Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!
- Thread starter Dolby
- Start date
Aronthaer
Back from Hiatus (3/18/22)
Haha, wasn't me. I haven't talked about the trolls/alts at all, actually.
Glad to see you're back! I'm still reading up too, I just got back from church.
I actually appreciate Crys this game. Idk why inkling tried to put a last minute case on them, if anything that would make him town. Also, any case against someone using the trolls is just kinda low, imo.
@Daniel, I thought you'd know how I am day 1 by now lol. At least I'm not hopping on every bandwagon every chance I get, I'm just agreeing with some reads I've seen. & I had to defend myself considering this was the first time I've gotten votes on me, not defending myself would be stupid.
I want to post my reads but it's night and i'm scared cause scum is watching soo I'll wait for day 2.
@Daniel, I thought you'd know how I am day 1 by now lol. At least I'm not hopping on every bandwagon every chance I get, I'm just agreeing with some reads I've seen. & I had to defend myself considering this was the first time I've gotten votes on me, not defending myself would be stupid.
I want to post my reads but it's night and i'm scared cause scum is watching soo I'll wait for day 2.
as im working on my other cases, i just wanted to say that honey.dew's replacement is probably town since inkling, a confirmed maf member, tried to get them modkilled immediately in the beginning when they jokingly asked if it was ok to pm other players.
@Daniel
why didn't you post reads during D1? IIRC you posted none. I genuinely don't like your interaction with Cory. How you both seem to townread each other for really weird reasons. I'll try to explain by coloring what your actual words connotate. There seems to be a weird disconnection in what you're saying and the conclusion you're drawing.
"Not too sure what I think of cory so far. He had a pretty big ego in putting himself in the strongest scum hunter pedestal, when he really wasn’t doing much. That seemed to me like he was shoving it down our throats that he was trying to help, and he spent more time telling us that actually scum hunting. I didn’t like that. But then I reconsidered my suspicions when he got into a very heated fight with Aron that almost made them quit the game. While you could say that’s a scum trying to make a distraction or pressing a town player into spilling the beans, I see really no purpose in scum doing this. In all the time I’ve played here, all of the heated fights(ex. Tae and Inkling in Tarot, Trojan and Ness in Scummies, Jacob and I in BoI etc), it’s mainly just 2 town fighting. Not only is it stupid to press him as scum because there’s really nothing else to gain from it because he already claimed doc and it would make him pretty suspicious to doing so for no reason. I town read him from this, EDIT: Also now that i read his cautiousness on immediately clearing Xine, it’s not logical but understandable. While I highly doubt Xine would drive a teammate to lynching but I understand the fear of trusting someone too quickly. I usually don’t trust anyone too much, until deeper into the game, so I see where this response would come from a town. Town leaning on him for me. "
- - - Post Merge - - -
^^^ ugh oops i wasn't done with my post at all, just ignore and immma do an EBWOP
why didn't you post reads during D1? IIRC you posted none. I genuinely don't like your interaction with Cory. How you both seem to townread each other for really weird reasons. I'll try to explain by coloring what your actual words connotate. There seems to be a weird disconnection in what you're saying and the conclusion you're drawing.
"Not too sure what I think of cory so far. He had a pretty big ego in putting himself in the strongest scum hunter pedestal, when he really wasn’t doing much. That seemed to me like he was shoving it down our throats that he was trying to help, and he spent more time telling us that actually scum hunting. I didn’t like that. But then I reconsidered my suspicions when he got into a very heated fight with Aron that almost made them quit the game. While you could say that’s a scum trying to make a distraction or pressing a town player into spilling the beans, I see really no purpose in scum doing this. In all the time I’ve played here, all of the heated fights(ex. Tae and Inkling in Tarot, Trojan and Ness in Scummies, Jacob and I in BoI etc), it’s mainly just 2 town fighting. Not only is it stupid to press him as scum because there’s really nothing else to gain from it because he already claimed doc and it would make him pretty suspicious to doing so for no reason. I town read him from this, EDIT: Also now that i read his cautiousness on immediately clearing Xine, it’s not logical but understandable. While I highly doubt Xine would drive a teammate to lynching but I understand the fear of trusting someone too quickly. I usually don’t trust anyone too much, until deeper into the game, so I see where this response would come from a town. Town leaning on him for me. "
- - - Post Merge - - -
^^^ ugh oops i wasn't done with my post at all, just ignore and immma do an EBWOP
Why does it seem too quiet?
