Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

[EpicGamer12]

I've pointed this out earlier in the game, and a full ELEVEN people (no, i am not fabricating this) were viewing the thread at the time. If there were ANY mafia online (which is highly likely) then Kippla would have been targeted night one. Sure, they could have left him alive and designated one of their number to point it out (yes, i know I pointed it out, don't accuse me of being mafia because of this logic) but I serverly doubt considering that they would have an easy blue kill.

This is actually a decent point, which is strange coming from you. Although this point does have its flaws (like all points), if Kippla pointed out her role as a good, useful role, the mafia may have decided to take her out, assuming she was blue (because she said earlier that townie was boring until Karla corrected her). At the same time, it was just one simple post that's causing so much difficulty. Kippla stated that she was "a bit disappointed", but if she had have gotten a blue role, she definitely wouldn't have said that. Also, if she were mafia, she could be saying that in order to make it seem like she is a townie, as she roleclaimed later.

Basically, I didn't want to leave this post left as a completely solid point, and explore every angle that Kippla could have been coming from.

 

[Horus]

Hey guys, so if you couldn't tell;


2:05:29 PM <Horus> tbh, bored of forum mafia
2:05:43 PM <Horus> can mafia just shoot me or something
2:05:47 PM <Tom29193> Great post walls
2:05:54 PM <Tom29193> And how can you be bored
2:05:59 PM <Tom29193? You just sit there and post memes
2:06:17 PM <Horus> READING AIN'T FUN
2:06:24 PM <Horus> Y U ADD ME TO THIS TOM
2:06:32 PM <Tom29193> Reading Rainbow says otherwise
2:06:32 PM <VillageDweller> horus ty i was bored
2:06:34 PM <VillageDweller> then i died!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2:06:39 PM <VillageDweller> or got lynched same thing
2:06:40 PM <Tom29193> Kayla said you wanted in
2:06:54 PM <Horus> Honestly, never said that lol
2:07:02 PM <Tom29193> o
2:07:02 PM <VillageDweller> kayla wants an excuse to add ppl
2:07:07 PM <Horus> I'll continue though
2:07:07 PM <Tom29193> Blame Kayla then
2:07:17 PM <VillageDweller> don't b me and give up!!!!
2:07:24 PM <Horus> I'll go spend time out of my glorious day for this

Yeah so I'll continue for the sake of Reading Rainbow, though as Karla has said I don't really make any posts that matter here which is 100% true. Like, going through 3 different mafia games looking for each individual posts of certain people and then making a 700 word post about it is like a book report to me so this will probably be my last forum mafia game. Anyway, I'll see what I can do about my posts.

Right. so I think we're still talking about Dolby and CreeperHugz

CreeperHugz: Pretty much abandoned Mafia and is pretty much a waste of space on town, but at least she's just one more person the Mafia will have to kill right?

Dolby: So Dolby is having some issues with roleclaiming, apparently he denied being a Bus Driver but now he says he is, right after he failed to accomplish Karla's instruction. Additionally, it's rare to have two Bus Drivers.

Personally, I think I'm going to be voting Dolby unless something new comes to light. That's really suspicious and I don't see much of a reason not to.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Spoiler

Hey guys, so if you couldn't tell;


2:05:29 PM <Horus> tbh, bored of forum mafia
2:05:43 PM <Horus> can mafia just shoot me or something
2:05:47 PM <Tom29193> Great post walls
2:05:54 PM <Tom29193> And how can you be bored
2:05:59 PM <Tom29193? You just sit there and post memes
2:06:17 PM <Horus> READING AIN'T FUN
2:06:24 PM <Horus> Y U ADD ME TO THIS TOM
2:06:32 PM <Tom29193> Reading Rainbow says otherwise
2:06:32 PM <VillageDweller> horus ty i was bored
2:06:34 PM <VillageDweller> then i died!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2:06:39 PM <VillageDweller> or got lynched same thing
2:06:40 PM <Tom29193> Kayla said you wanted in
2:06:54 PM <Horus> Honestly, never said that lol
2:07:02 PM <Tom29193> o
2:07:02 PM <VillageDweller> kayla wants an excuse to add ppl
2:07:07 PM <Horus> I'll continue though
2:07:07 PM <Tom29193> Blame Kayla then
2:07:17 PM <VillageDweller> don't b me and give up!!!!
2:07:24 PM <Horus> I'll go spend time out of my glorious day for this

Yeah so I'll continue for the sake of Reading Rainbow, though as Karla has said I don't really make any posts that matter here which is 100% true. Like, going through 3 different mafia games looking for each individual posts of certain people and then making a 700 word post about it is like a book report to me so this will probably be my last forum mafia game. Anyway, I'll see what I can do about my posts.

