Mafia Murder Mystery Mafia-Mafia Win

After playing Mafia Mystery games for 2 years, ik how to investigate people on the first few days ^^

You do remember this is a PM game, you can talk to the other players outside the thread.

- - - Post Merge - - -

His claim is a lie
him and panda are scum

@Cory who ? Tom or Liam ? Why don't you explain your train of thought ? You just pop in here and blurt out accusations.
 
After playing Mafia Mystery games for 2 years, ik how to investigate people on the first few days ^^
Okay can you point out where and how my claim doesn't add up? I mean if there were deaths already I'd be more inclined to follow blindly, but ya kinda lackin in sway.

His claim is a lie
him and panda are scum
I am so glad you're just as predictable as you've always been.
 
My thoughts so far.

I feel like Crys is trying to push easy lynches like this post.
I'm voting Liam because he pmed 'Everyone' like an IDIOT, and ended up lying and skipping parts of the player list. Thank you for reading my opinions.

Feels scummy. Kinda reminds me of Mog doing almost the same thing the last game she was scum.
I think we should believe Liam for right now and focus on someone else.
Cory seems to be acting like his passed games.
Not sure about everyone else.
 
Tom is set to be lynched with only 2 votes. Please remember the voting rules and that you have until tomorrow 9PM EST.

I'll make a counter right now.
 
Out of everyone in the game right now, improper is the scummiest to me.

I'm voting Liam because he pmed 'Everyone' like an IDIOT, and ended up lying and skipping parts of the player list. Thank you for reading my opinions.

It feels like she is just hoping that there will be a wagon on Liam, instead of actually being suspicious, like she wants an excuse to lynch him.

xeno maf isn't real. It's day one and I'm okay with a Liam policy lynch.

It shows even more here that she's looking for an excuse to lynch Liam from the mere fact that she's calling lynching him a "policy lynch" when she just called him scum. Also, Policy lynches are absolute garbage and it just wastes D1. We have WoTC to get rid of bad players.

I'm alright with lynching improper today.
 
Because he is a third party.

:lemon:

I am so glad the lessons we take away from newbie games is that third party is bad because they are unknown and the unknown is scary!!!!

I've talked about it outside of the thread, but I do agree Improper/Crys is easily the scummiest person here right now. I think frankly if we were dedicated to going a policy lynch route we would have gone for inactive or bad players, Liam's at least trying compared to some.
 
Well Charlise is out. I just asked her why she voted tom and this was the response:

Charlise said:
N e s s said:
Would you mind if I asked why you're voting for the player Tom in the mafia game?

I'm actually quitting so I can't answer that question ^^
 
Back
Top