ignore previous post pls & ty
@Daniel
why didn't you post reads during D1? IIRC you posted none. I genuinely don't like your interaction with Cory. How you both seem to townread each other for really weird reasons. I'll try to explain by coloring what your actual words connotate. There seems to be a weird disconnection in what you're saying and the conclusion you're drawing.
Everything in your townread of him makes me uncomfortable. like it just doesn't sit well at all. you're saying he's town for fighting with Aron, something that scum did (inkling), you're saying he's town
you both are buddying each other in a really off way.
>ya I haven't contributed but what have u????
>the nub Tardis hasn't posted in depth reads why should I???? actually I think Tardis did post reads lmao, correct me if I'm wrong
>townreads Daniel for a counter
>townreads Toad for a post on Sarasa
>hesitant to townread Xine for lynching Inkling
I know you're a stronger player than this, Cory...
I thought Cory's reaction during the beginning of Night was extremely weird, like literally everything about what Cory said was weird.
That's the first thing out of your mouth when scum was lynched D1?
why do you care so much. it almost feels like he wanted Alexi lynched yesterday, I mean I did too, but I still did not vote for her because I wasn't very sure
there are a lot of people that didn't vote or voted for Alexi, not just you. why are you so worried about what people are thinking if it's something so little as voting?
this is so weird
yes, don't townlock Xine. but if you honestly believe that was a bus, with the interactions they had together, with how in depth the case she made on Inkling was, then you're reaching. and Xine had a point where she said it's weird how Cory townread Daniel for making a timeclock but doesn't seem like he trusts Xine very much.
contradicts what you said. You said you don't think inkling bussed anyone, WHEN INKLING CALLED CADBERRY SCUM. I'm thinking you just said it because you know your reads previously in the game weren't strong enough for you to go after Xine, if you went after Xine for lynching scum but and townread several others for weak reasoning then you'll definitely look awful. so instead you go for ez target, like Cadberry, who's new (pretty sure this is their first game) and literally doesn't even know the definition of bussing.
Daniel how do you actually townread this?
anyway now I'll respond to your read
I laid out his choices and told him the possibilities and what I would do personally. he's a nub, I didn't know
thx I'm trying to change my playstyle
yeah I wanted to make it clear as day that we weren't lynching Aron and also that anyone that kept pressing it was scum. And what do you know, that's how we found scum D1.
it's fine to question their claim. it's fine to not believe anything Aron says. my point is if you're trying to lynch a doc claim, that's scummy af. and oh look, that's what Inkling tried to do. I feel like I'm repeating myself sooooo much here and I'm pretty sure Xine and others have said the same thing. Aronthaer will die soon, and if he doesn't then we'll know.
Are you saying you want to lynch one of us to test that? How do you know that we aren't both town? even I was hesitant about Alexi, she responded with decently valid points, and it wasn't really worth losing her D1 to vote for her. so I didn't even vote for her. but my real question is: how come you think Cory V. Aron is town v. town but not Alexi v. me?? What makes you scumread us over scumreading Cory? I thought most intense arguments are town v. town, Daniel? If ANYTHING, Cory is scum over me and Alexi combined. So your reads on us (me, Alexi, Cory) make no sense. Do explain, I'd love to hear.
- - - Post Merge - - -
also I just woke up so ya I still managed to made mistakes in that post too but I'm too lazy to fix it so ur all just gonna have to deal with it :^)
@Daniel
why didn't you post reads during D1? IIRC you posted none. I genuinely don't like your interaction with Cory. How you both seem to townread each other for really weird reasons. I'll try to explain by coloring what your actual words connotate. There seems to be a weird disconnection in what you're saying and the conclusion you're drawing.
