Seroja
buck's bff
Alright I'm finally home and on my laptop, yeay! Since this is a PM game, the thread moves a bit slowly but it is Day 1. I really need to read past PM games to see how information gathered via PM were shared in the thread itself. Right now, I don't know if my thoughts/reads based on posts made are valid because I'm sure a lot of things are going behind the scenes (which is making me extra paranoid).
So anyway, here are my thoughts (I just wish the names are clickable ;A; )
Kirby- Tardis didn't post much and some of his earlier posts were filler posts. But he did post some helpful info later on imo, so thank you for that. However, it is interesting that he jumped on Crys' case for pushing a policy lynch on Liam. He said that she was pushing for an easy lynch, but he did the same thing with Nightmares in the last mafia game when he was town.
And this (in reply to Crys)
seems a bit like blue hunting to me, but I'm just speculating. I am on the fence with Tardis as of now.
Dolby- Dolby didn't post often but his latest post was pretty insightful. Thank you for posting your thoughts, but what about the rest of the players though? Anyway, since this is my first time playing with him, and knowing how good he is at this game, I am a little scared and paranoid if he's mafia. I hope not, but I'll keep an eye on him.
Panda- Panda's posts were somewhat confusing in terms of logic (in ref to her replies to Karla). She was quick to be suspicious of people for the slightest thing but I think that's good if she's town. But I hope she'd be more careful with claiming someone saying something when in fact she heard it from someone else.
If Karla hadn't questioned it, her statement could have caused a misinformation on Liam. Not sure if she was just careless or mafia. I'll keep a close eye on you.
Mog- Posting and questioning sensibly & freely. I think she's been helpful to town so far.
Liam- Like I said before, he's the type that says/do things without thinking them through. I am leaning more on him being town, though we can never be too careful. He could use this 'typical' behaviour of his to fool people. But I won't bet on it. The only thing I'm iffy about is that it's been almost a day since I pmed him and still no reply.
Tom- Tom is also one the players I will be having my sus goggles on. His 3rd party claim was unsettling. He said he was gonna try 'scheming some more'. Scheming what and why?
Are you really pro town? If you are, then what kind of scheming were you planning to do? How are we to know you're not just claiming so that town won't lynch you and then proceed to stab us on the back? Have to be extra careful here.
Toad- Didn't post much. I'm mostly null on him. But he could be coasting. Gotta keep an eye out.
Charlise/Natty- Umm very iffy with both so far. I'll wait until Natty posts more though.
Karla- Hmm honestly don't know what to think. He's a really snarky (sensible, but snarky) player though. Seems he posted whatever was on his mind, with a lot of snark added in.
Fleshy- Got the same vibe and tone as his previous game and he was town. I'm not too worried about him for now.
Ness- Ness is half and half to me. He seems to be pretty straightforward but I don't know. He could go either way to me for now.
Chrystina- Appears to be actively scum hunting, very aggressive. Not sure if really town (she did make a small case for Crys) or appearing to be helpful to town but is actually pushing for a mislynch. I will keep a close eye on her too.
Improper- The policy lynch Liam thing is a bit suspicious and because of that, if she's really town, I don't know why she insisted on it because she should know what happened with Tardis in the last game where he pulled the same move. If she's mafia why would she put herself on the radar and risk becoming suspicious/a lynch candidate by doing this? But maybe being obvious would make people think she couldn't have been mafia especially with Tardis already being an example. This could really go either way.
Cory- I honestly don't know why anyone who have no desire to play properly would even think about signing up. Please make an effort into helping town. If doing nothing means he is being 'town', then he could easily be mafia, not do anything/throw accusations around freely without proper explanation- and still be written off as town. This doesn't really sit well with me.
--
tl;dr I'm sus of almost everyone. I get very paranoid with good/experienced players because that means they could easily blend in with town and I'd not pick up on it, so I'll be keeping my eyes on them the most. And this being a PM game does not help at all (paranoia heightens). The only ones I'm more or less sure of are those who I've played with (mog, Liam, fleshy). It's 12am now and I need to get to bed soon so hopefully I can decide on who to vote soon.
