Mafia Murder Mystery Mafia-Mafia Win

[mogyay]

@dolby

1. He said he pmed a good part of the playerlist than bounced out of here. I assume that he's lurking considering that I asked why people are sus of me he said it was my attitude. His 'im going to pm a good chunk of the playerlist but leave the thread' rubs me the wrong way.

2. It might be tarot again considering the way the playerlist is acting like :eyes: rip cory

he did that in the previous game as well though. constantly made statements without backing them up. disappeared from the thread for long periods of time when people were questioning him. i agree it's shady but it doesn't seem much different from the last game

 

[f11]

he did that in the previous game as well though. constantly made statements without backing them up. disappeared from the thread for long periods of time when people were questioning him. i agree it's shady but it doesn't seem much different from the last game

well in my opinion I don't believe that considering he made multiple posts in the thread and actually suspected people in the last game I played with him.

 

[Chrystina]

Cory hasn't even made a single read or observation this entire game on panda. Unless you count him saying that she's "scum" then I don't know what you're agreeing to exactly???

Also, about improper:



She doesn't do any kind of substance to this post besides OMGUS. She says its time to "scum hunt" when she doesn't do any scum hunting at all. In fact, her next 2 posts are all threats about what will happen if we lynch her.





She's even back tracking in the last post. I'm pretty set on an improper lynch today.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Edit by posting: @Chrystina I know you mean you agree about panda being scum, but Cory hasn't done squat this whole game.

oh yeah I know Cory hasn't really done much. as you know from PM's, I was sus of panda a bit earlier so idk why I correlated it with agreeing with Cory. lol
especially since Dolby brought up really good points in his last post. being sus of someone for liking a post is just wat.

@Seroja
the reason why I said it was because Ares tried to do this trieing to avoid being lynched. I don't really like it when people say you will regret lynching me.

yeah but look what Ares turned out to be.

Crys/improper already soft claimed, but does mafia have safe claims? probably. so I'm somewhat agreeing with tardis here, it's not okay to just fully trust someone when they say "you'll regret lynching me" but... sometimes it is. crys is a more experienced player than ares was, so I'm going solely from meta and hers just isn't matching up.

---

my thoughts on other players-

Kirbystarship - not too sure really. null.
Dolby - town lean.
PandaDarling - pandaaaa are you scum ):
Mogyay - town lean
Liamslash - idk what to think about liam. havent seen him posting much. whoever said he was reminding them of aron in Trump, I gotta agree. (i think toads said this?)
Tom - apparently 3rd party?
Toadsworthy - town lean
Seroja - pretty sus of everyone but her reasoning makes sense.. not really sure what to think. more of a town lean than sus though.
Charlise / Natty / Byno - not sure. null
Karla - null / town lean?
FleshyBro - town lean
N e s s - town lean
Improper - scum pls lynch
Cory - cory .. eh... he isnt reminding me of xeno and AoT when he was town and posting a lot / posting without filters.. its almost like hes afraid of what to say ?? then again if hes scum, panda isn't. unless he would be so dumb to buss his partner this early. out of panda and him, i'm sure one of them is scum though.

 

[Cory]

You know all evidence can't be good.

 

[mogyay]

well in my opinion I don't believe that considering he made multiple posts in the thread and actually suspected people in the last game I played with him.

most of his posts were kinda crap though, i thought he could have done with toning it down and so far he is suspecting someone, it just happens to be u lol, id be interested in seeing if he has any more suspicions but like me, he might not have a lot to go off rn

 

[f11]

Idk how 'playing like xeno blade Mafia' is a good basis for lynch but ok chrys. I've never actually seen you play with this such certainty as 'town' I think you can bring a bit more proof than your sham case.

 

[PandaDarling]

I've never played with Liam before, but I PM'd him about the whole "I'm Townie" messages to more than half of us and all he wanted to say was "I don't know I wasn't thinking" and then he asked if I was gonna keep questioning him and I replied "what's wrong you don't want to communicate with me about he game?" And I haven't heard from him since. His unwillingness to cooperate and uninterest in not wanting to help scum hunt is making me suspicious of him still.

I want to hear more from Kirby, he is seeming a little quiet from what I remember, maybe he's changed his game play, if anyone can enlighten me on that it'd be much appreciated.

Please explain the bolded Panda.

My Thoughts
Cory- Dumb Town as usual. Behavior is similar to the beginning of AOT and Smash mafia
Liamslash- He PMed people and forgot to PM some of them. The actions that followed would be extremely dumb from a scum perspective. I feel like he's dumb town, let's move on
Chrystina-Feeling better about than earlier, simply for the Crys sus
Tom-He has a silver tongue that lies. Actually that claim could be proven though, if we have somebody perform an action on him on the night that he hides as a "coward". Pretty sure he'd be more cautious as scum
Improper/Crys-Not liking your recent behavior
Panda-Not liking their focus on Liam

Brief on most of these, I know. Have been at an wedding since 1 pm PST, so sorry for my absence
Will Charlise/Byngo's vote be nulled since they were replaced?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yes, I thought I said so earlier

@Dolby i was saying that even if all he did was make a noobie mistake or did something without thinking it though all the way, he is still not trying to help us understand it or explain himself, he's being too nonchalant for my liking.

