-
Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.
Mafia TBT Mafia IX: The Apocalypse [Game Over/Town Win]
- Thread starter Laurina
- Start date
Anybody want to explain why so many people jumped on the Waffles bandwagon after little to no evidence against her was posted? Am I missing something or are people just grabbing?
Also, this is a supernatural mafia, not a GoT mafia, you should pay more attention
Also, this is a supernatural mafia, not a GoT mafia, you should pay more attention
Anybody want to explain why so many people jumped on the Waffles bandwagon after little to no evidence against her was posted? Am I missing something or are people just grabbing?
Also, this is a supernatural mafia, not a GoT mafia, you should pay more attention
You go ahead and be suspicious of me, then. I'm not even going to bother. Whatever information you have, you did not get from me, because I have not been PMing you, and what you've heard is clearly not accurate. That being said, your entire previous post in which you said that "Sometimes I think you (Sataric) feed people bad information" doesn't really make any sense. That's all I have to say about the matter.
Why doesn't it make sense?
You've been fishing for information from everyone, except not giving much in return. Just because I'm not in contact with you, does not mean that I'm not in contact with anybody else. I do, however know, that Needle died from a mafia hit, and I'm looking at a very select few people who actually knew his role in the first place.
You've been fishing for information from everyone, except not giving much in return. Just because I'm not in contact with you, does not mean that I'm not in contact with anybody else. I do, however know, that Needle died from a mafia hit, and I'm looking at a very select few people who actually knew his role in the first place.
I will explain in very simple terms why it doesn't make sense:
You and I have not been talking in private. Everything we've said to one another is in this thread for all to see. Yet you claim that I have been giving people false information. You base this on things you've heard from OTHER PEOPLE. Thus, logically, you've been getting false information from other people, yet you assume that the fault lies with me. That doesn't add up. They could have told you anything, and said "Sataric said this" or "Sataric did that" - But you've never asked me to confirm anything. Maybe you should be pointing the finger at someone else, if you think about it for a second..
And the fact that you think I have not been giving much in return for the information I've gotten is completely false - But it's true that I haven't given you anything, as I stated above. That's because I don't know if I can trust you; It does not mean that I have not shared my information with other people that I felt I could rely on and that could add value to the Town team.
Princess
bunny enthusiast
Just wanted to bring up some things. I'm posting this now since day is pretty short. I'm awaiting a reply from one of my suspects.
Sataric
Why?
We've been trying to work together, but instead of being cooperative he has only tried to suck information from anyone. The most information he has ever been willing to share is two roles. His own and Feeloreena's (sp?) he wouldn't even specify who's role is who. Sure I can easily guess, but he hasn't been up front at all. All through out the thread he's been pointing fingers and as soon as he talks to the person he suspects he says oh nvm they're good.
Why are they good? Why are you storing all this information and not even helping town?
My second suspect is Tom (sorry bb)
Tom has had two different role claims, vig and vet. When I came to Tom about being suspicious of Jubs for claiming the same role as him (one-shot vig), Tom waved it off. However, as soon as BlueLeaf claimed one-shot, Tom switched to vig.
He also implied a DT roleclaim through this thread.
Also, Trundle, River, Tom and I had a group which figured out Gallows' was lying and all of us were the only people who knew Needle's (rip) role.
But tbh I don't know if the last part counts as much, considering I was targeting too last night. Maybe mafia wanted to a couple type kill idk.
Also, I let Sat know this already, but I'll try to grab what I said to him, I've been counting up the roles, and there's way too many baker claims.
In conclusion, I'm leaning towards Sataric at the moment.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh god the errors, sorry on my phone.
Sataric
Why?
We've been trying to work together, but instead of being cooperative he has only tried to suck information from anyone. The most information he has ever been willing to share is two roles. His own and Feeloreena's (sp?) he wouldn't even specify who's role is who. Sure I can easily guess, but he hasn't been up front at all. All through out the thread he's been pointing fingers and as soon as he talks to the person he suspects he says oh nvm they're good.
Why are they good? Why are you storing all this information and not even helping town?
My second suspect is Tom (sorry bb)
Tom has had two different role claims, vig and vet. When I came to Tom about being suspicious of Jubs for claiming the same role as him (one-shot vig), Tom waved it off. However, as soon as BlueLeaf claimed one-shot, Tom switched to vig.
He also implied a DT roleclaim through this thread.
Also, Trundle, River, Tom and I had a group which figured out Gallows' was lying and all of us were the only people who knew Needle's (rip) role.
But tbh I don't know if the last part counts as much, considering I was targeting too last night. Maybe mafia wanted to a couple type kill idk.
Also, I let Sat know this already, but I'll try to grab what I said to him, I've been counting up the roles, and there's way too many baker claims.
In conclusion, I'm leaning towards Sataric at the moment.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh god the errors, sorry on my phone.
@ PallyCake - I admit that my tactic of calling people out in the thread as suspicious was quite a cheap way to gather information from people that perhaps would have preferred to keep their roles a secret for a while longer, but even if it was quite an aggressive and sometimes slightly mean way of making progress, it was very very successful and that is what truly matters at the end of the day. The people I called out have forgiven me for it (And I did apologize to more or less every single one of them in PM's, by the way!) and it did lead to good cooperation and a brighter future for us all. The reason you don't know what I've told to many other players is simply because I thought you'd like the information to River, whom I'm not sure if I can trust. That is all. Everyone else pretty much knows everything that I know..