So anyway, here are my thoughts (I just wish the names are clickable ;A; )
Kirby- Tardis didn't post much and some of his earlier posts were filler posts. But he did post some helpful info later on imo, so thank you for that. However, it is interesting that he jumped on Crys' case for pushing a policy lynch on Liam. He said that she was pushing for an easy lynch, but he did the same thing with Nightmares in the last mafia game when he was town.
And this (in reply to Crys)
seems a bit like blue hunting to me, but I'm just speculating. I am on the fence with Tardis as of now.
Dolby- Dolby didn't post often but his latest post was pretty insightful. Thank you for posting your thoughts, but what about the rest of the players though? Anyway, since this is my first time playing with him, and knowing how good he is at this game, I am a little scared and paranoid if he's mafia. I hope not, but I'll keep an eye on him.
Panda- Panda's posts were somewhat confusing in terms of logic (in ref to her replies to Karla). She was quick to be suspicious of people for the slightest thing but I think that's good if she's town. But I hope she'd be more careful with claiming someone saying something when in fact she heard it from someone else.
If Karla hadn't questioned it, her statement could have caused a misinformation on Liam. Not sure if she was just careless or mafia. I'll keep a close eye on you.
Mog- Posting and questioning sensibly & freely. I think she's been helpful to town so far.
Liam- Like I said before, he's the type that says/do things without thinking them through. I am leaning more on him being town, though we can never be too careful. He could use this 'typical' behaviour of his to fool people. But I won't bet on it. The only thing I'm iffy about is that it's been almost a day since I pmed him and still no reply.
Tom- Tom is also one the players I will be having my sus goggles on. His 3rd party claim was unsettling. He said he was gonna try 'scheming some more'. Scheming what and why?
Are you really pro town? If you are, then what kind of scheming were you planning to do? How are we to know you're not just claiming so that town won't lynch you and then proceed to stab us on the back? Have to be extra careful here.
Toad- Didn't post much. I'm mostly null on him. But he could be coasting. Gotta keep an eye out.
Charlise/Natty- Umm very iffy with both so far. I'll wait until Natty posts more though.
Karla- Hmm honestly don't know what to think. He's a really snarky (sensible, but snarky) player though. Seems he posted whatever was on his mind, with a lot of snark added in.
Fleshy- Got the same vibe and tone as his previous game and he was town. I'm not too worried about him for now.
Ness- Ness is half and half to me. He seems to be pretty straightforward but I don't know. He could go either way to me for now.
Chrystina- Appears to be actively scum hunting, very aggressive. Not sure if really town (she did make a small case for Crys) or appearing to be helpful to town but is actually pushing for a mislynch. I will keep a close eye on her too.
Improper- The policy lynch Liam thing is a bit suspicious and because of that, if she's really town, I don't know why she insisted on it because she should know what happened with Tardis in the last game where he pulled the same move. If she's mafia why would she put herself on the radar and risk becoming suspicious/a lynch candidate by doing this? But maybe being obvious would make people think she couldn't have been mafia especially with Tardis already being an example. This could really go either way.
Cory- I honestly don't know why anyone who have no desire to play properly would even think about signing up. Please make an effort into helping town. If doing nothing means he is being 'town', then he could easily be mafia, not do anything/throw accusations around freely without proper explanation- and still be written off as town. This doesn't really sit well with me.
--
tl;dr I'm sus of almost everyone. I get very paranoid with good/experienced players because that means they could easily blend in with town and I'd not pick up on it, so I'll be keeping my eyes on them the most. And this being a PM game does not help at all (paranoia heightens). The only ones I'm more or less sure of are those who I've played with (mog, Liam, fleshy). It's 12am now and I need to get to bed soon so hopefully I can decide on who to vote soon.
anyways this whole 'case' is bs considering I started the liam wagon duh!!!! anyway im surprised you used 'is scum' rather than something like 'has the chance to be/im thinking they might' but no chrys seems to be 100% certain I was scum. Last time I saw her this certain this early was AOT :eyes: ciao
