Mafia TBT Mafia: Renaissance - Game Thread [ENDGAME - Town Wins]

Status
Not open for further replies.
If: Oath is mafia
Mafia: Tae, Shae, Dino?
This probably cements Glow as town, and leaves Shae as mafia because.
A. it seems oath genuinely believed that Shae was going to get modkilled, but it also seemed like they were trying to lynch Punchy. It looks more like a reluctant buss than anything.
B.Tae is mafia, oath appealed to a lot of people, but it seems likely that Oath was directing it towards (someone in the lynch) Tae to get them to flip.
C. Dino. Dino wildcard, you can replace Dino with Locket or even potentially Trundle. Dino only here because they voted Punchy.

However, oaths role has some interesting connotation.
1. Why wasn't I strongkilled night 1.
2. There probably isn't a roleblocker since mafia already has an RB.
3. Why... does mafia have a doc. It seems to imply that there's either a vig or a third party in this game (but that was already implied by the third kill. However, since a vig didn't claim, I think that basically locks in a third party SK as a potential role.

Which leaves us with 3 mafia + 1 tp.
Post automatically merged:

Oh sorry, it formatted that.

I wrote that when the lynch was decided, the one where he flips town is so much less interesting.
 
have to say, i've been town reading most on the shaebae lynch which makes me feel like i should re-evaluate things unless she's mafia too but is that possible?? like wouldn't mafia push harder for someone else if they were both
i'm rly sleepy
 
I don't think the 3rd-party is SK, I think the third kill was oath during night 2.

I think the third party role doesn't have any kill power.
 
have to say, i've been town reading most on the shaebae lynch which makes me feel like i should re-evaluate things unless she's mafia too but is that possible?? like wouldn't mafia push harder for someone else if they were both
i'm rly sleepy

That's what I was thinking about, oath's post towards the end of the day felt more like.

"Please lynch my afk partner over me" and less "I want to ml shae as town"
 
I don't think the 3rd-party is SK, I think the third kill was oath during night 2.

I think the third party role doesn't have any kill power.

Third party killer explains the third kill though.


What third party roles do they tend to use in forum mafia, besides SK and presumably cultist.
 
oh yeah that's true, it'd be in his interests to ask for a shea lynch even if she was mafia also hmmmmm
 
i still think shea is scum but we also kinda have no idea depending on what is going on
Post automatically merged:

all of my reads have been wrong for the most part though so i dont even know at this point
 
"Jack of all Trades: You are a Mafia Jack of all Trades. During the night phase, you have the choice of selecting between three 1-Shot abilities. These include: 1-Shot Roleblock, 1-Shot Doctor Protect, and 1-Shot Strongarm Kill. Each of these abilities may only be used once, and you may only select one ability per night. "

Who says you weren't roleblock day 1 shawo? Also, he has a strongarm kill, isn't that the possible 3rd kill during day 2?
 
if Shawo was rbed day 1 then that means tae would have been roleblocked
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top