Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[oath2order]

Question: How does everyone feel on Beary? 3DSfan? I'd like answers from all remaining players on this one.

Why am I asking? Because there's no method or reason to her ways, despite we imploring her to sit back and learn. She throws people under the bus because of gut feelings (I have those too, but I will find small reasons to back it up). She was as sporadic as 3DSfan in the previous game before his lynch and it's only day one. As much as I'd rather focus on inactives like 3DSfan, this kind of activity is only harmful to us the town in the long run. I've talked with our elected officials and they all confirm talking with Beary via PM, something they deny. Nothing wrong with being in talks with our officials, but there is something wrong with completely denying it to everyone. So unless both officials are complete scum, then beary has something to hide or is truly a bad player.

I point out 3DSfan, only because they haven't said anything since sign up but have voted Day One and called it at that. However they've been very active elsewhere, prompting suspicion on my end. You think he could contribute just a tiny bit here, much like Horus, enough to save themselves.

Beary was a lynch candidate yesterday. I felt they did a mediocre job of a defense, though I feel as if it is only because they are new.

I currently don't have an official list. I do have suspicions, but nobody is like "THIS IS WHO I WILL VOTE."

 

[iLoveYou]

I feel like, with Beary509 it's a very hit or miss situation.

She's seems like a new player (that is what her posts scream to me), and she's making a bunch of mistakes that make her look suspicious. I want to believe she is one of the Town players but is making awful mistakes to dig herself a bigger hole each time again. There is really no way to defend her any more than that. None of her posts can really even be used to support her case.

If the majority of voters for Day 2 lynching wants to set Beary509 to be lynched then I most likely will not pardon her lynch. We still have a lot of time to decide on who will be lynched, but if it is her then my mind is pretty much decided on not to pardon.

I am still looking into 3DSFan134. I literally have no opinion on this person. They are very inactive in this game. Complete opposite to Beary509.

 

[Prof Gallows]

Voted Beary based on my looking back at previous posts.

Much like everyone else, the posts to me looked pretty suspicious. And other than a couple of other posts from other people Beary is the only person that sticks out the most to me. I would have made a fancy elaborate post with quotes and stuff but I don't really feel it was needed.

 

[unravel]

Now people think that beary is suspicious because how she post and you can see how she act well I do understand that she is newbie. (To beary and newbies) next time you should give an evidence that why he or she is suspicious well you can't just say that this person is suspicious because you feel that he or she is suspicious. You should give a solid evidence and explain it.

It's okay not all of us are perfect .___.

- - - Post Merge - - -

There is a huge chance that Beary will be lynch on Day 2

 

[BlueLeaf]

My thoughts on beary: I don't suspect her of being new, rather the reason being is that she goes with the flow without reason. She even mentioned bandwagoning because "everyone else is." I don't suspect her of mafia, but she definitely has something to hide. Either that or she's just inexperienced and slipping up. She's digging her own grave, slowly and s l o w l y. I understand that she is a new player, but even an experienced player wouldn't say they're bandwagoning because everyone else is. Her posts are my evidence, from the voting thread to slip-ups to useless posts.

My thoughts on 3DSFan: Good thing you mentioned him. I think he got left behind after Night 1. I honestly forgot about him a while ago. If he turns out to be an important blue role, everyone will definitely be mad. I don't really think much of him. He probably forgot.

If Beary makes another mistake, then we need to question her and tell her to defend herself better. If she doesn't defend herself or keeps slipping up, I will most likely vote for her unless something super fishy happens from someone else.

 

[Prof Gallows]

Now people think that beary is suspicious because how she post and you can see how she act well I do understand that she is newbie. (To beary and newbies) next time you should give an evidence that why he or she is suspicious well you can't just say that this person is suspicious because you feel that he or she is suspicious. You should give a solid evidence and explain it.

It's okay not all of us are perfect .___.

- - - Post Merge - - -

There is a huge chance that Beary will be lynch on Day 2

I really think that posting obvious things like "There is a huge chance etc etc" is kinda pointless. =p

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Now people think that beary is suspicious because how she post and you can see how she act well I do understand that she is newbie. (To beary and newbies) next time you should give an evidence that why he or she is suspicious well you can't just say that this person is suspicious because you feel that he or she is suspicious. You should give a solid evidence and explain it.

It's okay not all of us are perfect .___.

- - - Post Merge - - -

There is a huge chance that Beary will be lynch on Day 2

While I do have a gut feeling on Beary, it's the way she acts that has me worried. She might as well be a non-contributor, as nothing of use has come from questioning her and I'm not terribly sure things will pickup from here on. If she can prove we can truly trust her and she can prove reasons as to why talking to our officials is something she wanted to hide, I will gladly cast my ballot for a lurker.

 

[unravel]

While I do have a gut feeling on Beary, it's the way she acts that has me worried. She might as well be a non-contributor, as nothing of use has come from questioning her and I'm not terribly sure things will pickup from here on. If she can prove we can truly trust her and she can prove reasons as to why talking to our officials is something she wanted to hide, I will gladly cast my ballot for a lurker.

