I honestly have no idea what I'm doing. This is my first mafia game so I am still really confused by everything lol
Mafia Noatun, City of Genesis | Bayonetta 2 Mafia | Umbra Witches Win
- Thread starter Bowie
- Start date
I honestly have no idea what I'm doing. This is my first mafia game so I am still really confused by everything lol
there has to be SOMETHING that made you vote
amanda1983
Senior Member
Ah mafia is a very confusing game at first, definitely. And I completely understand feeling pressure to vote, especially as we were both up for elimination if we failed to vote today (in-game day).
Why did you choose Ness though? There aren't really any right or wrong answers to that kind of question, although some are more likely to raise suspicions than others of course. You've clearly kept up with the thread since you quoted me and then Lani (Nightmares), so what made you choose Ness over any other name on the player list?
Yooooo.
Heyyyy.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I'm guessing Tensu voted Ness because of how aggressive he is, Tensu is new and things like this may same odd. So this is probably why they voted for Ness.
If I was new and didn't know what I was doing, I might have done the same.
maybe but even so, his aggressive play-style alone Isnt really reason enough to actually vote for him, especially when you cant edit/change your vote
I'd say there would be 2 or 3 sages? Then 7 or 8 townies?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Yeah, I don't really know what their reasoning was. Guess we'll just wait.
I'm going to lost a reads list soon by the way.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Lost = Post
.....
It isn't to do with me being suspicious of Uttumori, because I'm not. I'm trying to find where their thoughts stand on.
Don't know where the hell Prima went so I might as well look into other players, and Zendel isn't saying anything else that stands out to me just yet. I would like to see him step up instead of use the "I'm new" excuse.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I said don't give me a one-liner. Can you tell me in detail (Aka give me quotes, thought-provoking reasoning not just one liner posts like you did here) why you think that Primarina is suspicious?
I'm here. Just caught up on the thread after being away for about a day of real time. I'm still not sure why I'm suspect to people for voting for Corrie. I explained that I was feeling pressure to vote and didn't want to vote for no one, so I went with the person with the most votes to find out more information from their ouster. Unfortunately that ended up being a mistake because it was a mislynch, but I am new and thus admittedly not always sure what's best or what people consider normal here.
I think she had another motive besides the number of votes corrie had, also because she seems to have contradicted herself while responding to you and toad's questions
^^that was in response to toad
^^and that was in response to you, it seems like she tried to change her reason on voting, I'm probably wrong but thats just how i see it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh it seems like prim just barely explained herself woops
People can have multiple simultaneous motivations for doing something. I'm still not understanding why that's inherently weird. P.S. Again, I'm a dude.
Nightmares
(￣。￣)～ｚｚｚ
Prima is a dude btw
I feel those two points go together, but I see where you're coming from I guess
He wanted to at least vote for someone, and went with Corrie because she had the most votes = results
But he is the most sus still, and I'm not really agreeing with either of you at this point.... ;;
There's a high chance that the vote could have been a bandwagon-- whatever-- so yeah
Can I say he's in between null and scum LMAO
Last edited:
Tensu - Not enough to go off. He's new and voting for Ness hasn't been justified just yet, so I'll wait to see why he voted for him and then that might give some hints or information that make him seem sus or not.
Nightmares - Seems genuine and is sharing opinions openly but it really isn't enough for him to determine whether or not their town or sus.
Uttumori - She has been trying to get information and has been giving her opinion openly, it has definitely been enough for me to see some town characteristics, so town leaning but I'm not 100% certain.
Primarina - When they voted it seemed odd, It was like the last ten minutes that they jumped in. (Correct me if I am wrong) They have said that it's better having a lynch than no lynch and that we may get more information after the lynch but that doesn't really seem like a valid reason to lynch to me. Lack of trust from an other player is what should motivate your vote against them, I really don't find it to be worth it honestly if you lose a member for more info. Corrie's lynch was a mistake and the only one who is really getting bother for it is you, so it definitely wasn't the right choice for you. You're a mafia lean/ null for me at the moment.
Amanda - Giving information which is plausible, contributing and giving her opinion openly.
Toadsworthy - Played like this the first time I played mafia and was town, so I don't really see any reason why he wouldn't be town. For now I'm not sus of him, but that could change later on.
