Why are you being a Geoni try hard rn? Seems sus. I trust Harbour is town. Im sus about u as well Punchy
-
The first day of our new Mushroom Season event has passed, but things are just getting started. Read the update about changes made to the schedule, starting with day two. Be careful foraging and good luck! -
Come and see the official gallery showcasing all of your creative entries from The Bell Tree Fair 2024. In addition, the winners for the final raffles have been drawn! Click here for the event's final closing announcement.
Mafia TBT Mafia: Renaissance - Game Thread [ENDGAME - Town Wins]
- Thread starter N e s s
- Start date
- Status
Why are you being a Geoni try hard rn? Seems sus. I trust Harbour is town. Im sus about u as well Punchy
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
god **** this
idk how to play the game when Antonio f11 and panda are all omgus'ing you and you can't do anything about it because they're too stubborn to move their votes
and then mog follows them
lol I'm sorry mog
idk how to play the game when Antonio f11 and panda are all omgus'ing you and you can't do anything about it because they're too stubborn to move their votes
and then mog follows them
lol I'm sorry mog
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
this was my hell yesterday
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
IM NOT ANTONIO's "PARTNER" im not in any mason group... I don't believe his claim.
so you're going to say this in the midst of the whole geoni iso and us two being the wagons? your read kind of contradicts itself.
i'd love for evan/geoni to come back and go into more depth about punchy's playstyle.
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
this one is an old read i will give you that
but my sentiment is the same
you haven't really pushed for a lynch unless you pushed for geoni and i don't think that you did
Geoni
You're doing great!
Honestly? If you guys are -this- hung up on me I need to be solved for you somehow or the rest of the game will go to ****. I think Trundle should be solved via actions tonight because there's people who look really bad if Trundle really was scum after all, namely f11. And Oath is right in saying it and f11 is wrong for being opposed to it just because there 'could be a framer' in this game.
Heyden's move onto Harbour with me is really sketchy and if Harbour is town I was just completely wrong on then Heyden's changing his mind about him as I gained more and more heat just looks bad. Hell, it looks bad even if Harbour -is- scum.
Punchy shouldn't even be considered now but I'm not sure I think any votes on Punchy are scum trying to get him lynched. Scum could be hiding on that, sure, but like I said before his playstyle just rubs people who don't know him the wrong way.
I honestly don't understand why Evan isn't working with the town more on what they want to be focused on as day approaches its end but I think if Evan is scum it doesn't absolve Locket since it could just be a bus but Locket has the 'I'm lost' excuse at the moment and that shouldn't last the entire game. If there's a towny out there that has the energy and wants to be helpful they should summarize the game so far during the night phase for people who haven't caught up still.
Tae could go either way at this point because I feel they really dropped off in terms of giving any reads as day 2 has gone on but I'm almost in a similar boat out of being pissed. Still, that shouldn't be ignored, especially since I didn't have the greatest first impression of them.
glow felt like she was in the least being considerate of me and my Harbour case for a moment even if she disagreed with some of it but she moved onto scumreading me and her EoD isn't the greatest but this could all just be a reflection of her playstyle and personality.
Shaebae seems lost but is sheeping both me and dead town and that shouldn't continue to be excused just because they also come across as lost.
Mog's hammering of Jacob yesterday felt towny enough and if she's scum she's doing a great job but she hasn't provided much in terms of reads outside of seeming to agree with me and I have the right to feel paranoid that this is coming from a place of being TMI. Save her for later though because she can still be set up for a mislynch over this if town.
If tae is also town then don't trust shawo anymore. Don't give the dude any semblance of a lead. But don't just vig shoot him tonight either.
DinoTown just feels there. I'd need the time to reread again but they seem like they're trying? I'm still kind of null on her.
The sudden and recent Punchy train just feels gross idk.
Harbour is just...ugh. My points in the ISO stand but she feels so rand! in joining the Punchy wagon she's tunneled all game and seemed kinda derpy in response to me when I was last around.
Idk about Panda voting Harbour right now and not just wanting to work with town, if she's off wagon on Harbour again by the end of the hour she deserves the sus she gets but I'm just not sold on her yet, maybe because I'm tilted about Heyden.