Everything in your townread of him makes me uncomfortable. like it just doesn't sit well at all. you're saying he's town for fighting with Aron, something that scum did (inkling), you're saying he's town
you both are buddying each other in a really off way.
>ya I haven't contributed but what have u????
>the nub Tardis hasn't posted in depth reads why should I???? actually I think Tardis did post reads lmao, correct me if I'm wrong
>townreads Daniel for a counter
>townreads Toad for a post on Sarasa
>hesitant to townread Xine for lynching Inkling
I know you're a stronger player than this, Cory...
I thought Cory's reaction during the beginning of Night was extremely weird, like literally everything about what Cory said was weird.
That's the first thing out of your mouth when scum was lynched D1?
why do you care so much. it almost feels like he wanted Alexi lynched yesterday, I mean I did too, but I still did not vote for her because I wasn't very sure
there are a lot of people that didn't vote or voted for Alexi, not just you. why are you so worried about what people are thinking if it's something so little as voting?
this is so weird
yes, don't townlock Xine. but if you honestly believe that was a bus, with the interactions they had together, with how in depth the case she made on Inkling was, then you're reaching. and Xine had a point where she said it's weird how Cory townread Daniel for making a timeclock but doesn't seem like he trusts Xine very much.
contradicts what you said. You said you don't think inkling bussed anyone, WHEN INKLING CALLED CADBERRY SCUM. I'm thinking you just said it because you know your reads previously in the game weren't strong enough for you to go after Xine, if you went after Xine for lynching scum but and townread several others for weak reasoning then you'll definitely look awful. so instead you go for ez target, like Cadberry, who's new (pretty sure this is their first game) and literally doesn't even know the definition of bussing.
Daniel how do you actually townread this?
anyway now I'll respond to your read
I laid out his choices and told him the possibilities and what I would do personally. he's a nub, I didn't know
thx I'm trying to change my playstyle
yeah I wanted to make it clear as day that we weren't lynching Aron and also that anyone that kept pressing it was scum. And what do you know, that's how we found scum D1.
it's fine to question their claim. it's fine to not believe anything Aron says. my point is if you're trying to lynch a doc claim, that's scummy af. and oh look, that's what Inkling tried to do. I feel like I'm repeating myself sooooo much here and I'm pretty sure Xine and others have said the same thing. Aronthaer will die soon, and if he doesn't then we'll know.
Are you saying you want to lynch one of us to test that? How do you know that we aren't both town? even I was hesitant about Alexi, she responded with decently valid points, and it wasn't really worth losing her D1 to vote for her. so I didn't even vote for her. but my real question is: how come you think Cory V. Aron is town v. town but not Alexi v. me?? What makes you scumread us over scumreading Cory? I thought most intense arguments are town v. town, Daniel? If ANYTHING, Cory is scum over me and Alexi combined. So your reads on us (me, Alexi, Cory) make no sense. Do explain, I'd love to hear.
- - - Post Merge - - -
also I just woke up so ya I still managed to made mistakes in that post too but I'm too lazy to fix it so ur all just gonna have to deal with it :^)
Yea, I looked back and saw it was Tardis.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Yo Daniel, what was with the wishy washy read of inkling?
Also, what was this:
I'm better now so I'll reply in a sec but I like meow's analysis on this. I don't like Daniel, I don't like Cory, and I think both of them are scum.
Also, what was this:
Why the hell would you ask that? I call blue hunting.Daniel's read of Tardis said:
I'm better now so I'll reply in a sec but I like meow's analysis on this. I don't like Daniel, I don't like Cory, and I think both of them are scum.
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
You and Alexi got in a civil debate about her behavior, I didn't say I wang to lynch you guys as a test, I'm saying if one of you were to flip town or scum/town it would probably say what the other is. Cory and Aron on the other hand, got into a pointless fight in how Aron was dumb for claiming. Heated fights from what I've seen, are usually done by town vs town. There's no real point in beating a player who already claimed as scum. This kinda ego dumb play from Cory fits in from previous games I've been him do here and offsite. So I'm essentially meta TRing him. Cory is usually more reserved as scum, but as town he usually blurts whatever.
