Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

If aron knew they attacked you and got saved there is no way he would've claimed that he protected you. Because he would've known a real doctor would've stepped up and completely falsified him, ruining all his argument.... so he had to think of someone else
So are we calling aron a fake doctor and the mafia or just another cover role
 
The doctor gets a notification that their target was saved I think

It wasn't like that in Game of Thrones though. I was Doctor and saved endless N1, yet i didn't get squat.

If a Doctor saved someone, would both the saved and doctor get a PM about it, or just the saved person?
 
It wasn't like that in Game of Thrones though. I was Doctor and saved endless N1, yet i didn't get squat.

If a Doctor saved someone, would both the saved and doctor get a PM about it, or just the saved person?
Is this Game of Thrones? I think not, plus Sarasa seemed pretty confident with her claim so
 
yeah but I put Xine heavily on Town because of the whole inkling thing.... this is not helping your case whatsoever

Yeah, that's my main problem with this. I'm highly sus of Sarasa personally, but Xine I place as a heavy town, making this messy and confusing. Is it possible that Xine bussed Inkling?
 
This is insane. either we have two doctors or Xine and Sarasa are both scum and are playing us.

I kinda like the sound of the latter tbh. I've had my eye on Sarasa for a while now, I'll need to do an in-depth examination later. right now I'm going to bed.
Ok, given Im Doctor, what are your thoughts on my actions? Why are you so sure that you are the only Doc in this game?

And you seriously think Xine would go to those lengths to bus her own mafian?
 
Yeah, that's my main problem with this. I'm highly sus of Sarasa personally, but Xine I place as a heavy town, making this messy and confusing. Is it possible that Xine bussed Inkling?

seeing as how she was suspicious (and I'm pretty sure voted) of him with Shiida before he even came back right before the end of day 1, absolutely not... at the point she was talking about him he wasn't even that relevant, so I highly doubt if she was mafia that she would call out her scum partner like that
 
Oh I'm alive, hello. Yes I can confirm was saved.

I do not know what to believe at the moment. If Aronthaer was mafia it would make sense that he couldn't say he saved me, considering I would not get a notification if he simply opted for his team not to kill me. But since I was hit, then he would know that since I was alive, a real doc saved me. Therefor he could say that he saved me, and confirm himself. But I do not like his playing dumb about me being a likely target. He is basically saying he had no idea why inkling was being lynched. I said that I will probably die toward the beginning of night for obvious reasons. Hoping that he would take the hint. I know my name was mentioned multiple times. There is no way he is saying he didn't read any of that while he claimed to have deliberated over his decision.

I'm going to need awhile to make sense of these kills and everything.

I am beginning to believe Aronthaer is lying, I will need to look at him in depth. But the part that doesn't add up is that since he would know his team hit me and that I was still alive, therefor he could have claimed that he saved me and confirmed himself as Doctor. So...

The only other explanation was that he could have thought I had multiple night lives, but I find this unlikely.

Give me time to process this.
I know when I took it into consideration, I thought it might have warded mafia off of you, so I almost healed myself instead of you. Glad I didn't, though.

And what do you think about his tone in the initial claim and the following remorse? That's my main reason for town reading him
 
Ok, given Im Doctor, what are your thoughts on my actions? Why are you so sure that you are the only Doc in this game?

And you seriously think Xine would go to those lengths to bus her own mafian?

...No, I don't. I thought about it and although your actions have been pretty fishy I now realize it was probably because I claimed doctor and originally it was thought two doctors wasn't possible. On top of that Xine has contributed so much more than just the Inkling read so I'm gonna townread you.

Quick question tho: Why on earth did you claim. now the maf knows both doctors xD
 
Everything Heyden has said this entire start since day has just SCREAMED scum to me.

Heyden said:
I feel comfortable with a Sarasa or Crys lynch today.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Alexi I think he's just confused Noob Doctor.
Not even just Heyden, but so many people have been so quick to vote already. Maybe I just don't understand the mind set of the plurality lynch system, but man I have no idea why people are jumping to voting so fast.

Heyden said:
We can't really confirm he's lying until there is actually a real Doctor who outs, but we don't want that to happen.
Heyden said:
That is possible, but it would mean there's still a town doctor but we can't really get them to out...
Why would they? If it really isn't Aron and Aron is lying, why would they be so quick to go "Hey guise, yeah dat was me." GDI Kat you took away one of my points if your claim is real (I'm on sure of it's truth though).

Heyden said:
I don't see how I seem scum? I've been acting how I usually act as town..
Never played with him, no meta to go on so no comment.

Heyden said:
Why do you keep saying blocked?????
Probably because of being a newbie. Like he later said on, if it had been such a massive deal he wouldn't have worded it like that. Going back to what people said about tone in D1, this tone really strikes me the wrong way.