 

[Cory]

I'm 95% sure improper is town

 

[N e s s]

I'm 95% sure improper is town

And why is that?

 

[Liamslash]

Thought I might post now and share my thoughts on this and apologise for my behaviour, the reason I posted this because people have asked, I don?t know, I just made a bad decision and a bad time that I regret doing.
I'm not hiding anything, I don?t save my sent messages so I don?t know who I sent it to, but if I recall it was everyone except Fleshy and Ness, and this was not on purpose, I did just skip over them because I passed their posts.
Reason I have been inactive was because I had nothing to say; I know, bad reason. I'm trying to mature and become a better player and person in general as I know I haven?t made the best impression on everyone, and I'm sorry for this. I'm still a kid growing up and I'm not mature yet.
Anyway, onto my reads so far and the general feeling.​

---

PandaDarling
First up, Panda. She?s really been tunnelling on me, asking me 7 questions in a row that I couldn't answer, and when I finally had enough she accused me of not helping town. She?s been going way too ham on me. Also the fact that she said I said that I ?Pm?d everyone? when I never said that, I always said almost and never confirmed that.

Tom
I don?t believe his claim, he could easily be some hidden 3rd party role. I also feel like he?s experienced at mafia and that just makes me suspicious /shrug

FleshyBro
Honestly I think that MexFleshy team is real stupid, why would he point at that I didn't PM him? And if I was scum, I would probably act smarter than how I was. I feel like he?s been on his own somehow(?), and that makes me think that he is more town aligned.

Chrystina
At first it was very PandaxChrystina, they seem to be trusting each other a lot and especially at first, makes me think that they are working together somehow. Lately she has been making me less suspicious, hence the orange.

Improper
First up, she?s been acting way too weird with me. I'm suspicious of her because of how she just focuses on one person, shouting out ?scum scum scum?, yet goes on to call me unhelpful town, and what are you Crys? She?s either 1)Scum or 2) Just being silly. She?s also been telling us what would happen if she died, without putting up a proper argument or anything to go off.


Can we please put this message thing behind us, it's stupid and it's not going anywhere lol

 

[Cory]

And why is that?

Guess no one else noticed it.

 

[PandaDarling]

@Chrystina i went back and i have ISO your post and you seem to be trying to find something that sticks, but you're struggling, you were first sus of Liam after i pointed out what we thought was a discrepancy in his actions, and then you say you're sus of Crys when Crys is sus of Liam and then sus of me for ? tunneling ? when thats what i do its a bad habit of mine but its not out of norm. and you say you AGREE with Cory but then you are slightly scum reading Cory ? noting you are saying is holding water.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Thought I might post now and share my thoughts on this and apologise for my behaviour, the reason I posted this because people have asked, I don’t know, I just made a bad decision and a bad time that I regret doing.
I'm not hiding anything, I don’t save my sent messages so I don’t know who I sent it to, but if I recall it was everyone except Fleshy and Ness, and this was not on purpose, I did just skip over them because I passed their posts.
Reason I have been inactive was because I had nothing to say; I know, bad reason. I'm trying to mature and become a better player and person in general as I know I haven’t made the best impression on everyone, and I'm sorry for this. I'm still a kid growing up and I'm not mature yet.
Anyway, onto my reads so far and the general feeling.​

---

PandaDarling
First up, Panda. She’s really been tunnelling on me, asking me 7 questions in a row that I couldn't answer, and when I finally had enough she accused me of not helping town. She’s been going way too ham on me. Also the fact that she said I said that I “Pm’d everyone” when I never said that, I always said almost and never confirmed that.

Tom
I don’t believe his claim, he could easily be some hidden 3rd party role. I also feel like he’s experienced at mafia and that just makes me suspicious /shrug

FleshyBro
Honestly I think that MexFleshy team is real stupid, why would he point at that I didn't PM him? And if I was scum, I would probably act smarter than how I was. I feel like he’s been on his own somehow(?), and that makes me think that he is more town aligned.

Chrystina
At first it was very PandaxChrystina, they seem to be trusting each other a lot and especially at first, makes me think that they are working together somehow. Lately she has been making me less suspicious, hence the orange.

Improper
First up, she’s been acting way too weird with me. I'm suspicious of her because of how she just focuses on one person, shouting out “scum scum scum”, yet goes on to call me unhelpful town, and what are you Crys? She’s either 1)Scum or 2) Just being silly. She’s also been telling us what would happen if she died, without putting up a proper argument or anything to go off.


Can we please put this message thing behind us, it's stupid and it's not going anywhere lol

WHO is coaching you ? ? ? i never asked you 7 questions, and i know you've never player with me before but tunneling is my thing ( its not a good thing, but its a bad habit of mine) so if any of you are scum reading me for that you don't understand my meta and anyone who's played several times can vouch for that (Ness, Dolby, Tom). how come you couldnt use words and explain yourself before this post ? it makes me feel like someone helped you write that post.

