Mafia Mountainous Mafia: Camp Mafia - Mafia Wins!

[BetsySundrop]

reminds me of when ness said “the town” instead of town and got eliminated for it and was mafia lmao

That's attention to detail right there.

 

[Antonio]

yeah, like i said before, killing geoni is really weird when you end up confirming both wagons are town. i think mafia would hoping geoni would be eliminated cuz i doubt they’d kill blooming and blooming would probably behave the same today if they were busy with another game

Yes, this is also a valid point. I also find it weird they would kill Geoni rather than keep him in as a potential 2nd-day wagon. It seems the most logical conclusion was that they really wanted to get rid of Geoni.

Now I feel like we should discuss the possibility if Cat/Koopa is town. I obviously believe they are sus but I could also be wrong. The reason why I wanted to discuss this because if one of them flip town, then maybe Geoni death wasn't motivated by inexperienced players but instead motivated by something that Geoni said? I may have to look in Geoni next day if this in the case but I feel good about my current theory due to there not being any flaws at the moment.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

reminds me of when ness said “the town” instead of town and got eliminated for it and was mafia lmao

Wait, wasn't that me that pointed that out.

 

[Biancasbotique]

I guess I would have to vote for Koopa
[QUOTE="Antonio, post: 10099676, member: 103521"

Now I feel like we should discuss the possibility if Cat/Koopa is town. I obviously believe they are sus but I could also be wrong. The reason why I wanted to discuss this because if one of them flip town, then maybe Geoni death wasn't motivated by inexperienced players but instead motivated by something that Geoni said? I may have to look in Geoni next day if this in the case but I feel good about my current theory due to there not being any flaws at the moment.

[/QUOTE]

The only one really sussed by Geoni is blooming and he is town as well (If I am not mistaken) so when blooming got yeeted. No one really has motivation to kill off Geoni

 

[Damniel]

i think the geoni kill just came down to fear tbh

 

[Antonio]

The only one really sussed by Geoni is blooming and he is town as well (If I am not mistaken) so when blooming got yeeted. No one really has the motivation to kill off Geoni

Hmm, I should look into this tomorrow just in case but at least we can conclude that there was a motive to get rid of Geoni

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

i think the geoni kill just came down to fear tbh

I agree but it's important to be open to other possibilities.

 

[Biancasbotique]

I just voted for Koopa for the following reasons:

1) Given the choice of Catharina vs Koopa, I am inclined to townlean Catharina a bit more. Sure they have the same kind of play, but when Catharina made the slip up, i think it was unconscious. With Koopa, he has been making lots inconclusions even with the voting now. He voted Catharina to the explanation that Catharina voted for him when Catharina didnt even vote yet.

2) Going by Antonio's theory of fearkilling Geoni which makes sense to me, it could be two inexperienced players and going by possible Catharina/Koopa/Betsy/droqen/Bianca lineup, I am inclined to vote for Koopa more

 

[BetsySundrop]

I may regret this, but based on all the explanations and discussion today, I'm unvoting damniel. If I'm wrong, well, you got me. My legacy is, if I die tonight, look into damniel.

Based on a couple things, I'm voting catharina. First, based on posts, both are sus, but uhmmm.. I dont want to hurt any feelings, but I think its possible one was possibly implicated by the other at one point and isnt really good at defending. Also, one was on my top sus for a longer time.
Second, I don't think they are team, as they voted each other, but one is likely. I like Antonio's theory, though, but can't explain that. If I vote the wrong one and dont die, I'll vote the other next time. Otherwise, there may be a tie, in which case, one of them has got to be in there.

 

[Antonio]

I'll be sticking with my reads and keeping my vote on Koopadude.

 

[Damniel]

I may regret this, but based on all the explanations and discussion today, I'm unvoting damniel. If I'm wrong, well, you got me. My legacy is, if I die tonight, look into damniel.

Based on a couple things, I'm voting catharina. First, based on posts, both are sus, but uhmmm.. I dont want to hurt any feelings, but I think its possible one was possibly implicated by the other at one point and isnt really good at defending. Also, one was on my top sus for a longer time.
Second, I don't think they are team, as they voted each other, but one is likely. I like Antonio's theory, though, but can't explain that. If I vote the wrong one and dont die, I'll vote the other next time. Otherwise, there may be a tie, in which case, one of them has got to be in there.

are you referring to koopa and catharina?

