Mafia TBT Mafia: Game of Thrones - A Crown for a King - GAME OVER

[oath2order]

no i didnt, is there some relevant lesson to learn from that?

Yes

Sat is normally preachy

 

[KarlaKGB]

maybe if i post, ur post will show up cuz i cant see it for some reason

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok there it is. i mean hes had that preachy style since the beginning. hence why i said it wasnt related to any sort of read i have on him

 

[Ashtot]

Make me King, because I'll Lynch scum.

 

[N e s s]

General thoughts post coming up later today

 

[oath2order]

Make me King, because I'll Lynch scum.

Tom got made king

Plz read

 

[glow]

Make me King, because I'll Lynch scum.

you haven't read anything that's been posted the last several hours. thats kinda scummy
and you said I'm scum just bc I agreed with someone so uh

 

[Meg-Mog]

Sorry Lords and Ladies (and Others) of the court, I was held up by very important matters. I say All hail to King Tom and his almighty wisdom.

 

[glow]

Sorry Lords and Ladies (and Others) of the court, I was held up by very important matters. I say All hail to King Tom and his almighty wisdom.

Well Tom shouldn't just be voting by himself he should let the rest of town have a say in it. I know it's D1 but still

 

[Chris]

orange goo returns.​

Good day, good day and good morning to thee!



Goodness no! I don't wish to be king! Hath you even thought of thy ungodly rule that shall'th set forth?
By the divines.. I must refuse

Please drop this. I'm guessing this way of typing is something to do with the theme (I'm not familiar with Game of Thrones) but so far all eight of your posts have just been this old-timey fluff that makes it look like you're contributing to the game when really you've said nothing at all.

I need to do another re-read in a bit. My brain kind of turned to sludge between Kit and weeny's posts.

 

[Sataric]

I am naturally pretty preachy and annoying in these games, I'm afraid. I feel like sometimes it can be very useful to provoke a strong reaction from someone in Mafia as it tends to make people start talking and give you a much clearer picture of where they stand and what they feel. Furthermore I think it can be a useful way to make a bigger target out of yourself if you do not hold a very important role.

sataric's challenge on karla kinda rubs me the wrong way; it seems like he was just challenging him for the purposes of trying to find a legitimate reason early on to lynch karla, i guess? idk it's hard to put into words

granted, one can take this as a challenge to sataric attempting to put him down
i'll say right now that i would have no reason to put sataric down, or at least afaik as mafia

I never implied that I wanted to lynch Karla. Currently I have not gotten any truly scummy vibes from him, though he is hard for me to read. I merely disagreed with what he said earlier on - The townies are indeed important in this game but this early on I would never put them in front of the blue roles. Blue roles might be completely unique were as we have several townies for sure. Later in the game, if we lose many townies, we might have to reconsider.

Still waiting to hear something from Tom. His input is very important right now. But I feel that there's way too many players sitting comfortably in silence. It's a bit early to call people out for it but so far I think that there's too many passive players and even though it's day 1 that won't do us any good.

 

[glow]

@the 8 other people in this thread

sup??

- - - Post Merge - - -

(I mean the ones not posting btw)

 

[Ashtot]

You should lynch m3ow, I guarantee that they are scum.

 

[Damniel]

Honestly, I just think weeny was a troll and didn't care about what they did. But they did say they were Mafia so either it was to throw the game or just lack of caring play smartly as scum and just wanted to mess around. But I'd wait on seeing how their replacement plays befor executing them.

Kit's old English is pretty hard to read and I'm hoping it's a joke and you don't continue because I'd just ignore what you say.

I find Trojans actual attempt at playing really odd. He doesn't do much(if anything) in previous games, and him
Just all of the sudden questioning weird.

Trundle's lack of saying anything now is starting to seem off to me.