Heyden said:
Okay so Cory and Shiida were obviously the Mafia kills and Daniel was targeted by SK most likely.
How would you know this? Gut instinct can only go so far. (As an aside, could someone explain to me how KP works in forum mafia, I don't think I totally understand it?)

Heyden said:
Why did Xine live lol
Like I said when you originally posted this, why should it matter? Xine basically single handedly got us a lynch yesterday. It's funny that you are so sure in your previous post on who killed who, but then are so surprised Xine lived. It's pretty suspicious for you to say your previous post but then be so surprised that Xine is still alive.

Heyden said:
Shiida said to go after Sarasa and Crys, Daniels reads had Sarasa and Crys as scum, potential bussing? Cory was really mixed idk I'll look through him later.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Assuming there's 5 scum, if someone has a mafia report or something would it be good to out it? Considering that will lower the KP to 1..? I don't know
Iif people believe the Xine bussing theory (one I also don't buy, and almost no one else does it seems), why the **** would Daniel bus two more members of his team? If your theory of 5 scum is true, that would put all 3 still alive people on possible radar for scum. Two of them dead and two of them outed by their dying teammate. Plus if you buy into Xine bussing his team (again, I do not) why the hell would the 5 mafia all out their whole team? No, I think Daniel was trying to throw us off track. I'd find it EXTREMELY hard to believe if the 5 mafia, 2 being dead, had all been either killed or bussed at some point.

Heyden said:
http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?363810-Make-Mafia-Grate-Again!-Day-Two&p=6443038&highlight=#post6443038
Idk how to quote this as text, but yeah, this is him saying townie cnfirmed. I just don't even know how to respond, so I'll say "lol."

Heyden said:
i take pics
Nice job dodging the question. If you were town, why wouldn't you just say, "No I'm town."?

I'd just like to point out that I've thought Heyden was scum since my reads in Day 1, which you can see here:

ClamEatsCurry said:
Heyden - Really rubs me the wrong with way with his exit, their last few posts before he left were making sure no lynch would never be an option (to be fair it's a bad idea), but he made sure to leave making sure we didn't lynch him when no one was really sus of him or throwing his name out there. His past few posts really throw me on a sus trail. Not to mention for the first part of the game he put himself on invisible so we couldn't see that he was viewing the thread (see http://www.belltreeforums.com/showth...=1#post6434321 ). This post doesn't necessarily say scum, but going invisible is sus to me. Could be town, but I'm very wary of them.

Not even to mention any time he's been asked a question since day start (or even some beforehand as shown above), he's avoided every single one.


Not just Heyden though, I'm also super sus of Kat. Kat has claimed so many different roles since day start I don't even know...like I wanna say she's town and that I believe her but I just can't trust it seeing as how she was like "I can't explain right now cause reasons." Not only that but she claimed other roles too and then goes "Oh yeah I'm actually Doc." (Kat why do you wound me like this? ;_; ) Once I hear what Xine has to say, I'll either make a bigger case or lead more towards townie.


Does a Vig HAVE to shoot day 1?
 
...No, I don't. I thought about it and although your actions have been pretty fishy I now realize it was probably because I claimed doctor and originally it was thought two doctors wasn't possible. On top of that Xine has contributed so much more than just the Inkling read so I'm gonna townread you.

Quick question tho: Why on earth did you claim. now the maf knows both doctors xD
jw but are you ye goodfather?
 
It wasn't like that in Game of Thrones though. I was Doctor and saved endless N1, yet i didn't get squat.

If a Doctor saved someone, would both the saved and doctor get a PM about it, or just the saved person?

Both would be notified
 
...No, I don't. I thought about it and although your actions have been pretty fishy I now realize it was probably because I claimed doctor and originally it was thought two doctors wasn't possible. On top of that Xine has contributed so much more than just the Inkling read so I'm gonna townread you.

Quick question tho: Why on earth did you claim. now the maf knows both doctors xD
Yup!

And it was because Ness, Toads, everyone was kinda like "lol ok Sarasa's a PR" so I figured there wasn't much harm left in claiming.
 
I know when I took it into consideration, I thought it might have warded mafia off of you, so I almost healed myself instead of you. Glad I didn't, though.

And what do you think about his tone in the initial claim and the following remorse? That's my main reason for town reading him

The more Aron keeps talking the closer I get to that voting thread... so were you just saying you thought he was Town, to keep him off your back if he was a mafia and keep yourself alive? that way you could do something over night and try to prove him wrong?

do you actually think he is a scum?
I believe the probability of him being scum right now over the probability of there begin two doctors
 
But I do not like his playing dumb about me being a likely target. He is basically saying he had no idea why inkling was being lynched.

Yo, I missed quite a bit and I don't have time to read everything before D1 ends. could someone explain why they're suspicious of Inkling? My current vote is Alexi but if someone could give or link to me some good reasons why Inkling is scum I'll unvote.

Just realized he hit majority already. RIP

Voila.
 
Back
Top