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

did droqen say they weren’t gonna be around today

 

[BetsySundrop]

are you referring to koopa and catharina?

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

did droqen say they weren’t gonna be around today

are you referring to koopa and catharina?

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

did droqen say they weren’t gonna be around today

I dont know about droqen. For the other, yes. I was referring to koopa/cath. I don't think they are a team, but individually, yes.

 

[droqen]

I'm around for the last 25 minutes (i.e. now!)

Catching up. I see some votes have shuffled.

 

[BetsySundrop]

I just voted for Koopa for the following reasons:

1) Given the choice of Catharina vs Koopa, I am inclined to townlean Catharina a bit more. Sure they have the same kind of play, but when Catharina made the slip up, i think it was unconscious. With Koopa, he has been making lots inconclusions even with the voting now. He voted Catharina to the explanation that Catharina voted for him when Catharina didnt even vote yet.

2) Going by Antonio's theory of fearkilling Geoni which makes sense to me, it could be two inexperienced players and going by possible Catharina/Koopa/Betsy/droqen/Bianca lineup, I am inclined to vote for Koopa more

I hadn't noticed the vote discrepancy.

 

[droqen]

Everyone's cast their votes and they're looking like this at the moment:

Damniel (2) (droqen, Cath)
Koopadude (3) (Antonio, Damniel, Bianca)
Catharina (2) (Koopadude100, Betsy)

I'm sticking with Damniel, maybe out of confidence, or maybe out of stubbornness -- I have to know!
More thoughts to follow

 

[Damniel]

Everyone's cast their votes and they're looking like this at the moment:

Damniel (2) (droqen, Cath)
Koopadude (3) (Antonio, Damniel, Bianca)
Catharina (2) (Koopadude100, Betsy)

I'm sticking with Damniel, maybe out of confidence, or maybe out of stubbornness -- I have to know!
More thoughts to follow

if you think i’m more valuable dead than alive then idk what to tell you

 

[droqen]

@Damniel I think whether you're town or mafia you're motivated to make people think you're more valuable alive than dead Of course I'd like to have you around, if you're on my side. I've been reading you as mildly 'resigned-to-his-fate mafia Damniel' over 'righteous fury misjudged towny Damniel' based on some of your posts on page 18-19, but I'm still catching up.

 

[BetsySundrop]

Everyone's cast their votes and they're looking like this at the moment:

Damniel (2) (droqen, Cath)
Koopadude (3) (Antonio, Damniel, Bianca)
Catharina (2) (Koopadude100, Betsy)

I'm sticking with Damniel, maybe out of confidence, or maybe out of stubbornness -- I have to know!
More thoughts to follow

Am curious. Damniel had me convinced enough to change my vote, is there something in particular that you still suspect?

 

[droqen]

Am curious. Damniel had me convinced enough to change my vote, is there something in particular that you still suspect?

Can you catch me up (quickly, lol) on what in particular changed your vote? I'm still reading the last few pages and haven't found it.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

playing mafia is like eating spicy food, you enjoy the pain

truer words have never been spoken

 

[Damniel]

@Damniel I think whether you're town or mafia you're motivated to make people think you're more valuable alive than dead Of course I'd like to have you around, if you're on my side. I've been reading you as mildly 'resigned-to-his-fate mafia Damniel' over 'righteous fury misjudged towny Damniel' based on some of your posts on page 18-19, but I'm still catching up.

oh id be kicking and screaming if i was a wolf going down lol

 

[BetsySundrop]

Can you catch me up (quickly, lol) on what in particular changed your vote? I'm still reading the last few pages and haven't found it.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

truer words have never been spoken

Well, I guess I feel like he sort of explained it? Aannnd... now I feel stupid and am doubting myself....

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

oh id be kicking and screaming if i was a wolf going down lol

But you had my vote switched. ..

 

[Antonio]

I'll be changing my vote from Koopa to Catharina. I feel like Koopa could be more fake town then Catharina and I don't want to risk that rn.