 

[Liamslash]

WHO is coaching you ? ? ? i never asked you 7 questions, and i know you've never player with me before but tunneling is my thing ( its not a good thing, but its a bad habit of mine) so if any of you are scum reading me for that you don't understand my meta and anyone who's played several times can vouch for that (Ness, Dolby, Tom). how come you couldnt use words and explain yourself before this post ? it makes me feel like someone helped you write that post.

You did, if you would like me to go back and count the amount of questions with a question mark on the end, I will do so. I know I haven't played with you, so therefore my opinions would differ. But I did post this myself, no one is coaching me. Actually, this does make me more suspicious of you.

 

[toadsworthy]

I bet the real mafias are just content with letting all this blow up. They are probably hiding in the shadows. I honestly don't think Liam would've done that if he was mafia.... As much as he is a rambunctious tyke, he's played enough to know that if he is on mafia you lay low the first day. There's no way he would've pmed that many people, especially if he had communication with his partner. (No one would say "yeah that's a good idea do it"). All this makes me most suspicious of the ones riding him so hard, especially the real experienced players. However with improper and panda given my experience with them they wouldn't be acting like that as mafia because they know better than to bring that attention on to themselves.

The person I am most hesitant about is chyrstina. She came in hard, made big broad assumptions that swayed pretty quickly then just fell off once everyone was all over Liam and improper.

 

[Byngo]

we're still in day 1 so Chrystina's confidence that 2 mafia are already found is peculiar imo

 

[N e s s]

From what I can tell Chrystina never put up any supporting claim for why she thinks panda is scum besides agreeing with Cory, who hasn't done squat.

I messaged Chrystina earlier yesterday, and she told me that she was suspicious of a discord conversation they had about Liam.

[9:07 PM] Panda: so ya i dunno whats going on i thought it was really weird that Liam PM'd EVERYONE except a few ?
[9:35 PM] Panda: ??
[9:46 PM] Chrystina: yeah same, fleshy does have a point in his reply to me but still.... i dunno, it is weird
[9:46 PM] Chrystina: and the fact he ignored your question lol, did he even reply to your PM?
[9:47 PM] Panda: Even if he didn't get to all of us cause he got lazy it's still weird that he would send a message to the majority of us "revealing his role" ya and he didn't even response ?
[9:47 PM] Panda: So even if he is town he isn't going to be much of a help is he ? Haha

what I put in bold struck me as realllly off. Like she's almost hoping some Liam bandwagon will form and she'll jump right on it

So besides that last sentence i'm not too sure why Chrystina is certain that panda is scum because she hasn't given any insight on the matter

 

[KarlaKGB]

reads to me like she wants to justify a mislynch

 

[PandaDarling]

reads to me like she wants to justify a mislynch

@Karla naw i was pointing out the fact that he most likely won't be much of a help to the rest of us trying to scum hunt.

NOTE: that Chrsytina and I are pretty good friends, we talk on a regular basis so when you read through our conversations they are more playful and relaxed than anything else not as serious as they might seem.

 

[Chrystina]

@Chrystina i went back and i have ISO your post and you seem to be trying to find something that sticks, but you're struggling, you were first sus of Liam after i pointed out what we thought was a discrepancy in his actions, and then you say you're sus of Crys when Crys is sus of Liam and then sus of me for ? tunneling ? when thats what i do its a bad habit of mine but its not out of norm. and you say you AGREE with Cory but then you are slightly scum reading Cory ? noting you are saying is holding water.

- - - Post Merge - - -



WHO is coaching you ? ? ? i never asked you 7 questions, and i know you've never player with me before but tunneling is my thing ( its not a good thing, but its a bad habit of mine) so if any of you are scum reading me for that you don't understand my meta and anyone who's played several times can vouch for that (Ness, Dolby, Tom). how come you couldnt use words and explain yourself before this post ? it makes me feel like someone helped you write that post.

so tldr im flip flopping? but I'm actually not. I pointed out the liam and fleshy thing because I wanted a reaction from fleshy, seeing as we already had gotten Liam to post a few times, I got my reaction and it leaned town to me so I backed off. (i explained this already).
I decided to start a discussion on crys since the thread was dying and look where it got us. an active day 1, so are you mad that I chose to start being sus of your scum buddy or you as well? or both?

but if you are finding me sus for being sus of other people, including yourself, then LOL that makes literally no sense

we're still in day 1 so Chrystina's confidence that 2 mafia are already found is peculiar imo

peculiar? explain

From what I can tell Chrystina never put up any supporting claim for why she thinks panda is scum besides agreeing with Cory, who hasn't done squat.

I messaged Chrystina earlier yesterday, and she told me that she was suspicious of a discord conversation they had about Liam.



So besides that last sentence i'm not too sure why Chrystina is certain that panda is scum because she hasn't given any insight on the matter

that conversation is exactly why I started becoming sus of Panda. that and the post I just replied to makes me even more confident that she's probs scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Guess no one else noticed it.

Guess not. So uhhhh wanna contribute and explain?

 

[f11]

hey make sure to unvote me as we might need my inquisitiveness to see the truth later in game