Take all the time you need man, I hope everything happens ok, you come first
Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!
- Thread starter Dolby
- Start date
Take all the time you need man, I hope everything happens ok, you come first
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
hope everything is ok.
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
oh dang, I actually am not sus of you since Inkling called you and Cory out in the same post for making posts that were "similar to him"
- - - Post Merge - - -
i think your town if it makes you feel better.
My problem is that I don't know how many scum are in play because I am not familiar with the norms here. I would say in a game with ~20 players, there is four at least meaning 2 KP, but other factors seem to be pointing at the possibility of a higher KP. That is something I need sorted out, at least roughly, in order to draw better conclusions.
Based on the deaths of Shiida, Cory, and me being hit, this is the conclusion I'm drawing. Feel free to offer alternative options.
Mafia has KP of 3 & Daniel was hit by a Serial Killer or a Vigilante. This would mean that there were initially 5-6 scum.
I am not sure how I am liking the sound of two doctors, a watcher, obviously there is a cop, along with likely a vigilante, and I would assume that there is probably another power role as well (Bulletproof or something along those lines). Which means 5-6 Power Roles, 5-6 mafia, 1 SK(???) and the rest townies. This would mean that half of nearly everyone in the game are either scum or blue. Does this sound normal?
Now that two mafia are dead, we likely only have three left but maybe four? Four sounds like too much. I am going with 3, but would like other opinions on this. I am ruling out the idea of a third party group that has KP - please let me know if that is a reasonable assumption.
Based on the deaths of Shiida, Cory, and me being hit, this is the conclusion I'm drawing. Feel free to offer alternative options.
Mafia has KP of 3 & Daniel was hit by a Serial Killer or a Vigilante. This would mean that there were initially 5-6 scum.
I am not sure how I am liking the sound of two doctors, a watcher, obviously there is a cop, along with likely a vigilante, and I would assume that there is probably another power role as well (Bulletproof or something along those lines). Which means 5-6 Power Roles, 5-6 mafia, 1 SK(???) and the rest townies. This would mean that half of nearly everyone in the game are either scum or blue. Does this sound normal?
Now that two mafia are dead, we likely only have three left but maybe four? Four sounds like too much. I am going with 3, but would like other opinions on this. I am ruling out the idea of a third party group that has KP - please let me know if that is a reasonable assumption.
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
@Xine someone said early 4-6 total Mafia most likely and 1 SK ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
From my experiences here yes it sounds normal.
- - - Post Merge - - -
From my experiences here yes it sounds normal.
The KP is most likely 2 at the moment. Most likely 3 members, 4 would seem a little bit scumsided.
As for PR's, I'm pretty sure Dolby likes to incorporate a few more PR's than there usually are, so possibly up to 8 maybe. I don't believe in 2 doctors, I think I know what's actually happening but I'm keeping my mouth shut for the sake of keeping them safe.
And 3rd parties, I'm thinking 1 hostile (e.g Mad Hatter, SK) and a non-hostile (Lover, Lyncher)
Xine, Cory and Shiida are possible victims of Serial Killer/Mafia/Vigilante
Daniel was the victim of Vigilante or Serial Killer
If a vigilante did shoot Daniel, wouldn't it be good for them to out since they're basically just a vanilla townie now anyways?
...Can we please lesser the filler posts? Please? Everytime I refresh, a new page pops up and it's very time consuming to read through. It'll only make people who are inactive even more inactive because it's kind of discouraging to see all these new posts to read x_x
I've been only looking at inkling and Daniel's posts so far, and in particular I will base my reads on this:
I thought it's likely that inkling wouldn't include the name of her scummates on this list, and it's proven by how Daniel flipped scum, so I'll start from there. It's currently 1 PM where I am so I'll have more time to read through the thread later at night.
Also, it's VERY unlikely we have 2 doctors. Last time town believe we have two doctors, one of them turned out to be SK
I've been only looking at inkling and Daniel's posts so far, and in particular I will base my reads on this:
I thought it's likely that inkling wouldn't include the name of her scummates on this list, and it's proven by how Daniel flipped scum, so I'll start from there. It's currently 1 PM where I am so I'll have more time to read through the thread later at night.
Also, it's VERY unlikely we have 2 doctors. Last time town believe we have two doctors, one of them turned out to be SK
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
OMG so many post merge sorry... I would def count on a third party kP we usually have a serial killer somewhere in the mix in these games.
thats assuming vig is one shot lmao
mother of all llamas
llamas <3
Don't trigger me AyayaAlso, it's VERY unlikely we have 2 doctors. Last time town believe we have two doctors, one of them turned out to be SK
I'll post some thoughts up tomorow, had a hectic day only to come back to see another doctor claimed...Well they usually are, the only game I've played with a 2-shot vig was Reindeer mafia, but then again, they were killed last night and shot the Unlynchable
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
a full vigilante and two doctors would seem too town sided to me
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
Don't trigger me Ayaya
no one was even talking to you, this is a very ominous post. perhaps you should elaborate?
- - - Post Merge - - -
you aren't worthy
- - - Post Merge - - -
toads worthy
mother of all llamas
llamas <3
I was a replacement in Reindeer mafia, I came in halfway through the game (was my first game too haha) and I was given Doctor. Ayaya was also doctor and I tried to get her lynched but all of town thought there were two doctors and she ended up winning as Serial Killer in her first game haha. I really enjoyed my first game though..
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
@Xine, i think we shouldn't lynch Aron, theres a reason why both Sarasakat and Aron are correct, but i don't think its my place to explain it. Thats why they are both at the top of my color chart right underneath you.
I agree with Panda, I feel like only of Aronthaer/Sarasa is Doctor, and the other is something else..
- - - Post Merge - - -
only one of*
