Mafia Mountainous Mafia: Camp Mafia - Mafia Wins!

[BetsySundrop]

This is hard! I honestly do not know who to vote. Both mafias could be laying low now..or they could be active in the threads.
Just for the curiousity, lets say that I am revealed town. Would any of your reasoning change ?

I already have you in town (ish 55/45) so mine would not change. I'd still be wondering about catharina, damniel, koopa. Antonio I took of my wolf list.

 

[Biancasbotique]

d

I don't know though, just because someone says they think you're town, doesn't mean they don't have an agenda. I thought earlier that it was to break up towncore after he was voted on. But now he's explaining and it so far is making sense. Am I being led by the nose...I hope not

I think it will be so highly suspicious of Danny to vote you off this cycle. He has been making you towncore all this time even stating that your post made him rethink about some of the postings about me so he has no reason to vote you at all this cycle.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

I already have you in town (ish 55/45) so mine would not change. I'd still be wondering about catharina, damniel, koopa. Antonio I took of my wolf list.

Why did you take him off your wolf list? Because his reading is almost similar to yours? Just curious.

I had the same with droqen and yes I am inclined to take him off wolf list. But I am not gonna take him off possible sus.

 

[BetsySundrop]

Like I said, Catharina did a slip up which is messy as I dont think a mafia team would do. She answered Daniel's post directed to me. so made her town lean a bit. But I remember doing a Bianca where I pretended to just be lost at some points but then again, If i go by the psyche of a mafia, they would ignore Daniel's post about me all together and not even respond to it. One of them knows its for me.

As for Koopa, same thing with Catharina acting like he doesn't read the thread, especially mine. He has been consistenly been at me for days now even suggesting I am gonna be modkilled so he careless. My argument for Catharina goes the same with Koopa

You know there is a quote. Never attribute to malice that which can be explained by incompetence. But here it seems you never know if it's real or pretend.

 

[Antonio]

There are two mafia members in this game, due to the 1 mafia per 7 players rule (with the remainder counting as an extra). Right? Then wouldn't it make sense that both of them are inexperienced due to them voting off Geoni day 1? Usually, if there is more than one mafia member, they have to come together and decide on who to kill during night 1. Therefore, we can conclude that killing off Geoni was a collective idea between the mafia members. Therefore, can't we conclude that both of the mafia members are inexperienced.

I stated before that I believe Geoni death was motivated by inexperienced players, but I don't see how both of them can come to that conclusion unless they are both inexperienced. I do believe that a Koopa/Cat team is possible but I'm not sure how experienced Cat is as mafia.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

I also wish to state that I believe that someone inexperienced is in the Mafia team, the vote for Geoni is obviously motivated because they have deemed them a threat. I feel like more experienced players wouldn't pull such a move early on and would rather vote for somebody who would warrant less to work with you.

Here's my quote regarding my reason why I think Geoni vote was inexperienced motivated.

 

[BetsySundrop]

Why did you take him off your wolf list? Because his reading is almost similar to yours? Just curious.

I had the same with droqen and yes I am inclined to take him off wolf list. But I am not gonna take him off possible sus.

I put it in an earlier post somewhere. It's embarrassing. I was thinking both antonio/koopa entered the game in a similar way, and both going for geoni. Then antonio was pressuring koopa based on his geoni vote, while antonio was being pressured on his no vote. Add in geonis curse.

Then, i noticed antonio was basically parroting questions that had already been asked. I thought that was definitely sus and found plenty of direct examples, which I posted. Once he asked a question that had been answered in the post right before it. So I hammered him. Then he explained that he has a memory disability and did not remember things.... Well, that was embarrassing. Also, he started doing more detailed postings and reads.

 

[Biancasbotique]

There are two mafia members in this game, due to the 1 mafia per 7 players rule (with the remainder counting as an extra). Right? Then wouldn't it make sense that both of them are inexperienced due to them voting off Geoni day 1? Usually, if there is more than one mafia member, they have to come together and decide on who to kill during night 1. Therefore, we can conclude that killing off Geoni was a collective idea between the mafia members. Therefore, can't we conclude that both of the mafia members are inexperienced.

I stated before that I believe Geoni death was motivated by inexperienced players, but I don't see how both of them can come to that conclusion unless they are both inexperienced. I do believe that a Koopa/Cat team is possible but I'm not sure how experienced Cat is as mafia.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

Here's my quote regarding my reason why I think Geoni vote was inexperienced motivated.

It's a good theory about fearkilling Geoni. No experienced mafia would do that I would think. But who are the experienced here ? Sorry I am familiar with Antonio, Daniel and Geoni only. I know koopa's last game was last game. What about Betsy and Catharina? Are they new? I am assuming Catharina is new and Betsy has played games here for awhile

 

[Antonio]

It's a good theory about fearkilling Geoni. No experienced mafia would do that I would think. But who are the experienced here ? Sorry I am familiar with Antonio, Daniel and Geoni only. I know koopa's last game was last game. What about Betsy and Catharina? Are they new? I am assuming Catharina is new and Betsy has played games here for a while.