Right. so I think we're still talking about Dolby and CreeperHugz

CreeperHugz: Pretty much abandoned Mafia and is pretty much a waste of space on town, but at least she's just one more person the Mafia will have to kill right?

Dolby: So Dolby is having some issues with roleclaiming, apparently he denied being a Bus Driver but now he says he is, right after he failed to accomplish Karla's instruction. Additionally, it's rare to have two Bus Drivers.

Personally, I think I'm going to be voting Dolby unless something new comes to light. That's really suspicious and I don't see much of a reason not to.

- - - Post Merge - - -

In all seriousness though, I don't read through the old games, I just filter for the posts of the relevant people.

- - - Post Merge - - -

like this

 

[KarlaKGB]

Chatting with Tina on Mumble about suspects, and we looked at the election voting list on the first day.

Spoiler: End of election votelist

KarlaKGB ( 7 )
BowserFanGurl1999
SuperPenguin
Dolby
pallycake
BellBringerGreen
kerryelizabeth
oath2order

VillageDweller ( 3 )
Kuma
FoxWolf64
DeviousCrossing

River ( 2 )
River
Horus
MyLifeIsCake

Trundle (16)
KarlaKGB
Trundle
Justin
Farobi
Blueleaf
Kippla
LaurinaMN
Hikari
Chris.
tsundere
VillagerDweller
SlaughterShy
Klinkguin
TheCreeperHugz
Tina
beary509

Blu Rose (1)
Blu Rose (still)

FireNinja1 ( 1 )
FireNinja1

LaurinaMN
lynn105

Gandalf, Thunder, and Pikasweet did not vote but will not be modkilled due to error on my part. Final count per request.

So the players that voted for VD were Kuma, Foxwolf and Devious. I believe Kuma is innocent. Foxwolf and Devious have flipped Townie and Miller respectively. So that is a list of innocents. What if we look at people who hopped? Rewind about 20 hours:

Spoiler: Mid-day votelist

Updating the votes. <3
Correct me if I'm wrong. Should be right though. {:

KarlaKGB ( 7 )
BowserFanGurl1999
SuperPenguin
Dolby ( Please use ##unvote next time <3 )
pallycake
Beary509
BellBringerGreen
kerryelizabeth

VillageDweller ( 5 )
Kuma
Kippla
Hikari
FoxWolf64
BlueLeaf

River ( 2 )
River
Horus

Trundle ( 2 )
KarlaKGB
Trundle

Blu Rose ( 1 )
Blu Rose

FireNinja1 ( 1 )
FireNinja1

DeviousCrossing ( 1 )
DeviousCrossing

So we see that Kippla and Blueleaf both hopped off. Blueleaf was Assassin, but Kippla is under suspicion. Really, all of this tells us nothing. Instead, Tina raised the excellent point of looking at the Trundle votes towards the end of the election.

Trundle (16)
KarlaKGB
Trundle
Justin
Farobi
Blueleaf
Kippla
LaurinaMN
Hikari
Chris.
tsundere
VillagerDweller
SlaughterShy
Klinkguin
TheCreeperHugz
Tina
beary509

The highlighted names are the ones of interest. We have VD and Slaughtershy, both confirmed Mafia now. Let's look at the timing of the votes.
VD at 8.25PM
Slaughtershy at 8.51pm
Klinkguin at 8.56pm
TheCreeperHugz at 8.59pm

Anyone else thinks this looks like a coordinated agreement in Mafia chat to jump off the sinking VD ship and stack onto Trundle? Given CreeperHuz's suspicion already, I am sticking with my vote for her. Klinkguin, who's been lurking, and who told me in PM that

I don't post because it causes lots of discussion. It might even cause arguments and I don't like arguing

is probably going to be modkilled.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Well then... I'm going to switch my vote for TheCreeperHugz. Maybe he/she will eventually get on and give a defense sometime?

 

[KarlaKGB]

I don't post because it causes lots of discussion. It might even cause arguments and I don't like arguing

Also, does anyone else smell the scumminess from this?

What group of player does not like discussion?

Who really does not like arguing, because they know that they are defending a guilty case?

Mafia

 

[Dolby]

Also, does anyone else smell the scumminess from this?

What group of player does not like discussion?

Who really does not like arguing, because they know that they are defending a guilty case?

Mafia

Totally agree with you there, right now i think that we should discuss using a double-lynch

 

[Superpenguin]

Totally agree with you there, right now i think that we should discuss using a double-lynch

Te mayor has to declare it the day before. So if we want to use a Double lynch, the earliest that we can have it will be at tomorrows lynch.