I don't think it's Sataric or Tom. Waffles may have just been unlucky with his defense of two mafia, but either way, I think we should play it safe for now. I think we should stick to lynching MissNoodle or Waffles. If some of you trust Waffles, I'd say we should change to MissNoodle. Let's not get too confused with all these accusations though. A lot of them don't add up. And if Waffles or MissNoodle are actually bakers, then that may be unfortunate for them, but it won't be a big deal for us because it will only narrow our choices.
I agree - I will change my vote to MissNoodle because there's no counter-claims for Waffles saving Trundle on Day 1 in circulation anymore. It's a pretty safe bet. Still a slight gamble of course but you and I are hardly the only two people who have felt the scummy vibes coming from that direction. Many trusted people have told me throughout the day in PMs that it'd be their first choice for the lynch today.
Hold that thought - Guess I will wait a short moment until BlueLeaf has sorted out the snag with Tom, and shared whatever else may be on his mind. There is still no rush. But I feel like MissNoodle should come before Waffles now.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Well, I knew all along. I must've heard it from someone else. I've sent you a PM to clear up the confusion and to clear my name.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Well, I knew all along. I must've heard it from someone else. I've sent you a PM to clear up the confusion and to clear my name.
I will change my vote from ITookYourWaffles since there is no other claims of giving bread on Day 1 to Trundle (I apologise Waffles, I was told Yui Z gave bread as well but I see that has all been cleared up now). I support a lynch on MissNoodle. Many people have brought up her name and she still hasn't posted anything to clear it. She's also someone who has roleclaimed Baker (which as I have posted before we have far too many claims to), and has been staying rather quiet and not adding very much to the game. That gives off scummy vibes to me!
I know that I'm very cranky today but frankly, I don't care. I think you are scum and I am going to vote for you. Nothing you say adds up and your plea in a PM does nothing for you because I trust Tom and Pally fully before I trust somebody I do not even know.
*Sighs..* You really ought to chose your words more carefully. You cannot claim that "Nothing I say adds up" when in fact everything I say adds up and I've been telling the truth all along, and after the game round is over and won (or lost), and all roles are revealed, and I can put all cards on the table face up, then you'll be able to see that for yourself as well. Also, and this is really quite ironic, but I sent all my information to Tom (among many others). I find it super amusing that he didn't leak anything to you, seeing as you seem to think that you're "on his team" or something along those lines. But that was well played on his part because you look scummier and scummier for each fit you throw. I hope everyone I sent my information to keeps it to themselves as I asked, to eliminate the risk of anything falling into the wrong hands.
Wowzers. Okay I'm going to vote for MissNoodle because there's way too many baker claims and she barely even posts or does anything. I had called her out for her inactivity and considered her for a day 1 lynch and used her time zone as an excuse. *surprise surprise* she's been inactive. Surely 1 and a half weeks is long enough to post something that contributes instead if stating the obvious and agreeing with everyone else. So yeah~
If Sataric is scum, why aren't more blues dead? He's basically had every single player in this game claim to him and, if he were scum, it'd pretty stupid not to get rid of all the action roles~
If Sataric is scum, why aren't more blues dead? He's basically had every single player in this game claim to him and, if he were scum, it'd pretty stupid not to get rid of all the action roles~
This. I would expect more Blues to die. And something else ; Sataric claimed a role that would put him in a dangerous spot. If he were Mafia, why would he do this? There was at least one other role that would have been better to claim as. (Not leaking the role, I haven't asked for permission yet).
What I find even scummier about MissNoodle is that she's starting to post a bit in the Mini Mafia but hardly not at all here.
I think you need to get your story straight Pally. I claimed vig to everyone I talked to Day One, only Gallows saw through my charade and called me on it outside the thread. Yes, I defended Justin because I felt the behavior being displayed was similar to that in previous games when he was a vigilante and jack of all trades. When you wanted him dead, I reluctantly agreed. Around the time Blue Leaf claimed to me, I revealed myself as Veteran to you all as it became apparent I was in good company.
I haven't been hit yet which either means someone knows/leaked my role or someone is trying to set me . I welcome a counter claim to my role as John Winchester, the Veteran.
I haven't been hit yet which either means someone knows/leaked my role or someone is trying to set me . I welcome a counter claim to my role as John Winchester, the Veteran.
Let it make me look scummy, I don't care.
I stated all my reasons, I agree with my team mates, and as Tom just said, why hasn't he died yet? When he just told me that you were the one to figure his actual role out in the first place. And clearly, if I was scum, and Tom did infact claim to me on the very first day that he was 1-shot vig, why the frick wouldn't I want to take him out on the first night instead of risking him killing myself or a team mate.
- - - Post Merge - - -
This is exactly why I won't vote for her, because that screams uninterested townie.
I stated all my reasons, I agree with my team mates, and as Tom just said, why hasn't he died yet? When he just told me that you were the one to figure his actual role out in the first place. And clearly, if I was scum, and Tom did infact claim to me on the very first day that he was 1-shot vig, why the frick wouldn't I want to take him out on the first night instead of risking him killing myself or a team mate.
- - - Post Merge - - -
This is exactly why I won't vote for her, because that screams uninterested townie.
