Overrated Villager

[Dwayne Johnson]

raymond is just fujo bait lmao, let the tweeters have him

 

[0ni]

I've never understood the appeal of Fauna or Diana, they are always at the tops of the popularity lists and I keep trying to warm to them but just ... idk, something doesn't click

 

[h1pst4r]

Ngl I disliked Judy’s design when I first saw her because it felt just “too much”. But now I kind of want to find her, haha.

I also let Beardo move out to bring in Marshal, and while I feel Marshal is SUPER cute, I really missed Beardo for the first week! He had so much spunk and personality. Underrated for sure (not the point of the thread, but I was reminded by all the Marshal comments).

 

[0ni]

I actually have judy in my town and I adore her with every fiber in my body, but I ABSOLUTELY understand the creepy factor of the anime eyes

I totally get the creepy factor as well, but It only makes me love her more. Same with Coco, and also with Dotty's 'demon-eyes' surprised look lmao

 

[Uffe]

Raymond. He's like Marshal all over again. Nothing all that interesting but somehow popular. The only thing I like about Raymond is the heterochromia eyes, but that's it. There are far more interesting looking villagers.

 

[PugLovex]

i also must agree, raymond is highly overrated, even though he’s one of my new favorite villagers

i personally don’t like julian. i just don’t find him very interesting, same with marshal, although i used to hate marshal but i actually really like him now

i also must say judy. i’m sorry she is so scary looking to me with her eyes, i don’t find her cute at all. maybe i would like her if she weren’t snooty, i feel like the snooty just doesn’t fit her

 

[peachmilke]

I agree with all the raymond posts, out of the cats I feel like there are much better options and I think in terms of smugs there are just others I prefer! Aside from him I would say Merengue, I think she's cute but idk I'm not in love either

 

[Meira]

I think Raymond is overhyped and I would never pay that much to get him, however I do see why people are willing to do anything for him.

 

[Uffe]

I think Raymond is overhyped and I would never pay that much to get him, however I do see why people are willing to do anything for him.

If he was in my campsite, I would get Raymond. I grabbed Marshal when he visited my campsite. Yeah, I know I said they're overrated, but if people like them, why not make them envious if they visit? I still don't understand the appeal, but Marshal did grow on me.

 

[Koala92]

Sherb. He annoyed me when he was on my kids island.

 

[Meira]

If he was in my campsite, I would get Raymond. I grabbed Marshal when he visited my campsite. Yeah, I know I said they're overrated, but if people like them, why not make them envious if they visit? I still don't understand the appeal, but Marshal did grow on me.

Oh for sure, if they did come to my campsite, why not? I would probably sell them if I wasn't feeling them
Sometimes it might not be the looks that get you but the personality. For me that is the case anyway

 

[Sudsofsplash]

Personally I've never really cared about the "status" of a villagers popularity - I honestly only wanted Audie because I thought she was cute and I want Coco because I really liked her in New Leaf (and I've always wanted Lucky, so cute!!!)

I never want to purchase villagers off of people because personally the fun to me is seeking them out and finding them and maybe finding someone I never expected to like and keep (Like Dom! I can't help it, I have a soft spot for jocks) Honestly I got rid of my amiibo villagers too, because there was something boring about barely even working to find and get them in my personal opinion.

I don't think there's overrated villagers, I think there's the more "desirable" villagers. I think that it's really just up to everyone's personal opinion! I personally really disliked Raymond because I'm not a fan of the smug personalities (O'hare is the only smug for me LOL) and Sherb just repeated a lot of stuff my other lazy said and I ended up finding Bob anyways (Who I personally find a lot cuter than Sherb even though I love the goats)
It's just all down to personal preference like I hate the squirrels, so I'd never want Marshall anyways (Plus not a fan of smugs lol) I can see why people like them but personally it's not for me, but that doesn't mean they're overrated for being popular! Sure, people should give "lesser" villagers a chance, but it is their game and if they want Marshall, Raymond, and all the other populars then so be it!

 

[Uffe]

Oh for sure, if they did come to my campsite, why not? I would probably sell them if I wasn't feeling them
Sometimes it might not be the looks that get you but the personality. For me that is the case anyway

I don't know what people think of Hopkins, but I love bunnies and the color blue. When I found out he was basically a walking balloon or whatever, I had to get him. I also like his personality. I think he's lazy, and those types usually make me laugh with what they say.

 

[abby10]

I don't suuuuper get Fang's popularity tbh. Like I like him and all but I personally don't understand why he is top tier

 

[Jared:3]

Raymond for sure, not hating on him or anything but I don't see the obsession with him

 

[Rosewater]

Raymond looks gross fam. I don't like the 2012 hipster look he has going on. Just real outdated and not aesthetically pleasing at all.

Also I don't like Lolly. Her eyes are creepy.

 

[cinch]

.

 

[Sloom]

in this thread:

hope you enjoyed my creation i worked very hard on it

 

[petaI]

judy, sherb, raymond, dom, coco, stitches, ankha ..

 

[Hay]

Raymond is super over-rated imo... Hes a cat (like the 50th one, we didnt need another cat Nintendo) and his glasses dont even have frames. It reminds me of the kids who would say they wore glasses but just knocked the frames off the their 3D glasses from the movie theater. I saw someone who said that hes the first villager who wears glasses which is not true either :c I just dont get the hype!

edit: if he was a different animal i think I would like him more but the fact that there are so many cats already its so basic..