Those are my legacy reads like I'm sorry but I'm too tired and depressed and it's hard for anyone to trust me for me to have towned good enough here. I'm going to swtich to Heyden though but I'd be willing to resolve Trundle with a lynch if people just want to feel sure about d1, it's really up in the air with him though because I've been so conflicted about him. Typically that's a tell that the person is town but idek. He's def better solved with a check or shot by the vig though if there's one. f11 seemed derpy about the KP but has been on Jacob and now me.
One thing I'm noticing about these legacy reads of mine is that I really shouldn't have townread the Jacob wagon after all and feel **** for wanting to.
Heyden's move onto Harbour with me is really sketchy and if Harbour is town I was just completely wrong on then Heyden's changing his mind about him as I gained more and more heat just looks bad. Hell, it looks bad even if Harbour -is- scum.
Punchy shouldn't even be considered now but I'm not sure I think any votes on Punchy are scum trying to get him lynched. Scum could be hiding on that, sure, but like I said before his playstyle just rubs people who don't know him the wrong way.
I honestly don't understand why Evan isn't working with the town more on what they want to be focused on as day approaches its end but I think if Evan is scum it doesn't absolve Locket since it could just be a bus but Locket has the 'I'm lost' excuse at the moment and that shouldn't last the entire game. If there's a towny out there that has the energy and wants to be helpful they should summarize the game so far during the night phase for people who haven't caught up still.
Tae could go either way at this point because I feel they really dropped off in terms of giving any reads as day 2 has gone on but I'm almost in a similar boat out of being pissed. Still, that shouldn't be ignored, especially since I didn't have the greatest first impression of them.
glow felt like she was in the least being considerate of me and my Harbour case for a moment even if she disagreed with some of it but she moved onto scumreading me and her EoD isn't the greatest but this could all just be a reflection of her playstyle and personality.
Shaebae seems lost but is sheeping both me and dead town and that shouldn't continue to be excused just because they also come across as lost.
Mog's hammering of Jacob yesterday felt towny enough and if she's scum she's doing a great job but she hasn't provided much in terms of reads outside of seeming to agree with me and I have the right to feel paranoid that this is coming from a place of being TMI. Save her for later though because she can still be set up for a mislynch over this if town.
If tae is also town then don't trust shawo anymore. Don't give the dude any semblance of a lead. But don't just vig shoot him tonight either.
DinoTown just feels there. I'd need the time to reread again but they seem like they're trying? I'm still kind of null on her.
The sudden and recent Punchy train just feels gross idk.
Harbour is just...ugh. My points in the ISO stand but she feels so rand! in joining the Punchy wagon she's tunneled all game and seemed kinda derpy in response to me when I was last around.
Idk about Panda voting Harbour right now and not just wanting to work with town, if she's off wagon on Harbour again by the end of the hour she deserves the sus she gets but I'm just not sold on her yet, maybe because I'm tilted about Heyden.
Those are my legacy reads like I'm sorry but I'm too tired and depressed and it's hard for anyone to trust me for me to have towned good enough here. I'm going to swtich to Heyden though but I'd be willing to resolve Trundle with a lynch if people just want to feel sure about d1, it's really up in the air with him though because I've been so conflicted about him. Typically that's a tell that the person is town but idek. He's def better solved with a check or shot by the vig though if there's one. f11 seemed derpy about the KP but has been on Jacob and now me.
One thing I'm noticing about these legacy reads of mine is that I really shouldn't have townread the Jacob wagon after all and feel **** for wanting to.
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
what's your read on me
i'm pushing for an oath lynch. i believe geoni is town.
Geoni
You're doing great!
I kinda like this for shaebae for some reason.
Yes
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
geoni is literally town and i will die before they are lynched honestly
actually vote me if you think he's scum
actually vote me if you think he's scum
Right now 2 people have basically announced their desire to jump on Punchy. As much as I like your confidence about the people you're voting with mog, it still looks like Punchy's about to get a majority vote by a lot of people, I should probably be checking the voting thread more, but I think I have reason to be alarmed.
i didn't join the punchy wagon? and what does 'derpy' in response imply?
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
ok well that's going nowhere so my point stands
- Status
