• Guest, can you feel the love in the air? Valentine's Week at The Bell Tree has begun with a new mini-event featuring four activities to enjoy -- new and returning collectibles are up for grabs! Dive in to the love here.

Mafia Squeaky Clean Mafia - Day 3 - Ends Monday May 25 at 7pm EST

Mayor Leaf said:
so maybe she's a special role?
Click to expand...

let me tell you if she's a special role that is town-sided she would never do what she did- not even trying to defend herself. Kat is one of the best mafia players here (my opinion) and her last post didn't sit right with me.
 
my whole issue with kat is,

why would you come out and claim a name that is so clearly not gonna be town regardless of if you know the theme or not. he doesn't scream town at all so part of me is wondering if maybe kat wants an early out of the game hence why she would lie abt the name? am i reading too much into it?

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
DinoTown said:
I think - assuming the theme is true - that it's likely a special role for mafia or third party, a.k.a something town wants to get rid of ASAP.

Yes, there's the possibility the whole role name theme thing is a lot of hooey, however, at this rate, lynching Kat and watching where that flips is the best way to confirm this. Is Kat flips town, we will know that following the pursuit of role names was a bad idea and to not focus on that again in the future.
Click to expand...

we've literally already been told in the FIRST POST that following the pursuit of role names is a bad idea. voting based on role names is literally so lazy and it basically makes the past 350 posts completely pointless

you and antonio are suddenly tunnelling super hard on arstotzkhan. if she gets lynched and flips town my pre-existing suspicions on both of you are definitely warranted

honestly even if she flips scum i'm skeptical of you both
 
If kat flips, let's acknowledge Mayor Leaf relentless defense regarding them during the next phase.
Post automatically merged:

epona said:
we've literally already been told in the FIRST POST that following the pursuit of role names is a bad idea. voting based on role names is literally so lazy and it basically makes the past 350 posts completely pointless

you and antonio are suddenly tunnelling super hard on arstotzkhan. if she gets lynched and flips town my pre-existing suspicions on both of you are definitely warranted

honestly even if she flips scum i'm skeptical of you both
Click to expand...
Did you say you were going to change your vote to Kat? You're in this as much as us.
Post automatically merged:

Didn't*
Post automatically merged:

Listen, if kat is town then she should have been doing a much better defense regarding it.
 
epona said:
we've literally already been told in the FIRST POST that following the pursuit of role names is a bad idea. voting based on role names is literally so lazy and it basically makes the past 350 posts completely pointless

you and antonio are suddenly tunnelling super hard on arstotzkhan. if she gets lynched and flips town my pre-existing suspicions on both of you are definitely warranted

honestly even if she flips scum i'm skeptical of you both
Click to expand...

i agree with this, you're both pushing pretty hard against her and i think she could be town. i don't want to vote her but i like the way epona is framing her mislynch as a clue.
 
Antonio said:
If kat flips, let's acknowledge Mayor Leaf relentless defense regarding them during the next phase.
Post automatically merged:


Did you say you were going to change your vote to Kat? You're in this as much as us.
Post automatically merged:

Didn't*
Post automatically merged:

Listen, if kat is town then she should have been doing a much better defense regarding it.
Click to expand...

yeah, and then literally immediately after i posted that i was going to vote for her this whole thing spiralled
i haven't case a vote yet
 
Hey Epona, what do you think about Kat peacing out and not even attempting to defend themselves right when everything comes crashing down around them?
Post automatically merged:

Also vote placed, if I stop talking, I went to sleep
 
DinoTown said:
Hey Epona, what do you think about Kat peacing out and not even attempting to defend themselves right when everything comes crashing down around them?
Post automatically merged:

Also vote placed, if I stop talking, I went to sleep
Click to expand...

She realized she was getting lynched and accepted her fate. That's what I think is happening.
 
DinoTown said:
why are you willing to vote for someone you think is town?
that just looks bad, you'd be better off voting for someone you are actually worried about
Click to expand...
i respect the POVs others have suggested and i can see how she can be seen as a threat to town. i meant i was willing to vote for her if my vote counted, but seeing the latest tally of votes she's set to be lynched anyway and i just don't agree.
 
Mayor Leaf said:
i agree with this, you're both pushing pretty hard against her and i think she could be town. i don't want to vote her but i like the way epona is framing her mislynch as a clue.
Click to expand...
epona said:
yeah, and then literally immediately after i posted that i was going to vote for her this whole thing spiralled
i haven't case a vote yet
Click to expand...
Nothing has spiraled though? :/

Also, what am i supposed to do? Let you leave terrible arguments that has obvious holes regarding the logic? Am i not supposed to reply and let your terrible arguments linger?

Anyways, you ain't providing any other factual responses to mine. All you did was throw suspicion on me because you lacked argument.

4. Argument Backed by a Stick (Force; Argumentum Ad Baculum) — resorting to threat in order to have a point accepted.
Click to expand...
This is an argument fallacy. You are putting doubt into our suspicions for a reason.
 
My sus about Antonio were about making a fuss and misleading town, but now I think he's right on the topic and helping everyone colaborates, so it would be silly of me to keep my pride and a vote on him.
Also mayorleaf here is going on a tangent jesus christ
 
DinoTown said:
Hey Epona, what do you think about Kat peacing out and not even attempting to defend themselves right when everything comes crashing down around them?
Post automatically merged:

Also vote placed, if I stop talking, I went to sleep
Click to expand...

i think her roleclaim was more of a tactic to distract from the growing wagon on her. i don't think she's mafia; maybe third party, but either way the way she's playing is starkly anti-town and i don't really see any point in not lynching her at this stage

you and antonio really pushing the role name angle is giving me more red flags than kat herself though
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
934
N e s s
N e s s
C
Review the Video Game Above You!
Replies
11
Views
242
Midoriya
Midoriya
ILoveAnimalCrossing123
Bell Tree Forums Profile Inventory Item + TBT Bell Giveaway Contest Game (kinda but it is also kinda a game)
Replies
4
Views
191
-Blue-
-Blue-
C
Write Me a Short Story About...
Replies
1
Views
113
CoolJhon
CoolJhon
C
Make a Mii of the User Above You!
Replies
0
Views
122
Chronos314_XD
C
Back
Top