Ness - A weird one for me right now, he played like this the first time I played mafia and of course he was town, he will usually look in the wrong direction like he is now because get this, I was town in that game and he kept on trying to pressure me when I didn't really know what I was doing yet he expects to get amazing information from me and he's doing the same now. I've played 2 games Ness not like a bunch like you, so of course I'm not going to be amazing at it. Again he tries to pressure people and it works for the most part but like I said, he points at the wrong direction as he did the same thing to me the last time we played together and I was new + I was town.
I think there is 3 sages and 7 witches, minus two now.
So possibly 3 vs 5 at the moment.
Town:
Uttumori (still cautious)
Toad
Amanda
Zendel
Null:
Nightmares
Tensu
Ness
Mafia leans:
Primarina
- - - Post Merge - - -
Sorry for any errors in any sentences.
Nightmares - Seems genuine and is sharing opinions openly but it really isn't enough for him to determine whether or not their town or sus.
Uttumori - She has been trying to get information and has been giving her opinion openly, it has definitely been enough for me to see some town characteristics, so town leaning but I'm not 100% certain.
Primarina - When they voted it seemed odd, It was like the last ten minutes that they jumped in. (Correct me if I am wrong) They have said that it's better having a lynch than no lynch and that we may get more information after the lynch but that doesn't really seem like a valid reason to lynch to me. Lack of trust from an other player is what should motivate your vote against them, I really don't find it to be worth it honestly if you lose a member for more info. Corrie's lynch was a mistake and the only one who is really getting bother for it is you, so it definitely wasn't the right choice for you. You're a mafia lean/ null for me at the moment.
Amanda - Giving information which is plausible, contributing and giving her opinion openly.
Toadsworthy - Played like this the first time I played mafia and was town, so I don't really see any reason why he wouldn't be town. For now I'm not sus of him, but that could change later on.
Ness - A weird one for me right now, he played like this the first time I played mafia and of course he was town, he will usually look in the wrong direction like he is now because get this, I was town in that game and he kept on trying to pressure me when I didn't really know what I was doing yet he expects to get amazing information from me and he's doing the same now. I've played 2 games Ness not like a bunch like you, so of course I'm not going to be amazing at it. Again he tries to pressure people and it works for the most part but like I said, he points at the wrong direction as he did the same thing to me the last time we played together and I was new + I was town.
I think there is 3 sages and 7 witches, minus two now.
So possibly 3 vs 5 at the moment.
Town:
Uttumori (still cautious)
Toad
Amanda
Zendel
Null:
Nightmares
Tensu
Ness
Mafia leans:
Primarina
- - - Post Merge - - -
Sorry for any errors in any sentences.
amanda1983
Senior Member
From memory Prima explained the vote at the time when Toads asked, and I didn't think there was anything odd or suspicious about the reasoning Prima gave. I haven't seen anything since that's changed my perception but I'll go over the posts when I can (I'm not home yet and it's almost midnight so I'll do my best to get that done before EoD 2 but I can't promise I will).
I know, that's why I'm not 100% certain that he's mafia.
amanda1983
Senior Member
Ah I'm sorry for the confusion, I just checked the timestamps. When I sent my post through I hadn't seen your's yet - I'm on mobile on a train coming from the country so internet reception is spotty lol.
If I'd seen your post I'd have worded mine a bit differently to make sure it was clear mine was just a general comment rather than a reply aimed at anyone.
Oh right, sorry then!
um to be honest, I've been reading a bit through the posts and I've noticed they were a bit aggressive and I thought that was a bit suspicious I guess. Sorry but there's not really much more to it than that I think
amanda1983
Senior Member
Your reasoning is sound, and I'm going to keep it in mind when I go back through the posts. Please don't feel pressure to change your reads from me or anyone else, your doing great!
Thanks, I really hope I know what I'm doing though haha
amanda1983
Senior Member
Edit by way of post : post #158 is to Zendel, sorry! I'm going to give up trying to post on this internet now.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ah haha this does apply to you, too, though I wrote it for Zendel. I'm so sorry for the confusion. I've made a mess of this lol.
:/
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ah haha this does apply to you, too, though I wrote it for Zendel. I'm so sorry for the confusion. I've made a mess of this lol.
:/