I didn't post my reads because on the first day, there was a lot of inactivity from certain players and I wanted to give them time to post before I made my reads. Because when I do my reads, I like doing detailed ones on each player. The 2nd day of D1 I was gone the whole day and only checked in on my phone(my friends needed help so I was with her until very late). I got home like 2 hours before the deadline and while I was typing my scum reads at least so I could make the deadline and post my other reads later, inklings majority was reached. So I decided that I might as well have just made all the reads together. Sorry for that inactivity, it was just bad IRL timing.
- - - Post Merge - - -
The read on Inkling was pretty hasty since I wasn't home. I didn't want to vote for him immediately, but I from what I quickly read, i wasn't against it. So I was just okay with it, not for or against it. I probably would have voted for him, but the majority was reached early and I was still typing my reads.
I wanted to know if he was actually claiming or just asking a question. It seemed like he was just soft claiming blue by asking that out of nowhere. Did no one else pay attention to that?
I didn't post my reads because on the first day, there was a lot of inactivity from certain players and I wanted to give them time to post before I made my reads. Because when I do my reads, I like doing detailed ones on each player. The 2nd day of D1 I was gone the whole day and only checked in on my phone(my friends needed help so I was with her until very late). I got home like 2 hours before the deadline and while I was typing my scum reads at least so I could make the deadline and post my other reads later, inklings majority was reached. So I decided that I might as well have just made all the reads together. Sorry for that inactivity, it was just bad IRL timing.
- - - Post Merge - - -
The read on Inkling was pretty hasty since I wasn't home. I didn't want to vote for him immediately, but I from what I quickly read, i wasn't against it. So I was just okay with it, not for or against it. I probably would have voted for him, but the majority was reached early and I was still typing my reads.
I wanted to know if he was actually claiming or just asking a question. It seemed like he was just soft claiming blue by asking that out of nowhere. Did no one else pay attention to that?
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
That was just a stupid move on my part then sorry. What would be the point of me asking that question if I was scum?
scum would want to know if it were a claim or not to get rid of the possible blue.
Pretty sure we all did but nobody brought it to attention cause that is PR hunting...
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh sorry. didnt refresh page and see comments before
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
How long till night ends ? i was gonna make a post close to deadline as to not help influence mafia actions but also in time to help town, incase i die N1 again (thanks Ness).
-but now my sister wants me to go to the festival/ carnival we have in town today and i don't know if im gonna be able to find time.
-but now my sister wants me to go to the festival/ carnival we have in town today and i don't know if im gonna be able to find time.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
I'll answer the stuff I didn't answer before.
The statement could be fabricated, but I don't think Ness would be the kind to fabricate derp clears. Therefore, I'm willing to trust him on it. Fight me.
Everything else I responded to
I didn't clear Cory for it. I said I thought it was a townie thing for him to do. But literally anything can be perceived as scummy or townie. Literally anything. We have to go with what the best probability is.Daniel said:
No, I was explaining what meta was. If you're talking about me agreeing with his meta analysis, then ok? I'm sorry I'm slightly aware of my meta?Daniel said:
Lying about what? But have you read the guy's tone? It was pure as hell.Daniel said:
My read was pretty obviously changing at that point. You failed to mention a page later (on 50 posts per page), I wrote my new read on Cory, which was neutral/slight scum. And that question in of itself wasn't implying I heavily scumread him. I was pointing out his hypocrisy. And at that point in the game, at least I was actively engaged in the chat and trying to make heads and tails of Aron's claim. Cory had done literally jack ****.Daniel said:
It was meant to be motivational. People were like "ehh we don't know who to lynch".Daniel said:
Did you read the read itself? I was saying Kevinn wasn't contributing in the posts he did make.Daniel said:
Let's be honest - any mafian would go to their scumchat before going to thread to see if they needed to catch up on any plans scum had been hatching. The would have heard the Doc claim there.Daniel said:
The statement could be fabricated, but I don't think Ness would be the kind to fabricate derp clears. Therefore, I'm willing to trust him on it. Fight me.
Everything else I responded to