 

[glow]

You should lynch m3ow, I guarantee that they are scum.

lmao
would you like to elaborate on this?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Honestly, I just think weeny was a troll and didn't care about what they did. But they did say they were Mafia so either it was to throw the game or just lack of caring play smartly as scum and just wanted to mess around. But I'd wait on seeing how their replacement plays befor executing them.

Kit's old English is pretty hard to read and I'm hoping it's a joke and you don't continue because I'd just ignore what you say.

I find Trojans actual attempt at playing really odd. He doesn't do much(if anything) in previous games, and him
Just all of the sudden questioning weird.

Trundle's lack of saying anything now is starting to seem off to me.

I highly doubt weeny is mafia. I'm 99% sure that was a troll act. just read through their posts

 

[EpicGamer12]

Yeah true, hopefully King Tom leads us to victory haha

This post is weird but I'll get back to it later in the game if I'm not dead because it's Tom

- - - Post Merge - - -

sataric's challenge was weak as hell which i find pretty scummy. on an unrelated note to the game, his preachy tone in his posts annoys me the most

I don't think it's scummy at all. You have always thought him to be preachy and lacking of conviction when you're playing with him regardless of his alignment.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Honestly, I just think weeny was a troll and didn't care about what they did. But they did say they were Mafia so either it was to throw the game or just lack of caring play smartly as scum and just wanted to mess around. But I'd wait on seeing how their replacement plays befor executing them.

Kit's old English is pretty hard to read and I'm hoping it's a joke and you don't continue because I'd just ignore what you say.

I find Trojans actual attempt at playing really odd. He doesn't do much(if anything) in previous games, and him
Just all of the sudden questioning weird.

Trundle's lack of saying anything now is starting to seem off to me.

wooooololololo I actually have class and a life just like the beginning of Ness' mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -

Here is just a quick chime in even though I am not going to post anything substantial until I have my laptop in 7 hours: Ashtot was made King in Tom's kingmaker and had a gut feeling he went with Day 1and lynched scum. His early reads are a lot more valuable than you think. He is incredible at reads. He can pick me off as scum in my first few posts easy, and I've seen him do it with a lot more people than myself.

 

[Trojan]

This post is weird but I'll get back to it later in the game if I'm not dead because it's Tom

- - - Post Merge - - -



I don't think it's scummy at all. You have always thought him to be preachy and lacking of conviction when you're playing with him regardless of his alignment.

- - - Post Merge - - -



wooooololololo I actually have class and a life just like the beginning of Ness' mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -

Here is just a quick chime in even though I am not going to post anything substantial until I have my laptop in 7 hours: Ashtot was made King in Tom's kingmaker and had a gut feeling he went with Day 1and lynched scum. His early reads are a lot more valuable than you think. He is incredible at reads. He can pick me off as scum in my first few posts easy, and I've seen him do it with a lot more people than myself.

So you're praising Ashtot now?

 

[oath2order]

Trundle and ashtot scum?

 

[glow]

This post is weird but I'll get back to it later in the game if I'm not dead because it's Tom

meg-mog posted the same thing pretty much?? why is that weird but not hers

Sorry Lords and Ladies (and Others) of the court, I was held up by very important matters. I say All hail to King Tom and his almighty wisdom.

I don't get why people do not read before posting opinions

Here is just a quick chime in even though I am not going to post anything substantial until I have my laptop in 7 hours: Ashtot was made King in Tom's kingmaker and had a gut feeling he went with Day 1and lynched scum. His early reads are a lot more valuable than you think. He is incredible at reads. He can pick me off as scum in my first few posts easy, and I've seen him do it with a lot more people than myself.

so far on the m3ow case we have

* me agreeing with Ayaya + not making a 10/10 scumhunting post 2-3 hours into the game
* gut feelings

if someone would like to make an actual case against me lmk

 

[Trojan]

I dont think there is really a reason to make a case against you

 

[KarlaKGB]

1. ashtot day 1 lynched scum in one game = epic sample size. nobody can reliably deduce someone as scum on the first day
2. tom is already king so why are ppl still talking about who shud be king