Well yeah she doesn't contribute and she talks non-sense such as this:

>.> Horus
You naughty naughty
Editin things

I'm not so sure about 3DSFan I will re-read this thread again

 

[Hikari]

@Beary
Seeing as a bandwagon is starting for you, would you like to defend yourself? I want to hear your defence before I start voting.

 

[BellGreen]

I feel like beary509 will just cause more trouble for herself with her useless spamming. I don't think she'll get to the point where she actually contributes something good without spamming. Her reasoning to everything doesn't make sense. Would you really vote and say that you voted for XXXX just because everyone else does and you don't know what to do?
I know she's a new player and she's getting used to this but...

Spoiler: Collection of Spam

IM A GIRL PPL

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, sorry for my inactivity today, as I has to go get shots ._.

- - - Post Merge - - -

PITY ME

Horus has posted a might 5 TIMES!!!!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Mighty *

>.> Horus
You naughty naughty
Editin things

Can ANY humor be implemented into constant murder?!?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yes.

I'm reading through the first mafia, and it was much more relaxed and humorous, and seemed more enjoyable

I feel like beary509 should start defending herself. She's getting nowhere and it would be a shame to lose another blue role

 

[unravel]

I feel like beary509 will just cause more trouble for herself with her useless spamming. I don't think she'll get to the point where she actually contributes something good without spamming. Her reasoning to everything doesn't make sense. Would you really vote and say that you voted for XXXX just because everyone else does and you don't know what to do?
I know she's a new player and she's getting used to this but...


I feel like beary509 should start defending herself. She's getting nowhere and it would be a shame to lose another blue role

Exactly not only that don't forget 3DSFan he ONLY posted 3 times (was looking at his profile to make it more easier)

Spoiler: He only post this

I'M SIGNING UP!

I'll try to NOT do that revenge voting like I've did in the first one.

I'm hoping to not be a townie again.

He should say something about this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

* I mean He should say something that why is he inactive in game

 

[Midoriya]

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but isn't the mayor the only one who votes? I may have missed something though so I'm not sure.

 

[radical6]

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but isn't the mayor the only one who votes? I may have missed something though so I'm not sure.

thats only on day one

 

[Midoriya]

thats only on day one

Wow, how did I miss this. Okay then, thank you.

 

[oath2order]

I hate to start the bandwagon, but the 3DSfan thing is very suspicious.

I'm hoping to not be a townie again.

In my opinion, but in my mind, I read this as "I want to be mafia." The statement, coupled with inactivity, leads me to believe that he is a townie, and disgruntled with the fact.

 

[Midoriya]

For awhile part of me has thought Beary is just a new player, and part of me thinks they're actually suspicious. For right now I'm voting for Beary since there could be something more about her that's hidden, but if she posts a good defense then I might change my vote.

 

[unravel]

I hate to start the bandwagon, but the 3DSfan thing is very suspicious.

I'm hoping to not be a townie again.

In my opinion, but in my mind, I read this as "I want to be mafia." The statement, coupled with inactivity, leads me to believe that he is a townie, and disgruntled with the fact.

I'm not sure about this well for me somethings not right about 3DSFan because he is inactive (I have to re-read the post again and again)

And about this quote

I'm hoping to not be a townie again.

I'm not sure if he wants to be Mafia or not, well what if he is a mafia? We don't have a solid proof that 3DSFan is a mafia. Now my question is did he (3DSFan) post something in day 1? I haven't seen him posting in night 1 and day 2. I'm sure he will be modkill tomorrow because he didn't post so yeah.

 

[TheCreeperHugz]

Wow, just woke up to find 3 town dead, including one blue role.
This really isn't going too well, though I'm not sure what happened to the last KP.

As for my thoughts on Beary, I think she is probably a townie and is just quite bad at this game due to being new. Though there is a chance she is mafia, and I may vote for her, depending on how others act.
Even if she is a townie, the spam posts aren't really helping us...

 

[radical6]

Wow, just woke up to find 3 town dead, including one blue role.
This really isn't going too well, though I'm not sure what happened to the last KP.

As for my thoughts on Beary, I think she is probably a townie and is just quite bad at this game due to being new. Though there is a chance she is mafia, and I may vote for her, depending on how others act.
Even if she is a townie, the spam posts aren't really helping us...

again, they probably hit someone who was protected by a medic/veteran.

i wont vote for beary...yet. tbh shes just a newbie. i feel like if she was mafia, someone in the mafia chat wouldve at least scolded her and helped her out. i would like to see how she responds to all this, but ill make my mind up tomorrow when i wake up i guess.

 

[TheCreeperHugz]

again, they probably hit someone who was protected by a medic/veteran.

i wont vote for beary...yet. tbh shes just a newbie. i feel like if she was mafia, someone in the mafia chat wouldve at least scolded her and helped her out. i would like to see how she responds to all this, but ill make my mind up tomorrow when i wake up i guess.

Wouldn't that then look really suspicious as she would suddenly improve her posts?