 

[Elijo]

Also, does anyone else smell the scumminess from this?

What group of player does not like discussion?

Who really does not like arguing, because they know that they are defending a guilty case?

Mafia

I honestly agree with this, however, wouldn't that mean that lurkers could possibly be a future suspect? They don't bring information worthy enough to bring discussions or arguments. They may also have nothing to say, but that is just my theory.

For now, I am going to vote Klinkguin.

 

[Beary]

I'm using my vote for Klinkguin as well.
Some things just can't have excuses.

 

[Horus]

like this

Wat, I don't even know how to do that. Share your secrets with me

 

[Blu Rose]

Well, I guess I'm going to vote for CreeperHugz...

Everybody produced really convincing evidence.

 

[BungoTheElf]

Ahh sorry guys, kinda forgot about this a bit D:

So, basically right now the main suspect is TheCreeperHugz? From reading, I'm pretty sure TheCreeperHugz is more in suspicion now, due to to her not posting after her vote on VD, She has last been on TBT at 2:25 est time for me and her last post was 2 days ago.. I feel like she might be mafia, but she hasn't posted anything or what so ever to defend herself in the last few days

UGhhh I feel like I'm becoming a bandwagoner if I vote for her though.. Other than that I think Klinguin is another suspect due to lack of posts and not wanting to post , but at this point I feel like both will be mod-killed. I want to think about my vote a little longer before I decide who to vote on.

 

[oath2order]

Ahh sorry guys, kinda forgot about this a bit D:

So, basically right now the main suspect is TheCreeperHugz? From reading, I'm pretty sure TheCreeperHugz is more in suspicion now, due to to her not posting after her vote on VD, She has last been on TBT at 2:25 est time for me and her last post was 2 days ago.. I feel like she might be mafia, but she hasn't posted anything or what so ever to defend herself in the last few days

UGhhh I feel like I'm becoming a bandwagoner if I vote for her though.. Other than that I think Klinguin is another suspect due to lack of posts and not wanting to post , but at this point I feel like both will be mod-killed. I want to think about my vote a little longer before I decide who to vote on.

Five hours, lynn, you've got five hours before modkill.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anybody else not vote?

 

[KarlaKGB]

Why are people voting Klinkguin over Creeperhugz? The case against Creeper is much more solid, plus Klinkguin is likely to get modkilled anyways in a few hours.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

I voted for TCH, because she has too much evidence and a solid case against her. It's silly to vote for Klink, as they will be modkilled if they don't post. Kill two birds with one stone.

 

[Laurina]

We have VD and Slaughtershy, both confirmed Mafia now. Let's look at the timing of the votes.
VD at 8.25PM
Slaughtershy at 8.51pm
Klinkguin at 8.56pm
TheCreeperHugz at 8.59pm

Anyone else thinks this looks like a coordinated agreement in Mafia chat to jump off the sinking VD ship and stack onto Trundle? Given CreeperHuz's suspicion already, I am sticking with my vote for her. Klinkguin, who's been lurking, and who told me in PM that
is probably going to be modkilled.

I decided to put my vote in for TheCreeperHugz. What Tina and Karla mentioned above has a big part in it. I believe she's a bit too jumpy with her decisions and a bit of unsure of what side she's trying to show us she's on. First she votes for VillageDweller, then she votes for Trundle because "he is good at spotting mafia". Then when there's good evidence against the VD case she denies it and says that Trundle is the suspicious one. After that blows over and once everyone is against VillageDweller she decided to jump right probably hoping to blend in just like the election and the VillageDweller lynch.

It looks like both TheCreeperHugz & Klinkguin are up for a modkill if they don't get their votes in.

 

[Chris.]

The highlighted names are the ones of interest. We have VD and Slaughtershy, both confirmed Mafia now. Let's look at the timing of the votes.
VD at 8.25PM
Slaughtershy at 8.51pm
Klinkguin at 8.56pm
TheCreeperHugz at 8.59pm

Above is the main reason I'm casting my vote for CreeperHugz. It's too big for 4 people to change votes that close together to be a coincidence. With 2 of the 4being confirmed mafia now, and Klink being modkilled if they don't post, it seems like the best choice is to vote for Creeper.

 

[Beary]

Above is the main reason I'm casting my vote for CreeperHugz. It's too big for 4 people to change votes that close together to be a coincidence. With 2 of the 4being confirmed mafia now, and Klink being modkilled if they don't post, it seems like the best choice is to vote for Creeper.

I think I will change my vote to Creeper. They both may be modkilled anyways.

 

[BellGreen]

Switched my vote to Hugz.
I hope Justin votes soon!