I believe Betsy is new because I don't recall playing with them. However, they have the actual drive to push on their opinions compared to both Koopa/Catharina. What's your opinion on a Koopa/Catharina team?

 

[Biancasbotique]

I believe Betsy is new because I don't recall playing with them. However, they have the actual drive to push on their opinions compared to both Koopa/Catharina. What's your opinion on a Koopa/Catharina team?

Based on your theory about fearkilling Geoni, it points out to possible Koopa/Catharina team

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

I put it in an earlier post somewhere. It's embarrassing. I was thinking both antonio/koopa entered the game in a similar way, and both going for geoni. Then antonio was pressuring koopa based on his geoni vote, while antonio was being pressured on his no vote. Add in geonis curse.

Then, i noticed antonio was basically parroting questions that had already been asked. I thought that was definitely sus and found plenty of direct examples, which I posted. Once he asked a question that had been answered in the post right before it. So I hammered him. Then he explained that he has a memory disability and did not remember things.... Well, that was embarrassing. Also, he started doing more detailed postings and reads.

Okay fair enough

 

[Antonio]

Based on your theory about fearkilling Geoni, it points out to possible Koopa/Catharina team

That's what I am thinking, what does everyone else think regarding the theory? I'm worried there may be a flaw with the theory but I haven't thought of one yet.

 

[BetsySundrop]

There are two mafia members in this game, due to the 1 mafia per 7 players rule (with the remainder counting as an extra). Right? Then wouldn't it make sense that both of them are inexperienced due to them voting off Geoni day 1? Usually, if there is more than one mafia member, they have to come together and decide on who to kill during night 1. Therefore, we can conclude that killing off Geoni was a collective idea between the mafia members. Therefore, can't we conclude that both of the mafia members are inexperienced.

I stated before that I believe Geoni death was motivated by inexperienced players, but I don't see how both of them can come to that conclusion unless they are both inexperienced. I do believe that a Koopa/Cat team is possible but I'm not sure how experienced Cat is as mafia.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

Here's my quote regarding my reason why I think Geoni vote was inexperienced motivated.

I really hate to say this because I'm inexperienced, but that does make sense, unless its an experienced player who is, uhmm not an expert?

 

[Biancasbotique]

I really hate to say this because I'm inexperienced, but that does make sense, unless its an experienced player who is, uhmm not an expert?

Yes it does, because you are describing me lol "experienced player who is not an expert"

 

[BetsySundrop]

It's a good theory about fearkilling Geoni. No experienced mafia would do that I would think. But who are the experienced here ? Sorry I am familiar with Antonio, Daniel and Geoni only. I know koopa's last game was last game. What about Betsy and Catharina? Are they new? I am assuming Catharina is new and Betsy has played games here for awhile

This is my first game lol.

 

[Biancasbotique]

This is my first game lol.

First game here in TBT or first game as mafia in general?

 

[Antonio]

Yes it does, because you are describing me lol "experienced player who is not an expert"

I also fall into the category too.

 

[Damniel]

yeah, like i said before, killing geoni is really weird when you end up confirming both wagons are town. i think mafia would hoping geoni would be eliminated cuz i doubt they’d kill blooming and blooming would probably behave the same today if they were busy with another game

 

[BetsySundrop]

That's what I am thinking, what does everyone else think regarding the theory? I'm worried there may be a flaw with the theory but I haven't thought of one yet.

I don't think it matters if it's flawed, it was a good point. I think I would broaden it to include players who aren't paying attention, or players who might make mistakes.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

First game here in TBT or first game as mafia in general?

First. Game. Ever. And while I love logic puzzles, etc...I gotta say, this is making me nuts.

 

[Damniel]

I don't think it matters if it's flawed, it was a good point. I think I would broaden it to include players who aren't paying attention, or players who might make mistakes.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

First. Game. Ever. And while I love logic puzzles, etc...I gotta say, this is making me nuts.

playing mafia is like eating spicy food, you enjoy the pain

 

[Biancasbotique]

Although you said first game ever. Are you also confirming that this is your first game as "mafia"

 

[BetsySundrop]

I may be a sucker, but I am holding off on Damniel, for now. I do appreciate the explanations, but i like Antonio's theory better, with modifications.

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

playing mafia is like eating spicy food, you enjoy the pain

It's giving me bird clues flashbacks...

Post automatically merged: Sep 14, 2021

Although you said first game ever. Are you also confirming that this is your first game as "mafia"

No. Wouldn't want my town to lose...

 

[Damniel]

Although you said first game ever. Are you also confirming that this is your first game as "mafia"

reminds me of when ness said “the town” instead of town and got eliminated for it and was mafia lmao