Damniel for reasons stated above, Kallie because I have reason to think she knows the game started but hasn't started playing. It'll come off as a bit angleshooty (out of game info) if I explain, which is why I'd lynch Damniel first to see if she eventually comes around.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also Ness, you're starting to come off as information-over-analysis. Could you give me a tier of your suspects and why?
Mine is
Myself
Dedenne - her end of the conversation between her and Ness seemed pure and genuinely uncertain/out of the know and all of her posts since have not been inconsistent in that regard. Doesn't seem partnered with Damniel.
Unravel- Waffles as scum wouldn't want to dismiss distracting moments like people wanting to look at my interaction with Antonio and her saying and she's not jumping to any conclusions or pushing anyone where there's opportunity to. I want to see more solving but so far this is just one of those 'she doesn't play this way as scum' reads. Also gut and tone tbh.
Ness- A bit information-over-analysis, like I've said, but is helping push the game in the right direction by getting that information on the table. Need to see what he begins to conclude to actually see whether or not I'm willing to trust him.
Heyden - Some agreeable reads, some disagreeable. Their post just before I unvoted them explaining why they thought what they did about Toads seems like a towny post because pure townies just explain what made them come to x conclusion while wolves are more defensive. This isn't a hard townread though because that's not enough but yeah.
Antonio - Didn't come in doing anything other than saying he might be out of power soon, and I'd like for him have to, so he's kind of my nullread.
Toads - It's entirely possible he's frozen and doesn't know how to -truly- enter the thread and it's one of those reads that I'll know more about depending on what Damniel is. If Damniel is a wolf Toads seems spewed town but if Damniel is town, not so much and he might have been right.
Kallie - Reasons stated above. Should be here by now because of that out of game information I have (****ty I know) but I just don't like it. I might change this read -if- she really comes in swinging in a way that doesn't seem like that recent mafia game she played here. I think it was the last game here in general.
Damniel- Also stated above:
Damniel it's a pretty slow game. The effort you need to be giving when you're trying to solve a game is analysis rather than just asking questions or seeing how people react. You have to determine whether they're town or mafia from that and this isn't what I'm seeing you doing outside of your moment with Toads. And now you're saying you want to get replaced. And you entered just shading people and now upon return seem nervous and deflective.
I'm really wanting to just vote you and consider this a RWSTFO moment. (rand wolf, sub the f out) But a little part of me wants to have faith in you as a player.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Basically my working day 1 POE is Antonio, Toads, kallie, and Damniel in order of least to most suspicious.
