (sorry cory)

 

[inkling]

I would REALLY prefer to lynch inkling today, because while I see me0ws points I also believe that Alexi contributes a lot while inkling has done basically nothing. Alexi has contributed and given opinions, although wishy washy, at least they are somewhat valid.

maybe im not trying to put a big red ex on my back the way aron did.