Mafia Super Smash Bros: Mafia! Game over! Mafia wins!

I don't think a player like ender would make a stupid move like that, that's just asking to be lynched if I was lynched and flipped red.

I agree with you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

When did I ever put my suspicions on endless?

You're mean for making me dig for this
I'm done with my reads, but my spoilers turned out weird so sorry about that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay as promised, here are my reads. Even though like half of the players i can't read due to lack of posting, here it is.
 
To be honest ender, your opinion on scum is constantly changing. You say kill kit but then me but then trundle. Your acting weird.
 
Tbh Trundle is a viable option. He's hardly clear, though I don't really get a scum-feel from him at all. Still could be worth a cop-scry because I've been told he's good, and I haven't played with him previously, so I've got no real grasp on him yet.

My biggest thing is that Tom died. That's what I think should be looked at if you're considering Trundle. Tom didn't really do much, they did a bit of "meme-mafia" back and forth together.

Tom tends to die early in more recent games because people think that he's an amazing player (which he doesn't really get to show off because he dies early). They view him as a threat. Trundle has played games with Tom before, he knows that Tom would be able to catch him if he (Trundle) was scum.

The same could also be said about me and Dolby, so take as you will.
 
"nintendofan85,Bluepikachu,cheese4mees,KumKwat,Monkeyd99,Pillow Bunny,Sap88,Haydenn- Have not posted enough to get a proper read on them, sure they could be secretly laying low while talking to their teamates, but i can't give a scumread with so little they have provided. A couple of them have already voted, but haven't really said why so i want to hear from these people.
Oath2Order, Tom,Kit, and Trundle- Have only posted a little, but hasn't really helped town much. Oath voted for me solely because Ender was suspicious but never stated why he was sus, which is a bit weird thing to do for an experienced player. Tom has really only been joking around, but i haven't seen anything that has caught my eye yet. Kit has only popped in from time to time to state facts and possibilites, but hasn't given much of their own opinion on things. Trundle only popped in when people asked where he was, which is a bit strange but it could just be for a busy schedule so i won't think to much about it, hasn't really provided much but just agree with my suspicions of Starry. I haven't seen anything to strange with these players so they're town to me for now.
Dolby-
Dolby has only recently joined, but his read on Lucanosa wasn't really solid as Lucanosa playing IRL mafia would explain why he claimed to have played before, yet still be confused, not saying this means Lucanosa is innocent, but it's possible it was just a new mistake. Dolby hasn't posted a lot to work with so they're okay for now.
Ender & Endless- They're just questioning people so far which isn't unusual to me. But both held back on their reads on me so i want to know what's up with that. It wouldn't really surprise me if they were mafia, but i don't think they are. I can't really get a good read on them is what i'm basically saying.
Lucanosa- He's new to mafia(or claims to be new to forum mafia), so he's somewhat confusing and illogical behavior can be explained by that, but it doesn't mean a new member should be excused for their actions(N e s s and Starrywolf were new players and were also mafia so i can't shake of the possibility like i have before).

He has continuously been acting erratically and confused, which makes sense for a newbie. If he was in fact mafia, the team should be ashamed of themselves for letting him do all this confusing stuff and not controlling him. I'm not saying i think your compleltey innocent, but your behavior can easily be explained so i'm not putting you for priority lynch.
Starrywolf- My priority lynch for today.

Overall, i your scummy behavior can only be explained by you actually being mafia, i wouldn't know why you would act like this otherwise, acting silly and innocent, but when caught changes to a calm person who bandwagon ed on me for Lucanosa. Your teammates trying yo save you it seems."

Reading the origonal post is better for anyone who feels like digging, just posting this because the quote glitched
 
I agree with you.

- - - Post Merge - - -



You're mean for making me dig for this
I'm done with my reads, but my spoilers turned out weird so sorry about that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay as promised, here are my reads. Even though like half of the players i can't read due to lack of posting, here it is.
Oh yeah I Labelled them as either way but I don't think that would be considered high suspicions.
 
My biggest thing is that Tom died. That's what I think should be looked at if you're considering Trundle. Tom didn't really do much, they did a bit of "meme-mafia" back and forth together.

Tom tends to die early in more recent games because people think that he's an amazing player (which he doesn't really get to show off because he dies early). They view him as a threat. Trundle has played games with Tom before, he knows that Tom would be able to catch him if he (Trundle) was scum.

The same could also be said about me and Dolby, so take as you will.
I didn't know that about Tom. Barely even thought about his death..
Hmm

- - - Post Merge - - -

I agree with you.

- - - Post Merge - - -



You're mean for making me dig for this


Oh yeah I Labelled them as either way but I don't think that would be considered high suspicions.
Right but it was still a thingy
 
To be honest ender, your opinion on scum is constantly changing. You say kill kit but then me but then trundle. Your acting weird.

... wtf is this post even.

I said kill kit, and then backed off when they claimed Cop. That's a reasonable reaction.

I said that I Don't want to kill you but with only 4 hours left in the day, I've acknowledged that you might be the best lynch target for today.

I never said I want to lynch trundle. I just acknowledged that Kit's point about Trundle might be true, and admitted that I had no real read on him.
 
My biggest thing is that Tom died. That's what I think should be looked at if you're considering Trundle. Tom didn't really do much, they did a bit of "meme-mafia" back and forth together.

Tom tends to die early in more recent games because people think that he's an amazing player (which he doesn't really get to show off because he dies early). They view him as a threat. Trundle has played games with Tom before, he knows that Tom would be able to catch him if he (Trundle) was scum.

The same could also be said about me and Dolby, so take as you will.

Definitely to keep in mind but not really enough to build a case.
 
I want to hear from the inactives, nintendofan voted but didn't say anything afterwards and I feel like they have something important to say, pretty sure one of them is the vig who killed sap.

The fact that there was a survivor in this game makes me wonder the set up is.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If no one is going to claim cop, I'm going to have to believe kit.
 
Back
Top